<< I caution everybody from blasting the philosophy behind our health care system. It is not broken and, for that matter, a philosophy in itself cannot be "broken". Health care for all, regardless of whether you are rich or poor is something that is affordable and can produce great results. However, the implementation of it sucks. It needs money bad, and the money is definitely there. A lot of governments in Canada will use the state of the health care system to push their mandate to privatize it. Don't buy their rhetoric. I wouldn't be surprised if their pockets are lined by very wealthy lobbyists who would like to open up shop in Canada. >>
GL:
It all boils down to money. You either get taxed to death to pay for a socialized system, or you pay the insurance companies for a privatized system. Take your pick. Regardless, somebody's getting rich. It is idealistic to think that socialized health care will ever work. This is typical socialist thinking. But what the socialist fails to recognize, time and again, is that their ideals run counter to reality. Socialism, in any form, just doesn't work. It's not the type of system rational people want to live under. The 20th century alone is replete with examples of failed social experiments.
Have you ever asked yourself why the health care system in The United States is arguably the best in the world? It's because our societal system breeds healthy competition. And competition has the propensity to bring out the best in people. It's literally survival of the fittest. It spurs us on to be creative and independent. The alternative is to be dependent upon a central governing body; which history shows is just flat out dangerous. There is no accountability or sanctions built into a centralized system. Not to mention that creativity atrophies in such a system.
Does the U.S. system have problems? You bet it does! And much of it is because of the greedy bastards in the insurance industry, and the administrations of health care facilities. But I'd much rather deal with that, and know where my money is going, than deal with the greedy bastards in a centralized system who could be spending my tax dollars on Lord knows what.
To address your specific quote that <<a philosophy in itself cannot be "broken">>, I counter with, "Yes it can". It's broken from my frame of reference. It's broken from the frame of reference of reality. In a Utopian society? Sure. But we don't live in a Utopian society. That's the reality. Should we attempt to create a Utopian society? No. It goes against human nature as human nature exists now. A thousand years from now? Who knows, but I doubt it.
Also, as far as your quote, <<Health care for all, regardless of whether you are rich or poor is something that is affordable and can produce great results.>>, is concerned, please site where in the world this is being realized on a scale of quality that the U.S. provides. I have spoken with people from Italy, England, Romania, Ukraine, China, Iraq, Iran, Algeria . . . my occupation places me in contact with many foreigners, about this very subject. Every single one of them that came from a socialized health care system tells me how piss-poor it is when compared to the U.S. system. Coincidence? I don't think so.