• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Guy Fieri's new NY restaurant is getting murdered by the critics

Page 6 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
"Guy" Fiero responds to zero stars review:

I lolled:

http://eater.com/archives/2012/11/15/watch-guy-fieri-respond-to-nyt-zerostar-review.php

fieri-nyt.jpg
 
I get that it's a tourist trap and designed to be that way. What I hate, HATE, coming out of a restauranteur's mouth, though, is the idea that his restaurant needs to work out its lumps over the first few months.

FUCK. NO. PERIOD. You open, you do it right. Last I checked, I'm not at a soft opening if I'm paying full menu price and picking up my own bar tab. That shit better be ready to go day 1, and as good that day as it is a year later. I just don't understand why I'm supposed to lower my standards because I'm giving you a shot early on. That's not how you win repeat business. But again, regulars aren't what Fieri is going for with this place.
 
Trust me man, I've watched probably over a hundred episodes of Triple Ds, some of them multiple times and he definitely does it, though not in every episode. Plus its the whole shtick; the stupid hair, the shades backwards on his neck (total douchebag maneuver), and his overall awesomer-than-thou demeanor. So obnoxious. Richman does not have any of that, at least from the handful of episodes I've seen.

The wife won't even let me watch the show without my headphones on if she is in the room because she finds him so obnoxious. 😀

KT

Trust me I have eaten at his restaurants in California and I will tell you they are pretty damn good for the type of food they serve.

It`s really too bad your wife has no tolerance for the finer things in life.....
 
Trust me man, I've watched probably over a hundred episodes of Triple Ds, some of them multiple times and he definitely does it, though not in every episode. Plus its the whole shtick; the stupid hair, the shades backwards on his neck (total douchebag maneuver), and his overall awesomer-than-thou demeanor. So obnoxious. Richman does not have any of that, at least from the handful of episodes I've seen.

The wife won't even let me watch the show without my headphones on if she is in the room because she finds him so obnoxious. 😀

KT

if you find him so obnoxious/irritating/duschebaginess why have you watched his show over 100 times?

I have never met him but i know the owners of the Lauer-Krauts and he did a show at their place. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KO_YmBF5hf4

they loved him and the crew. he was polite, respectful and to them seemed like a stand up guy.
 
Last edited:
I suppose some people can come to the conclusion that Guy Fieri is a douche based on his style. Fieri has a California-boy style, much like Bourdain has a New York City style, Zimmern has that Minnesota/mid-westy style, and Paula Deen has a southern style. However, coming to the conclusion anyone is a douche based on their style is likely unfounded since I doubt that anyone here personally knows any of those people to any significant degree.

That said, I've been to a few places that Fieri has recommended on triple-D and have come away unimpressed in every case. Maybe I've been unlucky but none of the places made me go "Wow, that was great. I have to go back again."
 
That said, I've been to a few places that Fieri has recommended on triple-D and have come away unimpressed in every case. Maybe I've been unlucky but none of the places made me go "Wow, that was great. I have to go back again."

I'll back that up.

he went to a diner around the corner from my ex... when we were dating, we went there all the time, but really, they were nothing special compared to any other jersey diner.
 
FUCK. NO. PERIOD. You open, you do it right. Last I checked, I'm not at a soft opening if I'm paying full menu price and picking up my own bar tab. That shit better be ready to go day 1, and as good that day as it is a year later.
Yeah, doesn't work like that. Years ago, I got hired as a waiter and room service porter for a new hotel, restaurant, banquet and convention center. We were training while the carpet and wall treatments were still going in. Panes of glass and exterior doors were not installed yet (plywood covering). Restaurant was very upscale but not truly high-end. Our first two days of service (at least in the restaurant) were by invitation only, on a Friday and Saturday night. There were a dozen professional athletes (active and retired). There were several state senators and representatives (or former). Several local celebrities and a few nationally known ones. The owners were fairly well-heeled and connected.

We got three days of training, one was mostly classroom type stuff, going over policies, food safety, the menu, and shit. The other two were only about five or six hours each, frequently interrupted because the restaurant manager would have to go and take a call about some equipment that hadn't showed-up yet, calling around to rent equipment like an ice machine because the new one they purchased already broke down, et. al. And then training on the new touch screen ordering/POS computer system (again, from 1990). Big learning curve and some unexpected behaviors to get worked-out on that.

For the most part it went fine but we had some problems in the first week, mostly with wait staff timing, communication with the kitchen, inconsistent timing of the kitchen in putting out orders, the damned computer. We just hadn't worked enough with each other at service volumes to get that refinement and communication down. Every day for the first week, there was a new waiter or cook starting, who was learning everthing on the fly. And the restaurant manager, head chef, and sous chef were all experienced with excellent credentials (e.g. chef and sous were both ACI graduates, restaurant manager had a BA in hospitality from a reputable public university, all had 10+ years of experience).

They only hire enough staff to handle a fraction of the slated capacity at first. e.g. if the restaurant will eventually seat 300, they do NOT expect to be filled to capacity for at least a couple weeks, so they don't bother hiring a full staff. They gradually hire more staff as business warrants. But if business comes in, you seat and serve them, even if you're really stretching your staff way too thin. With each new group hired, they don't get much more training than we did. So on and so forth...

I agree that two months is a little long for anyone to still be pinning their slip-ups on but your expectation of everything always done right on Day #1 (or even Week #1) just doesn't exist in the restaurant world. Or is exceptionally rare. Oh and the menu often changes during the first few months, as you identify what is not selling or being received well.
 
Last edited:
I agree. A good restaurant grows organically, it takes a while to find its roots. People who go in the first day do it to be part of that process and see what new is being brought to the table.
Some seem to think its like rehearsal for a play or something. It would be, if rehearsal for plays went like "OK everyone, you've all done this before somewhere else, here is the script, your costumes, and assigned roles. You've all been shown the stage, your dressing rooms, and the props. Curtain goes up tomorrow at 7PM, please be here at least two hours before so we'll have time for one complete rehearsal." WTF?

And then some of your staff inevitably turn-out to be not very good at what they do. Most managers don't believe in firing their way to the team they want. As long as they are showing-up on time, have a decent attitude and are trying, you try to bring their skill and competence up-to-par with mentoring, experience, and some patience.
 
i dotn mind him ffs
his enthusiasm seems genuine
his style aint mine but whatevs


he looks like a douche..obv
but he dont come off like one
he seems like agood guy


but hye look @the frugal gourmet
<.<....................................................................
 
I suppose some people can come to the conclusion that Guy Fieri is a douche based on his style. Fieri has a California-boy style, much like Bourdain has a New York City style, Zimmern has that Minnesota/mid-westy style, and Paula Deen has a southern style. However, coming to the conclusion anyone is a douche based on their style is likely unfounded since I doubt that anyone here personally knows any of those people to any significant degree.

The thing is, the dude is from ohio and his 'california-boy' style just comes across as affect. The dude created a dumb character and he seems to have bought into it. Generally, people who do that are assholes, irl.


That said, I've been to a few places that Fieri has recommended on triple-D and have come away unimpressed in every case. Maybe I've been unlucky but none of the places made me go "Wow, that was great. I have to go back again."

I don't understand the show. He goes to diners and eats over the top greasy food. I wouldn't trust that dude's taste further than I could throw his spiky haired ass.
 
It amazes me that so many of you have expertise in running a business, economics, religion, physics, and anything else you want to believe that gives you a false sense of superiority.
 
Trust me man, I've watched probably over a hundred episodes of Triple Ds, some of them multiple times and he definitely does it, though not in every episode. Plus its the whole shtick; the stupid hair, the shades backwards on his neck (total douchebag maneuver), and his overall awesomer-than-thou demeanor. So obnoxious. Richman does not have any of that, at least from the handful of episodes I've seen.

The wife won't even let me watch the show without my headphones on if she is in the room because she finds him so obnoxious. 😀

KT


I watch DDD when i can. I love the resturant, the food etc. I HATE HIM. i think the show would be 100x better without him.

he does find some great places i would like to visit.
 
lol those Nachos are worse than the ones you get at ballgames

I don't know about that. Last time at Angels Stadium the "nachos" were a bag of tostitos chips and a cup of cheese that was semi-hard.

Petco Park had an amazing Nacho cart, it's was piled on chili, cheese, and a big plate full of chips, with onions and jalapenos on the side for your pleasure - And it was cheaper too, sigh.

I don't know why anyone would have thought a restaurant opened by Guy Fieri in Times Square was going to be good. I'd have figured a substandard TGI Fridays/Chili's, and that really is what it seems like.
 
I've been to a couple of DDD locations and both were good for diner food. More things homemade than normal for diners and fairly well done. I can't imagine anyone watching any episode of his show and thinking that the food was haute cuisine. It's elevated diner food at best. The thing that is impressive about most of the places featured is how much they make from scratch in-house. Most diners don't do that.
 
Back
Top