Honest, hard working people getting screwed over by the system

tcsenter

Lifer
Sep 7, 2001
18,893
544
126
The Korean businessman came with his family to the Seattle area in 1997 under a federal program that promises permanent residency to immigrants who create jobs by investing in small businesses.
WTF?? I wasn't aware that there was a need to entice foreign investment in the United States or attract more immigrants (like the three billion we already have trying to get into the country aren't enough?). Another federal program that has no legitimate value and needs to be sh-t canned.

As for the families that may be deported, that's a tough break and all, because it seems like they may have been good people, but don't let the door hit your ass on the way out!
 

IGBT

Lifer
Jul 16, 2001
17,967
140
106
US immigration policy is based on 1800's era "unsettled continent" . The continent is settled. We now live in a country that has an overloaded infrastructure. We import half our oil, the electrical grid is near blackout/brownout and we now face severe water shortages in our western states. So on top of this overloaded infrastructure why are we still pretending to be an "unsettled continent"?? May be a symptom of a failing political system of three piece suits,toupees and polished teeth whose only concern is getting elected.
 

dfi

Golden Member
Apr 20, 2001
1,213
0
0
I don't believe anyone thinks the US is an "unsettled continent" today, or even 10 years ago. Actually, if you read carefully, it seems like this was a way to stimulate the lagging US economy of the early 90s. This policy was implemented to encourage foreign investment, with citizenship as their reward.

A million dollar total investment, or half a million in stagnant economic areas, and the creation of 10 jobs held by US citizens. And obviously, these new immigrants will have to pay for housing, buy common items, and pay taxes. I don't know about you, but that sounds like a good deal for any local economy. The end of the article also quotes a seattle official who is on the side of the immigrants. And why not? These immigrants have injected millions of dollars into the local economy and created hundreds of jobs. If I was the mayor the seattle, I'd tell the INS to piss off.

Ok, I can understand if the INS wants to investigate whether or not these immigrants actually inject half a million dollars and created 10 jobs. But to retroactively apply modifications (saying that immigrants now need to create their own company instead of merely investing)to previously accepted members is trickery at best. Even worse, it's playing with people's lives. Not to mention what this will do for our economy. The article mentions about 850 immigrants that were allowed through this program. So that's 425.5 million dollars the INS wants to take OUT of the US economy, as well as 8500 newly unemployed US citizens.

Now maybe if the economy was doing great, then I can justify it by saying that the US government is run by lying bastards. But this doesn't even make any sense! They might as well take money and burn it in the streets.

dfi
 

hans007

Lifer
Feb 1, 2000
20,212
18
81
Originally posted by: tcsenter
The Korean businessman came with his family to the Seattle area in 1997 under a federal program that promises permanent residency to immigrants who create jobs by investing in small businesses.
WTF?? I wasn't aware that there was a need to entice foreign investment in the United States or attract more immigrants (like the three billion we already have trying to get into the country aren't enough?). Another federal program that has no legitimate value and needs to be sh-t canned.

As for the families that may be deported, that's a tough break and all, because it seems like they may have been good people, but don't let the door hit your ass on the way out!




do you realize that all foreign investment is good. not to mention if he immigrates, that would actually be domestic investment. do you have a problem with immigrants or something. any investment is more money in the country, and is good in every single way. that immigrant will pay taxes , among other things, and fund our social services, etc.


seeing as he actually had money to invest, it is likely he wont be a total drag on social services and welfare, such as others in this country who were born here and basically dragging our society down and contributing nothing. if anything we should let in more immigrants such as the ones in the article and somehow find a way to deport all the broke ass uneducated non tax paying bums in this country to some other place.


 

NuclearFusi0n

Diamond Member
Jul 2, 2001
7,028
0
0
Originally posted by: hans007
Originally posted by: tcsenter
The Korean businessman came with his family to the Seattle area in 1997 under a federal program that promises permanent residency to immigrants who create jobs by investing in small businesses.
WTF?? I wasn't aware that there was a need to entice foreign investment in the United States or attract more immigrants (like the three billion we already have trying to get into the country aren't enough?). Another federal program that has no legitimate value and needs to be sh-t canned.

As for the families that may be deported, that's a tough break and all, because it seems like they may have been good people, but don't let the door hit your ass on the way out!




do you realize that all foreign investment is good. not to mention if he immigrates, that would actually be domestic investment. do you have a problem with immigrants or something. any investment is more money in the country, and is good in every single way. that immigrant will pay taxes , among other things, and fund our social services, etc.


seeing as he actually had money to invest, it is likely he wont be a total drag on social services and welfare, such as others in this country who were born here and basically dragging our society down and contributing nothing. if anything we should let in more immigrants such as the ones in the article and somehow find a way to deport all the broke ass uneducated non tax paying bums in this country to some other place.

respect++;
:)
 

gopunk

Lifer
Jul 7, 2001
29,239
2
0
seeing as he actually had money to invest, it is likely he wont be a total drag on social services and welfare, such as others in this country who were born here and basically dragging our society down and contributing nothing. if anything we should let in more immigrants such as the ones in the article and somehow find a way to deport all the broke ass uneducated non tax paying bums in this country to some other place.

damn skippy. wish we could trade some of "i live off society, have 3 children and am pregnant with a fourth" citizens for immigrants that actually contribute something to society.
 

Kevin

Diamond Member
Jan 1, 2002
3,995
1
0
The US is considered unsettled because of the vast populations differences. Most of our population is focused around the coastal areas that leave central states with less people. Take a look at this map.
 

iamme

Lifer
Jul 21, 2001
21,058
3
0
Originally posted by: hans007
seeing as he actually had money to invest, it is likely he wont be a total drag on social services and welfare, such as others in this country who were born here and basically dragging our society down and contributing nothing. if anything we should let in more immigrants such as the ones in the article and somehow find a way to deport all the broke ass uneducated non tax paying bums in this country to some other place.

My thoughts exactly.
 

Shelly21

Diamond Member
May 28, 2002
4,111
1
0
Originally posted by: iamme
Originally posted by: hans007
seeing as he actually had money to invest, it is likely he wont be a total drag on social services and welfare, such as others in this country who were born here and basically dragging our society down and contributing nothing. if anything we should let in more immigrants such as the ones in the article and somehow find a way to deport all the broke ass uneducated non tax paying bums in this country to some other place.

My thoughts exactly.

But that would deport a lot of people on welfare which is majority white population. And you know that wouldn't happen...

 

gopunk

Lifer
Jul 7, 2001
29,239
2
0
Originally posted by: Shelly21
Originally posted by: iamme
Originally posted by: hans007
seeing as he actually had money to invest, it is likely he wont be a total drag on social services and welfare, such as others in this country who were born here and basically dragging our society down and contributing nothing. if anything we should let in more immigrants such as the ones in the article and somehow find a way to deport all the broke ass uneducated non tax paying bums in this country to some other place.

My thoughts exactly.

But that would deport a lot of people on welfare which is majority white population. And you know that wouldn't happen...

good lord, is that true? the majority? as in more than 50%?
 

Red Dawn

Elite Member
Jun 4, 2001
57,529
3
0
That said, if they are already here and are contributing (not on welfare) then I believe they should be able to stay.
 

Pepsei

Lifer
Dec 14, 2001
12,895
1
0
A major misconception is there are more blacks getting welfare....

but as far as I know, majority of the welfare people are white....

however, i think blacks on welfare gets more money than whites as a whloe...... someone correct me if i'm wrong....
 

gopunk

Lifer
Jul 7, 2001
29,239
2
0
Originally posted by: Pepsei
A major misconception is there are more blacks getting welfare....

but as far as I know, majority of the welfare people are white....

however, i think blacks on welfare gets more money than whites as a whloe...... someone correct me if i'm wrong....

ah i see... and it all comes clear now.... heh, i thought she was saying that the majority of white people are on welfare.
 

tcsenter

Lifer
Sep 7, 2001
18,893
544
126
The article mentions about 850 immigrants that were allowed through this program. So that's 425.5 million dollars the INS wants to take OUT of the US economy, as well as 8500 newly unemployed US citizens.
The article mentions the program is replete with FRAUD, so not all that money is being put to work as it should be, as I would certainly suspect of WEALTHY IMMIGRANTS who do not come to this country to participate in the American dream, they come to make themselves even wealthier (by creating shell businesses only long enough to satisfy the requirements, most of that money is then funneled through investments that employ nobody). The "jobs" that are created are often filled by family members they help bring over, cousins and nephews and brothers, so no new "net" jobs are created at all.

$500K-$1M in some of these countries is beyond rich, its Bill Gates status, and this is how much they have managed to SAVE, which means they've made far more in their own countries. Again, there are plenty of ways to attract AMERICAN investment to these areas, we don't need more stinking furriners.
But that would deport a lot of people on welfare which is majority white population. And you know that wouldn't happen...
It waffles back and forth every few years, whites make up more than 50% of those on welfare for a few years, then it falls again below 50%.

But that is deliberately cherry picking your numbers. Whites make up a far greater percentage of the population and based on proportionate representation, whites have a far lower rate of welfare participation than others. I'm not sure how this became a race issue. I do believe that American citizens are multi-racial these days.
 

gopunk

Lifer
Jul 7, 2001
29,239
2
0
The article mentions the program is replete with FRAUD, so not all that money is being put to work as it should be, as I would certainly suspect of WEALTHY IMMIGRANTS who do not come to this country to participate in the American dream, they come to make themselves even wealthier (by creating shell businesses only long enough to satisfy the requirements, most of that money is then funneled through investments that employ nobody).

i agree, but obviously they are trying to fix those problems without affecting the legitimate people, so i don't see what your gripe is.


The "jobs" that are created are often filled by family members they help bring over, cousins and nephews and brothers, so no new "net" jobs are created at all.

those people have to spend their money in our economy in order to live.
 

gogeeta13

Diamond Member
Dec 31, 2000
5,721
0
0
Originally posted by: gopunk
Originally posted by: Shelly21
Originally posted by: iamme
Originally posted by: hans007
seeing as he actually had money to invest, it is likely he wont be a total drag on social services and welfare, such as others in this country who were born here and basically dragging our society down and contributing nothing. if anything we should let in more immigrants such as the ones in the article and somehow find a way to deport all the broke ass uneducated non tax paying bums in this country to some other place.

My thoughts exactly.

But that would deport a lot of people on welfare which is majority white population. And you know that wouldn't happen...

good lord, is that true? the majority? as in more than 50%?

Have you ever been to the projects in any of the big cities? they are all mexican and black.....
 

hans007

Lifer
Feb 1, 2000
20,212
18
81
Originally posted by: gogeeta13
Originally posted by: gopunk

Have you ever been to the projects in any of the big cities? they are all mexican and black.....


yes that is true. but there arent that many big cities if you really think about it. most of the middle of the country is not big cities, and most of the middle of the country is white people. though i dont think most white people are poor, there are so many white people, and obviously some of them are poor, that there are still a large number of below poverty line white people.


anyways, even if these people are just trying to get richer, etc. they will be residents of this country and in some form or another the money will help the united states in some way. there is no way these people are taking away from the country, even if all they are doing is bringing all their relatives over and their relatives money, that is still money that will be stored in US banks and invested in US equities. All their relatives presumably will have to pay taxes on their income and whatever capital gains they make from their investments.


not to mention the cashflow into the US as invvestments (if they are just here to make money then they'd make investments, and really who in the US doesnt wanna make money, saying the immigrants are coming over just to make more money is pretty obvious, isnt that the reason all immigrants come to america , to better whatever situation they are already in. why else would someone come to america, just to be american, i really believe people look for the best situation that they can have. )
the money in investments, can be used to fund other investments (as it will be tied up in banks, etc, which can loan it out to other people who can start businesses with it, etc). its an economic cycle. either way i dont see how having rich immigrants come over hurts the country at all. possibly if they were dirt poor and lazy, which is very rare in immigrants, but yeah the argument that they are somehow just leeching off the country is illogical.