- Oct 9, 1999
- 17,627
- 5
- 81
I'm getting my first widescreen HDTV in about a month. After doing some measuring I found out I'm gonna have to stick with a 42" widescreen set, can't really go any larger.
I'm narrowed down between two right now:
Toshiba 42H82
PRO'S
-Large internet "fan" base...easy to find information on things such as calibration
-720p support (upconverts to 1080i) which is good for the upcoming 720p Xbox games
-TOshiba is known for their excellent color fidelity
CON'S
-$300 more than the Samsung
-upconverts 480p (DVD) signals to 540p which results in some resolution loss, hard to notice in real world apps but if you put up an AVIA test screen its clearly visible
--
Samsung HCM4216W
PRO'S
-Cheap price
-I am extremely happy with my samsung computer monitor that i've had for 3 years (the 950p) and still works like new, so Samsung is pretty good in my books.
-Doesn't alter the 480p signal...better resolution technically
-I just found the service manual (for setting the 64 point manual convergence anyway) on the net which saves me having to go and buy (let alone find) a service manual
-Extremely small footprint (only 18 inches deep) and only 108 pounds
-Seemed to have a very nice picture even when viewing on the sh*t source in the store with a completely uncalibrated set
CON'S
-Won't accept a 720p signal, just 1080i. Therefore I'd be stuck running my xbox games in 480p even if they support 720p
-Not as big of a "fan" base on the net
----------
I'm in a very tough dilemma here. Argh....
DOes anyone own these sets? and if not, what set do you own and how do you like it? Also post your experiences with calibrating it and doing manual convergence/geometry adjustments/etc. If you haven't done any of this, it's pretty highly recommended. The quality of the picture can literally increase 10-fold if you spend a couple hours with your set.
I'm narrowed down between two right now:
Toshiba 42H82
PRO'S
-Large internet "fan" base...easy to find information on things such as calibration
-720p support (upconverts to 1080i) which is good for the upcoming 720p Xbox games
-TOshiba is known for their excellent color fidelity
CON'S
-$300 more than the Samsung
-upconverts 480p (DVD) signals to 540p which results in some resolution loss, hard to notice in real world apps but if you put up an AVIA test screen its clearly visible
--
Samsung HCM4216W
PRO'S
-Cheap price
-I am extremely happy with my samsung computer monitor that i've had for 3 years (the 950p) and still works like new, so Samsung is pretty good in my books.
-Doesn't alter the 480p signal...better resolution technically
-I just found the service manual (for setting the 64 point manual convergence anyway) on the net which saves me having to go and buy (let alone find) a service manual
-Extremely small footprint (only 18 inches deep) and only 108 pounds
-Seemed to have a very nice picture even when viewing on the sh*t source in the store with a completely uncalibrated set
CON'S
-Won't accept a 720p signal, just 1080i. Therefore I'd be stuck running my xbox games in 480p even if they support 720p
-Not as big of a "fan" base on the net
----------
I'm in a very tough dilemma here. Argh....
DOes anyone own these sets? and if not, what set do you own and how do you like it? Also post your experiences with calibrating it and doing manual convergence/geometry adjustments/etc. If you haven't done any of this, it's pretty highly recommended. The quality of the picture can literally increase 10-fold if you spend a couple hours with your set.