Help choose a server board

NightFalcon

Senior member
May 22, 2004
218
0
0
Hi guys, even though I thought I was already past this stage, I once again find myself questioning the decision since it was made a few months ago. So here's the deal... I'm building a server for myself, nothing too advanced, but not cheap either. The current cost as I estimate it will be around $2500.

The problem I have with my motherboard choice is this - my hard drive setup will be a RAID 5, powered by the Broadcom RAIDCore controller which is a PCI-X 133MHz interface. Of course I'd like to get a motherboard that supports this, but it seems that motherboards from companies like Supermicro (my first choice) only add 133MHz after the $350 range. My question is this, how much of a performance drop would I see if I use a 133MHz capable card in a 66MHz slot?

Also, there are a few boards that I have found which do have 133MHz PCI-X slots, but they aren't really from companies known for their server boards - ASUS for example. I love that company, and all my workstations use their boards, but what are they like for a server.

For some practical examples, if you had to choose between the Supermicro X6DVL-EG board and the ASUS NCLV-D, which one would you go with? Both are in the $250 price range, but Supermicro is much better known for their server boards then ASUS is. On the other hand, ASUS does support 133MHz PCI-X slot, whereas Supermicro only has 2 66MHz slots.

Any advice?
 
Nov 11, 2004
10,855
0
0
I would personally take the Asus. I've had a great experience with their PC-DL (Something of the likes.) board and it was great.
 

NightFalcon

Senior member
May 22, 2004
218
0
0
What about in terms of the PCI-X speed? Will the difference between 133MHz and 66MHz be apparent? Obviously the theoretical maximum bandwidth of 133 is twice that of 66, but will an SATA RAID 5 array (even with 8 drives which I may have later on) be able to reach those rates, or will it be limited to less then 500MB/s just by the hard drives themselves?