OK so now the power supply refuses to turn on?
Remove everything(to be sure nothing gets fried)
Plug the power supply ATX connector to the motherboard.
Remove ALL those little connectors that show hard drive LED, power LED etc etc.
Connect ONLY the power switch connector to the little pins.
Plug the power supply MAIN cable into a different wall outlet.(dont use a power strip, just incase it is bad)
Now press the the power button.. does the power supply fan turn on?
If yes... then the problem could have been the power strip, wall outlet, shorted device, incorrect power switch connector, etc.
If it did NOT turn on, then remove the little connector for the power switch from the motherboard, and use a screw driver, or similar tool to CONNECT those little pins for 1-2 secs, did this turn the power supply on?
If this screw driver trick worked then your power switch is bad.
If none of this worked then either the power supply is bad, or the mainboard, and since you have 2 mainboards, you can test them both. If it still won't work then it is the power supply.
Good Luck...