Having problems with audio through HDMI

SantiClaws

Senior member
Sep 2, 2000
439
1
81
I have a TV set up as a second monitor and it is connected to my PC via HDMI. I have a Xonar DS sound card. When I extend my display to the second monitor, the video comes through fine but sometimes the audio doesn't transfer over and still plays on my PC. I sometimes was successful by moving the display to a single monitor and then doing it again, but sometimes not. It's driving me crazy, there's probably some setting that needs to be changed, but I have no clue what it is and if that's the case, why does it work sometimes?

Any ideas? Thanks
 

BonzaiDuck

Lifer
Jun 30, 2004
16,665
2,039
126
I have a TV set up as a second monitor and it is connected to my PC via HDMI. I have a Xonar DS sound card. When I extend my display to the second monitor, the video comes through fine but sometimes the audio doesn't transfer over and still plays on my PC. I sometimes was successful by moving the display to a single monitor and then doing it again, but sometimes not. It's driving me crazy, there's probably some setting that needs to be changed, but I have no clue what it is and if that's the case, why does it work sometimes?

Any ideas? Thanks

I think you're going through frustrations similar to mine -- trying to integrate an Onkyo AV/Receiver with HDMI passthrough to an HDTV -- with my PC. In "Control-panel->Sound" you should find all the sound devices on your system listed for which drivers are installed. Windows will recognize both digital and analog devices. Your PC speakers (I have a Logitech Z640 5.1 system with subwoofer) are analog -- as I can see from the ports on that Xonar DS which I found at the Egg after reading your post.

HDMI on the other hand, is digital." There may be several issues that need to be cleared up which overlap substantively per the problems you are having and the problems I am having.

This is why some here have remarked that HTPC-duty is best left to a dedicated PC for that purpose, while I instead have elected to make it only part of my PC's usage.

The easiest way to resolve this would be to use one, single speaker system and sound configuration for everything. For me, this means less integration with my Onkyo/Home-theater system, and a subwoofer and center speaker on the opposite side of the room from where it should be -- unless I move my multi-use computer from my desk to that side of the room.

I can get stellar "integration" and surround-sound through the ONkyo -- IF -- IF -- I choose to leave the receiver turned on all the time and relegate analog-audio and the computer speakers to "communications device" status while the Onkyo is "default."

We're going to get this resolved, sooner or later, as some people wearing guru-halos respond to your thread, my thread "Switching between speaker systems" (or something similar), or both.

There are immediate options: turn off HDMI audio, and allow the sound card to provide all sound -- whether "windows sounds," or TV audio -- is just one.

Are you using Media Center to watch TV? Because every time you change from one speaker system to another, you need to run "Tasks->General->Media Center-set-up->Set up speakers."

It ain't easy . . . . unless we can find more details and a way to resolve this that doesn't require a thousand mouse-clicks, "speaker tests" and other steps . . .
 

SantiClaws

Senior member
Sep 2, 2000
439
1
81
Not using WMC. My PC speakers are indeed analog, a Logitech 5.1 system, the model number of which I can't remember. Using one speaker system for both is really not much of an option given the room configuration. Ugh. The video card, by the way, is an MSI 5850.

Several suggestions here, I haven't tried, I'll give them a go when I have a chance.

http://en.kioskea.net/forum/affich-110196-no-sound-on-lcd-tv-desktop-hdmi-connection
 
Last edited:

BonzaiDuck

Lifer
Jun 30, 2004
16,665
2,039
126
Not using WMC. My PC speakers are indeed analog, a Logitech 5.1 system, the model number of which I can't remember. Using one speaker system for both is really not much of an option given the room configuration. Ugh. The video card, by the way, is an MSI 5850.

Several suggestions here, I haven't tried, I'll give them a go when I have a chance.

http://en.kioskea.net/forum/affich-110196-no-sound-on-lcd-tv-desktop-hdmi-connection

You may find this useful, but I can't confirm yet. I spoke to a rep at Cables-to-Go. Here's the text I'm posting in other related threads. Point being -- better to use a single sound card, onboard sound, etc. than enable drivers for graphics HD (in my case nVidia) as well as another sound hardware (like my onboard RealTek). Here it is:

OK . . . Here's a solution I think may work.

Here -- I'm speaking about my own hardware, but this may be useful to someone else who posted this problem. I'm adding post to his thread and mine as well.

Assume that "simple is best" and that RealTek analog 5.1 and digital audio output (RealTek) driven by same or compatible drivers. Therefore -- eliminate the nVidia audio thru HDMI, and use SP/DIF cable to connect onboard sound to the AV/Receiver. I cannot see why this will not work -- but it's just an extra $40 cable. Inputs to the AV/Receiver can be reassigned.

I cannot confirm this yet, but I contacted a Cables-to-Go rep (now called C2G), who was only concerned about ability to disable computer's HDMI audio. But like Dylan says in "highway 61" -- This can be very easily done . . . out there on Hi-way . . . sixty-one! . . "

Comment? encouragement? Whatever?
 

SantiClaws

Senior member
Sep 2, 2000
439
1
81
The problem for me would be that I don't run the cable from the PC to a receiver but straight to the TV, which doesn't have an SP/DIF input. I do have a receiver connected to the TV, but it is old and doesn't have an SP/DIF input, either. Even if I did have an SP/DIF input on the TV, the SP/DIF output on the soundcard is in use for the speakers, so it would not really be of much help.

You may want to also consider getting a dedicated soundcard for your PC; I've heard of all sorts of issues related to RealTek and its drivers.
 

SantiClaws

Senior member
Sep 2, 2000
439
1
81
Well, I solved my problem to some extent. The issue was only occurring with VLC Media Player. When I use different software for the same media file, no problems.
 

BonzaiDuck

Lifer
Jun 30, 2004
16,665
2,039
126
Well, I solved my problem to some extent. The issue was only occurring with VLC Media Player. When I use different software for the same media file, no problems.

Another thing I discovered with the gfx-card GTX 570 HDMI sound drivers . . . Suddenly, everything works and configures more easily after unchecking "Allow applications to take exclusive control" of the sound channel.

Still waiting to get the digital coax cable, and now my SiliconDust suddenly doesnt' want to provide the premium HD channels. So I'm going through the entire rigamarole when I first set it up . . .

Don't need these complications when trying to sort out audio . . .

FREAKIN' JACK VALENTI, MEDIA-PROTECTION NAZIS, and HDCP . . . *$#!%%*^ IT!
 

BonzaiDuck

Lifer
Jun 30, 2004
16,665
2,039
126
Well, I solved my problem to some extent. The issue was only occurring with VLC Media Player. When I use different software for the same media file, no problems.

So . . .. not a hardware or handshaking problem per se . . . just this "VLC Media Player" thing of yours . . .

I got my problem solved, though. Almost as good as it gets. Now -- what to do with the Logitech Z640 5.1 "analog" 3.5mm-plugs speaker system?