Hezbollah prisoners freed in exchange for dead Israeli soldiers

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

jman19

Lifer
Nov 3, 2000
11,225
664
126
Originally posted by: Common Courtesy
Originally posted by: Marlin1975
I don't see why they did this. If they want to be fair kill the prisoners and then swap bodies.
At the time, Israel may not have known that their people were dead.

Because they were returned dead (how long, who knows) it may affect future swaps.
Much may determine when and how they died.

I find this story to be completely disgusting, but I do believe Israel knew this already, as I remember reading about this a few weeks ago. They went through with the swap expecting to receive dead bodies :(
 

Fern

Elite Member
Sep 30, 2003
26,907
174
106
Originally posted by: jman19
Originally posted by: Common Courtesy
Originally posted by: Marlin1975
I don't see why they did this. If they want to be fair kill the prisoners and then swap bodies.
At the time, Israel may not have known that their people were dead.

Because they were returned dead (how long, who knows) it may affect future swaps.
Much may determine when and how they died.

I find this story to be completely disgusting, but I do believe Israel knew this already, as I remember reading about this a few weeks ago. They went through with the swap expecting to receive dead bodies :(

I think that was a different swap. It was the one with the guy who murdered a little kid etc.

Fern
 

jman19

Lifer
Nov 3, 2000
11,225
664
126
Originally posted by: Fern
Originally posted by: jman19
Originally posted by: Common Courtesy
Originally posted by: Marlin1975
I don't see why they did this. If they want to be fair kill the prisoners and then swap bodies.
At the time, Israel may not have known that their people were dead.

Because they were returned dead (how long, who knows) it may affect future swaps.
Much may determine when and how they died.

I find this story to be completely disgusting, but I do believe Israel knew this already, as I remember reading about this a few weeks ago. They went through with the swap expecting to receive dead bodies :(

I think that was a different swap. It was the one with the guy who murdered a little kid etc.

Fern

I'm pretty sure this is the same thing. I remember hearing about the little kid getting killed, and another dying from her mother smothering her while trying to protect her. Not sure what the source was, but this has been out for at least a week now. It's just back in the news because the swap just took place.
 

jman19

Lifer
Nov 3, 2000
11,225
664
126
Originally posted by: Fern
^ Yeah, you're right. My bad :eek:

Fern

No worries.

To be honest, even though I had read this before, I was pretty furious to read about this, especially to hear that the guy mentioned above was lauded upon his return, despite the fact he is just a cold blooded murdered.
 

Dari

Lifer
Oct 25, 2002
17,133
38
91
The problem with these threads is that on the Israeli side you have individuals, lives, and characters. But on the arab side you have numbers and a defense of killing civilians. It'll never balance out because the lives are not equal.
 
Jun 26, 2007
11,925
2
0
Originally posted by: ProfJohn
This story just makes me sick.

Hezbollah crosses the boarder and attacks a group of Israeli soldiers taking two of them captive. Then for TWO years they refuse to allow anyone access to them and allow no news of their fates. Then they negotiate the release of some prisoners and return the bodies to Israel.

Just makes me sick. Every little thing Israel does is looked at with a microscope meanwhile Hezbollah is holding the bodies of two people and refuses to let any information about them out at all.


AP story

It might make you sick because you are a retarded ignoramus, but the dead bodies are more worth to the Jews than the live bodies are to the Muslims.

Actually, from you, that is to be expected.

You NEVER get ANYTHING beyond your own retarded thoughts.
 
Jun 26, 2007
11,925
2
0
Originally posted by: Marlin1975
I don't see why they did this. If they want to be fair kill the prisoners and then swap bodies.

Mostly because their religion, if you understood it, you'd understand why killing them in exchange would not be a good idea for the ones exchanged for their bodies, they would then be the cause of murder.

The Jewish religion is much more straight forward than the Christian where you can just pretend it's whatever you want to and interpret things as you see fit for whatever you've done.
 
Jun 26, 2007
11,925
2
0
Originally posted by: dphantom
Originally posted by: Marlin1975
I don't see why they did this. If they want to be fair kill the prisoners and then swap bodies.

Why take terrorists prisoners in the first place? Just shoot them.

How many men have you killed? In what way have you ever been involved in a situation like this? Do you understand anything at all about the Judaism?

I'll answer that for your dumb arse... NO!
 
Jun 26, 2007
11,925
2
0
Originally posted by: Lemon law
Originally posted by: ProfJohn
This story just makes me sick.

Hezbollah crosses the boarder and attacks a group of Israeli soldiers taking two of them captive. Then for TWO years they refuse to allow anyone access to them and allow no news of their fates. Then they negotiate the release of some prisoners and return the bodies to Israel.

Just makes me sick. Every little thing Israel does is looked at with a microscope meanwhile Hezbollah is holding the bodies of two people and refuses to let any information about them out at all.


AP story
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The ever delusional PJ is somewhat correct, Hezbollah is a group of rascals. What he denies is that the Israeli army is regarded by many to be an equally morally degenerate set of rascals.

And if you get to that point of being open minded, one can see the current Israeli v. Palestinians and Arabs conflict as an infinitely large set of wrong on both sides, and each and every days, both sides stack up more wrongs until it becomes impossible to find anyone who is right. And all sides justify their evil on the fact that the other side is also evil.

At a certain point, one has to say this stupidity leads no where, but one has to be a better person than PJ to realize it.

You're fucking retarded "a group of rascals".

Insanity explained, someone should collect your quotes and put them in a book and name it "thoughts of a complete retard".

You're not open minded, you are not middle ground, you just hate people more than most others do and for some reason you love child rapists and killers who are Muslim while hating them who fight them?

You're somewhat of a pedopheliac and pedokiller admirer? I just don't get it, you seem to embrace the most evil of all people in this world while hating the people who fight them.

I don't know how you can get "fighting evil" out of your definitions, i really really really don't get it.

But maybe children and especially pre-teen girls are evil in your book.
 

Lemon law

Lifer
Nov 6, 2005
20,984
3
0
Ya, I always ask ball less Brits about terrorism. Back when you Brits had the Palestinian mandate, two future Israeli PM's, Begin and Mier blew up the King David Hotel, killing
a bunch of Brits, and you passed it by.

That crap has nothing to do with Judaism, it was simply future State sponsored terrorism. And once Israel became a State, they found State sponsored terrorism was so much better.
 

EagleKeeper

Discussion Club Moderator<br>Elite Member
Staff member
Oct 30, 2000
42,589
5
0
Originally posted by: Lemon law
Ya, I always ask ball less Brits about terrorism. Back when you Brits had the Palestinian mandate, two future Israeli PM's, Begin and Mier blew up the King David Hotel, killing
a bunch of Brits, and you passed it by.

That crap has nothing to do with Judaism, it was simply future State sponsored terrorism. And once Israel became a State, they found State sponsored terrorism was so much better.

And the fact that the British were biased toward the Arabs had nothing to due with it.
The Jews had ended up in a war agasint those that were supposed to govern them. Similar to 200 years previous on another continent.
The Jew alerted the British military that the hotel was going to be bombed. The Brits did nothing/ignored the warning.
 
Jun 26, 2007
11,925
2
0
Originally posted by: Lemon law
Ya, I always ask ball less Brits about terrorism. Back when you Brits had the Palestinian mandate, two future Israeli PM's, Begin and Mier blew up the King David Hotel, killing
a bunch of Brits, and you passed it by.

That crap has nothing to do with Judaism, it was simply future State sponsored terrorism. And once Israel became a State, they found State sponsored terrorism was so much better.

Definently, the London bombings didn't hurt us, didn't cause us to panic and invade... well no one, but we, as well as the entire earth realized and supported the efforts made in Afghanistan, well except you then, child rapist embracer as you are you thought that was a bad fucking idea.

You don't know anything about it and it's fucking ridiculous to hear an ant whine, get a fucking grip you piece of shit and stop defending these inherently abhorrent groups and maybe, maybe, if you educated yourself on the matter and responded with some kind of knowledge, i wouldn't think you are pro-child-rape.

How about that you fucking moron?

It has everything to do with Judaism, the bodies have to be returned to sacred ground, alive or dead they mean just as much to any Jew.

But you don't get that either because unilke me, you don't get any culture besides the culture of your own which is a culture of pure hatred of anyone who disagrees with your dum arse.

Most of your posts are retarded, those who are not are filled with praise for the most evil groups in this world, i don't respect you and i never will.

Fuck off twat.
 

sapiens74

Platinum Member
Jan 14, 2004
2,162
0
0
I'm just waiting for God to sort it out


They both claim he will destroy the other.......


/end sarcasm
 

nick1985

Lifer
Dec 29, 2002
27,153
6
81
Originally posted by: JohnOfSheffield
Originally posted by: Lemon law
Ya, I always ask ball less Brits about terrorism. Back when you Brits had the Palestinian mandate, two future Israeli PM's, Begin and Mier blew up the King David Hotel, killing
a bunch of Brits, and you passed it by.

That crap has nothing to do with Judaism, it was simply future State sponsored terrorism. And once Israel became a State, they found State sponsored terrorism was so much better.

Definently, the London bombings didn't hurt us, didn't cause us to panic and invade... well no one, but we, as well as the entire earth realized and supported the efforts made in Afghanistan, well except you then, child rapist embracer as you are you thought that was a bad fucking idea.

You don't know anything about it and it's fucking ridiculous to hear an ant whine, get a fucking grip you piece of shit and stop defending these inherently abhorrent groups and maybe, maybe, if you educated yourself on the matter and responded with some kind of knowledge, i wouldn't think you are pro-child-rape.

How about that you fucking moron?

It has everything to do with Judaism, the bodies have to be returned to sacred ground, alive or dead they mean just as much to any Jew.

But you don't get that either because unilke me, you don't get any culture besides the culture of your own which is a culture of pure hatred of anyone who disagrees with your dum arse.

Most of your posts are retarded, those who are not are filled with praise for the most evil groups in this world, i don't respect you and i never will.

Fuck off twat.

OK thats just too funny. :thumbsup:
 
Jun 26, 2007
11,925
2
0
Originally posted by: nick1985
Originally posted by: JohnOfSheffield
Originally posted by: Lemon law
Ya, I always ask ball less Brits about terrorism. Back when you Brits had the Palestinian mandate, two future Israeli PM's, Begin and Mier blew up the King David Hotel, killing
a bunch of Brits, and you passed it by.

That crap has nothing to do with Judaism, it was simply future State sponsored terrorism. And once Israel became a State, they found State sponsored terrorism was so much better.

Definently, the London bombings didn't hurt us, didn't cause us to panic and invade... well no one, but we, as well as the entire earth realized and supported the efforts made in Afghanistan, well except you then, child rapist embracer as you are you thought that was a bad fucking idea.

You don't know anything about it and it's fucking ridiculous to hear an ant whine, get a fucking grip you piece of shit and stop defending these inherently abhorrent groups and maybe, maybe, if you educated yourself on the matter and responded with some kind of knowledge, i wouldn't think you are pro-child-rape.

How about that you fucking moron?

It has everything to do with Judaism, the bodies have to be returned to sacred ground, alive or dead they mean just as much to any Jew.

But you don't get that either because unilke me, you don't get any culture besides the culture of your own which is a culture of pure hatred of anyone who disagrees with your dum arse.

Most of your posts are retarded, those who are not are filled with praise for the most evil groups in this world, i don't respect you and i never will.

Fuck off twat.

OK thats just too funny. :thumbsup:

Actually, this fucked up POS has praised the Talibans more than once, that just isn't funny, it's fucking sick.
 

Lemon law

Lifer
Nov 6, 2005
20,984
3
0
The JOS delusions is that I care about your opinions or want your respect. Far from praising evil groups in the world, I hope help let others be open minded enough to see they are no more or less evil than the groups you champion.

And excuse me, my father is technically a jew, I grew up surrounded by jews, many of my friends were and still are jews, and they are people first, and being jewish or non jewish has very little to do with their attitudes. People are people are people the world around. And when some prig like you comes in and tells anyone to do it your way or else, its not rocket science to figure out you will end up being counter productive.

But as an American, I am more worried about stopping the same stupidity in my country. You Brits just make a good negative example to point to. Your ancestors who built up your former empire did not do it by raw force alone, they did it with a smarter strategy of gradual conversion.
 

kylebisme

Diamond Member
Mar 25, 2000
9,396
0
0
Originally posted by: Common Courtesy
Originally posted by: Lemon law
Ya, I always ask ball less Brits about terrorism. Back when you Brits had the Palestinian mandate, two future Israeli PM's, Begin and Mier blew up the King David Hotel, killing
a bunch of Brits, and you passed it by.

That crap has nothing to do with Judaism, it was simply future State sponsored terrorism. And once Israel became a State, they found State sponsored terrorism was so much better.

And the fact that the British were biased toward the Arabs had nothing to due with it.
The Jews had ended up in a war agasint those that were supposed to govern them. Similar to 200 years previous on another continent.
If the British were biased towards the Arabs, why did they allow any Zionists to immigrate the region at all, let alone with the promise of being able to found their own ethnic nationalist state there in Arab lands?

Originally posted by: Common Courtesy
The Jew alerted the British military that the hotel was going to be bombed. The Brits did nothing/ignored the warning.
Or so Begin claimed anyway. Do you know of any proof of that claim, or are you just taking a terroritst at his word?
 

nick1985

Lifer
Dec 29, 2002
27,153
6
81
Originally posted by: Lemon law
The JOS delusions is that I care about your opinions or want your respect. Far from praising evil groups in the world, I hope help let others be open minded enough to see they are no more or less evil than the groups you champion.

Dont be completely retarded lemon law. If you honestly think that the USA and Britain are no less evil than the Taliban, then you are just fucking stupid as all hell. Plain and simple. Open minded my ass, twat.
 

magomago

Lifer
Sep 28, 2002
10,973
14
76
Originally posted by: yllus
Originally posted by: ElFenix
where is the arab ghandi or MLK?

It's actually starting to happen. It just can't happen fast enough.

The tide begins to turn: Al-Qaeda founders, militants and sympathizers are publicly denouncing terrorism

This past November, Noman Benotman went public with his own criticism of al-Qaeda in an open letter to Zawahiri, absorbed and well-received, he says, by the jihadist leaders in Tripoli.

In the letter, Benotman recalled his Kandahar warnings and called on al-Qaeda to end all operations in Arab countries and in the West. The citizens of Western countries were blameless and should not be the target of terrorist attacks, argued Benotman, his refined English accent, smart suit, trimmed beard and easygoing demeanour making it hard to imagine that he was once on the front lines in Afghanistan.

Although Benotman's public rebuke of al-Qaeda went unnoticed in the United States and Canada, it received wide attention in the Arabic press. In repudiating al-Qaeda, [ex-leader of the militant Libyan Islamic Fighting Group Noman] Benotman was adding his voice to a rising tide of anger in the Islamic world toward al-Qaeda and its affiliates, whose victims since September 11 have mostly been fellow Muslims.

Significantly, he was also joining a larger group of religious scholars, former fighters and militants who had once had great influence over Al Qaeda's leaders, and who -- alarmed by the targeting of civilians in the West, the senseless killings in Muslim countries and al-Qaeda's barbaric tactics in Iraq --have turned against the organization, many just in the past year.
I'm not so sure what Al Qaeda has to do with this issue which involves Lebanon, Palestine and Israel.

That said, I think this serves as wonderful PR for the Israeli government. the amount of press generated for them that makes them seem "dovish" and "trying hard to achieve piece" because they traded a murder for remains of dead soldiers is generous. The fact that you have articles that talk about how people celebrated the release of a murder (and honestly I do'nt even know about the details. I'll give give the benefit of the dobut) only makes the Israeli government look better. We'll see seeing posts about "inhuman arabs" for a while as people refer to celebration of the return of a murder, etc.

The good I see in this is simple: it is dialogue. even if it is small, it happens. That is something I'll be happy for no matter what. If both sides believed that the other indeed MUST be destroyed at no cost, then something like this would have never happened.
 

ProfJohn

Lifer
Jul 28, 2006
18,161
7
0
Originally posted by: Aimster
Originally posted by: ProfJohn
This story just makes me sick.

Hezbollah crosses the boarder and attacks a group of Israeli soldiers taking two of them captive. Then for TWO years they refuse to allow anyone access to them and allow no news of their fates. Then they negotiate the release of some prisoners and return the bodies to Israel.

Just makes me sick. Every little thing Israel does is looked at with a microscope meanwhile Hezbollah is holding the bodies of two people and refuses to let any information about them out at all.


AP story
So when Israeli soldiers crossed the border and killed Hezbollah fighters it was ok but when Hezbollah did it , just disgusting.
Had Hezbollah never attacked these soldiers Israel would have never invaded Lebanon.
 

Aimster

Lifer
Jan 5, 2003
16,129
2
0
Originally posted by: ProfJohn
Originally posted by: Aimster
Originally posted by: ProfJohn
This story just makes me sick.

Hezbollah crosses the boarder and attacks a group of Israeli soldiers taking two of them captive. Then for TWO years they refuse to allow anyone access to them and allow no news of their fates. Then they negotiate the release of some prisoners and return the bodies to Israel.

Just makes me sick. Every little thing Israel does is looked at with a microscope meanwhile Hezbollah is holding the bodies of two people and refuses to let any information about them out at all.


AP story
So when Israeli soldiers crossed the border and killed Hezbollah fighters it was ok but when Hezbollah did it , just disgusting.
Had Hezbollah never attacked these soldiers Israel would have never invaded Lebanon.

Had Israel not attacked Hezbollah, Hezbollah would not have had a reason to attack Israeli soldiers.

Want to go back and forth all day?
 

EagleKeeper

Discussion Club Moderator<br>Elite Member
Staff member
Oct 30, 2000
42,589
5
0
Originally posted by: TheSnowman
Originally posted by: Common Courtesy
Originally posted by: Lemon law
Ya, I always ask ball less Brits about terrorism. Back when you Brits had the Palestinian mandate, two future Israeli PM's, Begin and Mier blew up the King David Hotel, killing
a bunch of Brits, and you passed it by.

That crap has nothing to do with Judaism, it was simply future State sponsored terrorism. And once Israel became a State, they found State sponsored terrorism was so much better.

And the fact that the British were biased toward the Arabs had nothing to due with it.
The Jews had ended up in a war agasint those that were supposed to govern them. Similar to 200 years previous on another continent.
If the British were biased towards the Arabs, why did they allow any Zionists to immigrate the region at all, let alone with the promise of being able to found their own ethnic nationalist state there in Arab lands?

Originally posted by: Common Courtesy
The Jew alerted the British military that the hotel was going to be bombed. The Brits did nothing/ignored the warning.
Or so Begin claimed anyway. Do you know of any proof of that claim, or are you just taking a terroritst at his word?

1)The Saudis officially are friends of the West - yet they allow/support Wabis from within the royal family. Orders came downtotheBritish military to hinderthe Zionist movement as much as possible.

2)When Hamas signed the truce with Israel last month, you kept insisting on proof that they signed a truce. Any information that was published, you refused to accept and/or ignored.
I am not going to waste any effort researching what information that may be available regarding the warning on the King David; it wil also be refuted/denied/ignored.

Those that are fully anti Israel/Jews // pro-Palestinian/Arab are unwilling to look at the fact that Arab/Muslim controlled/guided Palestinians do not want a true peace, but an excuse for publicity to show how they are the oppressed; anything for sympathy.
 

jamesall

Member
Apr 29, 2008
27
0
0
Someone need to get ripped of these terrorist group, Hezbollah and Hamas.

The sick part is Isreal exchange these terrorist for two bodies. The the most sickest part is these terrorist who murder civilians because they were jews are given Hero status, even the guy who kill the father in front of his 4-year-old daughter, then killing the little girl by smashing her skull with his rifle butt. What make this 16 year old terrorist do it? Hezbollah indoctrination. This is the same mind set that Hamas and Al Qeada have. Indoctrinate the youth, strap them with bombs, and target and murder as many innocent civilians as possible.