I'll go with hot face and fat body. Butterfaces are fun but there is something about looking into their eyes/face and seeing an injured fish...meh, kills it for me.
We had this chic at work who had a flat out perfect 10 body. But god damn her face, it was like a horse. Nobody would get near her even though she tried to screw everybody in the office and it wasn't subtle, nobody would touch it. She desperately tried to get dates but nobody wanted anything to do with that monster. She was so desperate it was almost sad, especially given she really did have a perfect 10 body.