After too much research, worrying, being wishy-washy, and not seeing much change in the availability of boards; I decided the best choice was the Asus Sabertooth P67. Seems to have higher quality caps and hardware like the other high-end Asus boards. I don't have an extra PCI/PCIex cards and I don't plan on going SLI anytime soon, so no reason to go Deluxe. Picked up an extra 50mm fan for the Sabertooth motherboard since it was only $5 on the order.
It's ironic how we all sit here and compain about $20 extra for the next motherboard up in the product line, and then drop $80 on filling up our car/trucks with gas. So I spent $219 instead of the $180 I was guessing. Screw it. 🙂