Grad degree vs. Phd

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Clocker

Golden Member
Sep 17, 2000
1,353
0
76
people on these boards need to chill

too much attitude

lets say it was a misunderstanding, get over it, and move on

 
Nov 3, 2004
10,491
22
81
Originally posted by: Clocker
people on these boards need to chill

too much attitude

lets say it was a misunderstanding, get over it, and move on

dunno, homercles' attitude was pretty ridiculous.
 

homercles337

Diamond Member
Dec 29, 2004
6,340
3
71
Originally posted by: IAteYourMother
Originally posted by: Clocker
people on these boards need to chill

too much attitude

lets say it was a misunderstanding, get over it, and move on

dunno, homercles' attitude was pretty ridiculous.

The OP is apparently graduating from U Texas (nebulous or not, he said i went to U Texas a #9 school), applying to GRAD school, and does not know that a masters is NOT required for phd programs. If this does not make ANYONE with a grad degree say WTF?! You are just as god damn dumb/uninformed as the OP. This kind of sheet warrants "attitude." Someone as clueless as the OP would NEVER be admitted to ANY grad program if was a committee member.
 

shuttleboi

Senior member
Jul 5, 2004
669
0
0
Yes, you can apply directly to a PhD program from undergraduate. I did that back in 1996 and was accepted to the PhD program at several schools. During the course of getting your PhD, you will have to pass through several milestones; among these is the qualifying exam (which can be a breadth exam, a depth exam or an exceptional research paper, depending on your school), and once you pass, you are given the M.S. degree if you happen to be in the PhD program straight from college.
 

shuttleboi

Senior member
Jul 5, 2004
669
0
0
Originally posted by: homercles337
Originally posted by: IAteYourMother
Originally posted by: Clocker
people on these boards need to chill

too much attitude

lets say it was a misunderstanding, get over it, and move on

dunno, homercles' attitude was pretty ridiculous.

The OP is apparently graduating from U Texas (nebulous or not, he said i went to U Texas a #9 school), applying to GRAD school, and does not know that a masters is NOT required for phd programs. If this does not make ANYONE with a grad degree say WTF?! You are just as god damn dumb/uninformed as the OP. This kind of sheet warrants "attitude." Someone as clueless as the OP would NEVER be admitted to ANY grad program if was a committee member.

Homercles, you really need to chill out. Before you get pissed at me too, yes, I do have a PhD, and I was a postdoc as well.

The OP said "Just to check I went to UT Austin (ranked 9 in the nation) and you can do the same thing there!!" No one enrolls in a school "just to check" if one can enroll into the PhD program. A little reading between the lines would suggest he went to check the UT Austin webpage for information.

If anything the OP is guilty of poor writing (kids these days, sheesh), and you are a bit guilty of reading his passage too quickly. With kids spelling ur, there/they're/their so badly these days, I would skip over a lot of their writing too.
 

Lazy8s

Golden Member
Jun 23, 2004
1,503
0
0
Now that's all behind us some bumpage for the daytime crew. Perhaps there is a UF masters or phd student here I can talk to?
 

BigJ

Lifer
Nov 18, 2001
21,330
1
81
Originally posted by: Syringer
Anyone know of sites that have average GPAs/GREs for grad schools admittants?

Most colleges have graduate school pages with that information listed right there.
 

jlmadyson

Platinum Member
Aug 13, 2004
2,201
0
0
When I had applied to doctorate programs in my field I already had a Master's, so it wasn't so much an issue for me.

However, like some have noted here, in my field (political science) at least, most programs do not necessarily require a Master's, but it is more a formality.

In example, you may apply to the PhD program and actually be accepted on the Master's track at first, then after say a year of good work be bumped to the PhD track, essentially bypassing the Master's altogether.

From my understanding, some fields/schools do not even require the aforementioned step, i.e., being accepted out right to the doctorate track. I know my cousin did this in his field (physiology) as well.
 

tfinch2

Lifer
Feb 3, 2004
22,114
1
0

pontifex

Lifer
Dec 5, 2000
43,804
46
91
Originally posted by: homercles337
Originally posted by: IAteYourMother
Originally posted by: Clocker
people on these boards need to chill

too much attitude

lets say it was a misunderstanding, get over it, and move on

dunno, homercles' attitude was pretty ridiculous.

The OP is apparently graduating from U Texas (nebulous or not, he said i went to U Texas a #9 school), applying to GRAD school, and does not know that a masters is NOT required for phd programs. If this does not make ANYONE with a grad degree say WTF?! You are just as god damn dumb/uninformed as the OP. This kind of sheet warrants "attitude." Someone as clueless as the OP would NEVER be admitted to ANY grad program if was a committee member.


if this is how stupid people with phds act and can't even read (i understood what the op said perfectly fine and i only have a high school education), then there is no hope for anyone.
 

Lazy8s

Golden Member
Jun 23, 2004
1,503
0
0
Originally posted by: tfinch2
Originally posted by: Lazy8s
Now that's all behind us some bumpage for the daytime crew. Perhaps there is a UF masters or phd student here I can talk to?

Straight from the UF webpage:

http://www.cis.ufl.edu/dept/gradcoord/grad-program/grad/phd.shtml#apply

Ph.D. students without prior CS/CE masters degree can apply for a masters degree after advancing to Ph.D. candidacy and having satisfied all the masters degree requirements.

/thread



Yeah I said that already ty though for the linkage. This was where my suprise came from, a Phd without a masters at all ever period. Most of my professors have a Phd and 3 or 4 masters degrees. After speaking with them this morning they were suprised to hear the masters degree is not awarded at all as well but they did not seem concerned either. Thanks for the replies...and some comic relief along the way.

Edit: Ok, not none at all ever you can go back and get it afterwards but why if you apparently don't ned one? You already have a Phd.
 

ghostman

Golden Member
Jul 12, 2000
1,819
1
76
I didn't read the whole thread, but from what I did read, you seem to be leaning more toward IT business management. To me, that actually sounds like you'd be better off taking a job, getting some real-world experience, then having your company cover your MBA instead.

Although I value education highly (especially real degrees like PhDs), the workforce (usually) doesn't care about your masters or your PhD - especially those that weren't crafted by the company. At the financial institution I work in, the masters grads follow the same path as the bachelors grads. They make no exceptions for PhD students either. The company will educate you in the fields they want you to be educated in.

And I was instructed not to waste my time and money to go to grad school by a masters graduate.

----

If you do intend to pursue further education, I tend to view a masters as an extension of a bachelors. It's purpose is to further educate you in practical, well-defined methods. When you hit PhD territory, it should mean that you're passionate about the subject and hope to develop beyond any well-defined methods.
 

BigJ

Lifer
Nov 18, 2001
21,330
1
81
Originally posted by: Lazy8s


Edit: Ok, not none at all ever you can go back and get it afterwards but why if you apparently don't ned one? You already have a Phd.

That's not what it says. It says you can get awarded the Masters after going for candidacy and meeting the requirements. So if you want, you can get the Masters degree once you've completed all the work for the Masters, but still with your Ph.D work to go.
 

Tobolo

Diamond Member
Aug 17, 2005
3,697
0
0
Originally posted by: homercles337
Wow, applying for grad degrees and you dont know that you can/should apply to phd programs?! Fsck, you are horribly uninformed. HORRIBLY, HORRIBLY uninformed. You never should have started this thread. Gawd, im just thinking, "wow, wtf?!"

edit: did you talk to/interact with any profs/grad students the whole time you were in school?

edit2: If i knew who you were i would contact the schools you are applying to and give bad recommendations using my credentials. I cant believe you dont know this ******. I was a postdoc at U Texas and that place is a machine for UGs, but for you to persue a grad degree and not know your options speaks VOLUMES!


What an ass
 

James3shin

Diamond Member
Apr 5, 2004
4,426
0
76
Go directly to PhD, do not collect $200. I'm looking to do the same thing. MD/PhD for the motherfvcking win(FTMFW)!
 

Reel

Diamond Member
Jul 14, 2001
4,484
0
76
Originally posted by: BigJ
Originally posted by: Lazy8s


Edit: Ok, not none at all ever you can go back and get it afterwards but why if you apparently don't ned one? You already have a Phd.

That's not what it says. It says you can get awarded the Masters after going for candidacy and meeting the requirements. So if you want, you can get the Masters degree once you've completed all the work for the Masters, but still with your Ph.D work to go.

What actually happens is that you get the masters when you get your PhD. They hate to give you a masters degree if you are taking money as a PhD student and have you leave with a free masters degree. You will get a masters in the end but you cannot get a masters mid-way and bail out. Disclaimer: I was a grad student in the department under discussion.
 

James3shin

Diamond Member
Apr 5, 2004
4,426
0
76

Originally posted by: homercles337
Wow, applying for grad degrees and you dont know that you can/should apply to phd programs?! Fsck, you are horribly uninformed. HORRIBLY, HORRIBLY uninformed. You never should have started this thread. Gawd, im just thinking, "wow, wtf?!"

edit: did you talk to/interact with any profs/grad students the whole time you were in school?

edit2: If i knew who you were i would contact the schools you are applying to and give bad recommendations using my credentials. I cant believe you dont know this ******. I was a postdoc at U Texas and that place is a machine for UGs, but for you to persue a grad degree and not know your options speaks VOLUMES!

Need Ritalin much? Lay off the coffee and chill out.
 

Lazy8s

Golden Member
Jun 23, 2004
1,503
0
0
Originally posted by: Reel
Originally posted by: BigJ
Originally posted by: Lazy8s


Edit: Ok, not none at all ever you can go back and get it afterwards but why if you apparently don't ned one? You already have a Phd.

That's not what it says. It says you can get awarded the Masters after going for candidacy and meeting the requirements. So if you want, you can get the Masters degree once you've completed all the work for the Masters, but still with your Ph.D work to go.

What actually happens is that you get the masters when you get your PhD. They hate to give you a masters degree if you are taking money as a PhD student and have you leave with a free masters degree. You will get a masters in the end but you cannot get a masters mid-way and bail out. Disclaimer: I was a grad student in the department under discussion.

Yeah I spoke to the prof again and he said if I went Phd route I would get the masters upon completion of the Phd IF I did the extra work. I think at this point I am leaning towards going in as a masters student and changing to Phd after a year if I decide to. I don't know how applicable the Phd is going to be for the job that I want. As another poster said I would almost be better off getting an MBA. The problem there is I know virtually nothing about the business aspect but I very much enjoy the CS portion. I can always get an MBA if I decide that's the route I want to go in the future.
 

erub

Diamond Member
Jun 21, 2000
5,481
0
0
I applied to University of Texas and Georgia Tech Electrical and Computer Engineering Departments for admission in Fall 2006. At UT ECE, they had me fill out a supplemental form with these three options:
1. Masters
2. Masters then Ph.D.
3. Ph.D

I chose #2 which apparently was good for lots of $$. #1 probably not so.

GT had a checkbox:
MS/Ph.D.
If you chose M.S., it asked if you were considering Ph.D. afterwards, with the options for immediate/other (explain)

So there you have it..I chose GT MS ECE after getting their TA funding (MS then Ph.D (probably not happening). Add on an MBA FTMFW.
 

Lazy8s

Golden Member
Jun 23, 2004
1,503
0
0
Originally posted by: erub
I applied to University of Texas and Georgia Tech Electrical and Computer Engineering Departments for admission in Fall 2006. At UT ECE, they had me fill out a supplemental form with these three options:
1. Masters
2. Masters then Ph.D.
3. Ph.D

I chose #2 which apparently was good for lots of $$. #1 probably not so.

GT had a checkbox:
MS/Ph.D.
If you chose M.S., it asked if you were considering Ph.D. afterwards, with the options for immediate/other (explain)

So there you have it..I chose GT MS ECE after getting their TA funding (MS then Ph.D (probably not happening). Add on an MBA FTMFW.


That's what I was planning. I did put I am interrested in a Phd afteer my masters, which I am. I just don't want to dive in the deep end with cement boots.
 

DougK62

Diamond Member
Mar 28, 2001
8,035
6
81
Just about all of the PhD people that I know went straight for the PhD. A few picked up some sort of MS degree on the way.