• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Get to teach friends difference between "afford" and "able to make payments" tonight

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Right now they pay $620 a month for a 2BR, 700 SqFt condo with dish washer, clothes washer, and close dryer. They also have a one stall garage with electric garage door opener and a second parking spot right in front of the condo in a private lot.

What they currently have isn't that bad.

We lived in the exact same condo for a year, right below their current apartment. We just had a very generous tax return, and I got an incredibly large raise from work that opened up our opportunity. At the time we were in the condo, we planned on being there for another 3-4 years.
 
Oh, for the people wondering what sort of house you can get for $120k in my area, he's some pics of my house before it was finished

House
 


<<

<<

<< Where do yo guys live? 140k homes and 550 for rent? man that is such good prices. >>


I live on the eastside of Cincinnati. I pay $475/month for a two-bedroom (~ 900 square feet) apartment.
>>



I pay $475 + water (usually around $500 total) per month for a 700-square foot, one-bedroom apartment. In a semi-crappy complex in a semi-crappy neighborhood. don't feel too badly. 🙂
>>


Oh, trust me. I'm not complaining. I know I'm living pretty well.

Not only do I pay $475 for 2 BR's, but the location is good, too. My apartment complex is relatively secluded -- no traffic near it -- but it's also about 1/4 mile away from a major road in Cincinnati (Beechmont Avenue) that has every restaurant under the sun. I'm convinced that I'm living in one of the best apartments, for the cost, in the Cincinnati area. 😀
 


<< Oh, for the people wondering what sort of house you can get for $120k in my area, he's some pics of my house before it was finished

House
>>



dammit the bobcat is not included?!?
 


<< Why oh why can't they teach these things in a required class in high school. Budgeting 101 followed up with Investing and Savings 211 right after it. >>

I whole heartedly agree. We teach sex ed and ancient history but a gross number of people in their adults lives have not even the first clue about budgeting and basic investments. They don't know the first thing about financial security at all. It isn't hard but nobody knows because they've not put in even an inkling of effort into it. It should be learned in high school.

I'm 24 and 1.5 years ago I gave some basic lessons to a then-29 year old buddy who didn't have the first freaking clue and on my advice at least started investing some. By definition if you have to carry a balance on your credit card every month after month you can't afford something. That combined with not putting away in the ballpark of 10% of your income for investing means you are overstretching yourself IMO.

Income is meaningless without basic financial nowhow. Totally meaningless.
 
I'm single so when I bought my place I figured that although I would be going paycheck to paycheck, I would at least be building equity. I bought it while in college on using pay form my internship 🙂 Now that I'm out I'm making double payments. It a 15 year loan, but I'm on pace to make it in 7. 🙂
 


<< This also spells disaster for the subsequent offspring of these two. Many people, myself included, learned good budgeting and saving techniques from my parents. If these two will be living from paycheck to paycheck for the next 20 years, their kids will likely grow up to do the same. >>

Yep. My parents make a very high income but their money handling is extremely poor. It took them into their late 30's to even really start putting money away for retirement. My older brother has incredibly poor money handling as well. Only through the luck of being given "the millionaire next door" and actually reading it did I change my approach 180 degrees.

Personally when Mrs. skoorb is working we'll be making a lot of money and we aim to buy a house worth no more than 1.5 X our income. Sure we could buy more, and obviously 1.5X isn't going to work if you're making $20k/year, but I refuse to be a slave to my mortgage unable to buy furniture, put money away, vacations, cover kids when they come, etc.

---

It's really just a bad situation of their friends having houses and them being envious. I can imagine how they feel, but they need to realize that us other two couples are in different situations. Yes they sure do. It's going to be difficult to get that message across and you can't really put it that way but that's the fact of the matter. You and vi_gf aren't under a burden of debt, you have a higher income, and better prospects for income in the coming years. One has to live by their means, not by the means of their friends with a lot more money.
 
Tell them do not i repeat DO NOT buy a $140k house if there combine salary barely is 60k grossed.

My parents bought a new house about 5 years ago. It was about $170k my parents payed about 40k down and my father makes about $75k per year.

For the first 3 years, the times were really tough, it was living pay check to pay check and almost every 2 months or 3 months, they had to go into my father's
401k to raise the money for monthly payments for the loan.
We had no car payments, but my parents maxed out two or three credit cards in less than a year or two 🙁

There was no extra budget for anything, no eating outs, no emergencey funds, no extertainment, no savings etc.
And when the yearly property tax time comes, they have to dig again into the 401k for more money.
The first 3 years were really tough on them.

Now my mother is working as a realtor and financially wise, it is much, much better 🙂

But tell them don't do it!!
 
Kudos to you for taking on this mission. They need to remember that the bank has nearly a risk-free position on a mortgage - don't pay, and they take back the house. So why wouldn't the bank try to finance the biggest loan they can talk someone into? The bank isn't looking out for their interests, it's looking out for its own. And what is it going to cost them to furnish their home? Property taxes are probably going to rise ever year. So are all the utilities. Won't they ever want to take a vacation? And are they going to buy another car with cash? Where's that money going to come from? I'd ask if they can afford a house like that, why do they have credit card balances?

It's proper to figure in the mortgage tax deduction to determine the true cost of their mortgage, though.

Give them the book that Skoorb mentioned - "The Millionaire Next Door". It's available in paperback for a few bucks. I suggest that because I think their real problem is envy, not lack of budgeting ability which is the symptom. The book will show that the vast majority of wealthy people live modestly (hence, the name of the book) and do not live ostentatiously. If they can't overcome their envy problem, they are doomed.
 
1 good thing about living in Wv, alright the only good thing 😛, housing is CHEAP. I am 26 and just bought a house back in September for $42k. Its only a little 2br but its in real good shape, has a nice sized fenced and flat yard, decent area, detached 1 1/2 car garage, and only a $371 a month payment 🙂. Whenever I out grow it I'll either rent it out or just sale it.
 
The general rule that all banks use is that your monthly payment for a house (including taxes and insurance) should be between 28-38% of your monthly gross income (before taxes). Any higher and you won't be approved.

BTW, the house prices in MI rock for most areas. My wife and I bought a 1 year old condo in a really nice area, 1020sq ft. for $135k. I feel for you guys in California that spend three times as much for the same thing.
 


<< Oh, for the people wondering what sort of house you can get for $120k in my area, he's some pics of my house before it was finished

House
>>



Thats not a house.. thats a townhome or duplex.

big difference 🙂
 


<<

<< Oh, for the people wondering what sort of house you can get for $120k in my area, he's some pics of my house before it was finished

House
>>



Thats not a house.. thats a townhome or duplex.

big difference 🙂
>>



Maybe where you come from....Around here...call it carriage home, rowhome, townhouse, duplex, whatever....you own the structure (or at least your portion of it) you own the land it sits on. I've seen "houses" developed in suburban areas that have maybe 10 feet between them.
The firewall between my parents' townhouse and the one next store is wider than 10 feet!
 


<< Tell them do not i repeat DO NOT buy a $140k house if there combine salary barely is 60k grossed.

My parents bought a new house about 5 years ago. It was about $170k my parents payed about 40k down and my father makes about $75k per year.
>>



Crap, I wish I read this thread earlier. I was approved to buy a house up to $225K and I just commited to buying a $200K townhouse and I only make a little over $70K a year....With my parent's help, I'm putting down about $30K for downpayment + closing costs. I think I made a big mistake by overspending.🙁
 
Man, I'm getting old in here. I dont even own a house 🙁. eventhough,I had my share of poor financial management but I've learned a lot from it. Credit Cards are by no mean of Free money, only spend what you can pay in a month but if you can spend less kudos to you. I was trapped in college with a 5K Credit Card debt until Finally I paid it all off. It felt great the day i paid everything off.

Housing here in California is $1500/Month 2Bed/2Bath 1000+ sqft 🙁 <------Insanely high. Hopefully I can pull enough money together and afford a house around here. According to a website, If you make 100K/year <---- you could only afford a 240K house 🙁 with 240K i dont think you'll get much of a house in Northern California. Sad.

Vi_edit its great to have friends to lookout for ya. Keep up the good work.
 


<< vi_edit

I think you need to ease up and understand not everyone is sucessfull and smart like you. You should be proud of what you achieved and planned ahead. But not everyone in US in same position as you are, we live only once and we have to live to it's fullest. Sometimes things happen we don't expect you can't protect yourself from everything. No matter how you plan sometimes things happens and you can't stop it. Only thing you really need to think about your health and family. There parents in this world who achieved all of their goals and can't have children and they are parents who didnt achieve anything blessed with children. Godforbid you gonna have some disease or not be able to have chilren where you gonna take the money you saved up ? to your grave? donated it all in the end. rant over
>>




this is one of those usual, its his life, let him do what he wants because he should be able to do it no matter how dumb it is ideas. Vi_edit is basically a parent. the fact of the matter is, vi_edit is smarter and more sucessful than his friend. His friend could probably learn a lot from listening to vi_edit. If his friend does something stupid, well it would suck. vi_edit being a friend would not want life to suck for his friend. if his friend buys the house, and is broke and it gets forclosed and his children are starving, maybe vi_edit's friend needs to not have children for a while or buy a house. Vi_edit = looking out for friend and friend's possible children.
 


<< Tell them do not i repeat DO NOT buy a $140k house if there combine salary barely is 60k grossed. My parents bought a new house about 5 years ago.It was about $170k my parents payed about 40k down and my father makes about $75k per year. >>


Hmmm, that's rather close to the house I am looking at, my planned down payment and my income.


<< For the first 3 years, the times were really tough, it was living pay check to pay check and almost every 2 months or 3 months, they had to go into my father's 401k to raise the money for monthly payments for the loan. We had no car payments, but my parents maxed out two or three credit cards in less than a year or two 🙁

There was no extra budget for anything, no eating outs, no emergencey funds, no extertainment, no savings etc. And when the yearly property tax time comes, they have to dig again into the 401k for more money. The first 3 years were really tough on them.
>>


Really? 😕 I think I'm looking at the right market segment and don't plan to be house-poor at all. A 30yr mortgage for a house like this is about $850/month, certainly something a person who makes about 75K a year can handle. Heck, you can't get a decent apartment around here for under $750 and the nice two-bedroom ones go for over $1000. They say the Philly suburbs are "blessed" with affordable housing, but I think that's laughable because so many properties I'd like to consider cost between $200K-$250K. I can't buy a damn thing under $100K unless it needs major TLC or is located in an area with high property/wage taxes (which cancels out the mortgage savings).

Of course, I'm single while your father had to support you and your mother on his income. I think that's why your family was forced to live check-to-check whereas I plan on having a monthly "surplus" of about $500, preferrably more.

When I went on WaMu's website, they told me I can "afford" a $305,000 house. :Q Now that's insane. I do well for myself, but I don't think a single 28yr old should be buying a $300K house. Of course, I have no credit card debt or student loans, just a car payment, so my ratios are good. But still...they are saying I can afford a monthly mortgage of $1800. Ridiculous.
 


<< vi_edit

I think you need to ease up and understand not everyone is sucessfull and smart like you. You should be proud of what you achieved and planned ahead. But not everyone in US in same position as you are, we live only once and we have to live to it's fullest. Sometimes things happen we don't expect you can't protect yourself from everything. No matter how you plan sometimes things happens and you can't stop it. Only thing you really need to think about your health and family. There parents in this world who achieved all of their goals and can't have children and they are parents who didnt achieve anything blessed with children. Godforbid you gonna have some disease or not be able to have chilren where you gonna take the money you saved up ? to your grave? donated it all in the end. rant over
>>


This is an enticing argument because it is simultaneously right and wrong.

We should live for today, but we can't. We should embrace life, but we must harbor caution. It's a see-saw and too much weight on one side will upset the balance. It's cliche, but life is about moderation. Moderation, however, is elusive.

I've known people who throw caution to the wind and just spend money and do things because they want to, because they need to, or else they'll suffocate. Suffocation for them comes not from piles of debt, but from the inability to act on their desires. I look at these people with both pity and envy.

Dammit, for once I've love to forget about budgets and savings and plans and just live carefree. But I can't, because I'm scared. I'm scared more of debt, of being an economic slave, of wondering how the bills will get paid than living prudently and missing on opportunities. I couldn't tell you the last time I took a fun vacation. I haven't been more than 200 miles away from my residence in over 3 years. F'ing sucks, but young people start off with nothing (unless endowed by their parents) and it takes a LONG time to build net worth. Unfortunately, your youth is the time when you CAN embrace life and engage opportunities, but it's also the time when you can least afford it. It seems part of the human condition to be damned. 🙁 :|
 
We have friends like this as well...you just want to smack them around sometimes 🙂

Anyway, when the bank says "You can afford $140000" they're assuming you have no other debts (no car payments, no credit cards, no student loads, etc). A good rule of thumb for buying a house is multiply your household salary by 1.5. Thier house payments would be $1000-$1200 a month at that price. And that's just the house payment, not the insurance, the cost of furnature, etc. Then closing costs are usually $2000-$5000, and some places require a 10% good faith deposit on the house (a nice $14000 in this case).

Our friends bought a $96000 house on a $31000/year salary (husband works, wife doesn't). They've had their house two years now, and have refinanced twice, and taken out a home equity loan to pay a $3000 credit card bill (which they've maxed out again). She finally had to start working in a day care facility so she could take care of her kids and make some extra cash. Hope they listen...DON'T DO IT!!!! The numbers won't work.
 


<< A good rule of thumb for buying a house is multiply your household salary by 1.5. >>


That HAS to be wrong. Consider:

The median price for houses sold in February 2002 was around $152,000. Does that mean the median household income should be around $100K? Most households don't make that kind of money, sometimes not even near that.

A ratio of 2.5 sounds more reasonable based on my calculations, assuming you can put down 20% and don't have to service an extraordinary amount of debt. This ratio would typically induce a mortgage payment that equals about 15% of your gross income. Using the 1.5x ratio means you'd only spend 9% of your gross on the mortgage payment. You'll easily spend more for an apartment rent. Remember that most lenders use 28% mortgage-to-income as a maximum, so 15% is rather reasonable. If you CAN find a livable cheap house, go ahead and buy it, but otherwise you'll be renting forever waiting to "afford" a real house using the 1.5x benchmark.

And, of course, there are geographical differences. In my suburban zip code, there are 2 houses currently available under $150K and 95 over $150K. If I search upstate Pennsylvania, those numbers will probably flip-flop. I have to buy what's available and I can't wait until I make 100K a year to buy a house.
 

I'll try and post. I had a big long thing typed up, but the forums are hosed.

slag, Details schmeetails 🙂 I've got an 8 foot firewall between the two of us, I own my property, and I've got 1600 square feet of living space. To get a solo standing "house" with the same dimensions and ammenities, I'd be looking at paying nearly $25,000 more, and would be in a less preferable part of town. Technically it's a townhome, but for all intents and purposes it's a "house".

jhu, my gross earnings alone are just a few thousand less than their combined income. I also have the advantage as well that about 10% of my income is from self employement and I use that as a tax shelter and a way to write off 12% of my house payments, utilities, and property taxes, as well as 50% of all expenses of one of our cars. They don't have that luxury. Also, visgf works 20-30 hours a week, which ends up putting us 10 to 15 thousand dollars a year higher than them.

Ok, met with my friend(the hubby) last night. Wifey was away at work.

Basically here's how they operate. Neither of their families really had any money and neither of them ever got the toys and doodads that they wanted as kids. So now that they have money, they feel obligated to buy anything and everything that they've always wanted, but never had. They've each got their lists - Him, a dog, a four wheeler, a pickup truck. Her, dishes, bedroom furniture, nice clothes, ect. When the bills are paid, all excess money goes tword items on the "wish list".

Bad, bad, bad practices.

And yep, it is as I thought. Envy is REALLY fueling this house buying fire. Both of them are jealous of what we and another couple have. I basically told my friend that you have to live within *YOUR* means and not mine.

Luckily, he pretty much agrees with me that $120k is too much, and that they should be looking in the $80k-$90k range. This would be a fairly new, nicely equipped condo. At that point, their mortgage would almost be cheaper than their current rent, and they would be building equity, but not stretching themselves so thin that they can't afford to start saving for their future.

The bad part is that he's the rational one. She's not. She wants to live a fairy tail life, and she's taken his testicles with her. He's not affirmative enough to make her realize that this is a bad move. I hope that my thoughts agreeing with her husband's would point something out to her, but I don't think it's going to happen. I think I'm going to have to have a second gathering with her and go over these things all over again.

:frown:
 
My budget
$3000 a month net, wife is a stay at home mom. .

$650 mortgage
$200 property tax
$400 vehicle insurance and est repairs
$100 life insurance
$200 utilities: phone, gas, electric, and water. . .
$400 long term savings not inc pension plan
$300 Food and varisous sundries IE lightbulbs etc. . .
$500 discretionary spending $250 for me $250 for wifey a month

Total $2750
Leaves $250 a month for lifes what if's IE washing machine, saving for new cars etc, actually sits in a money market fund. . .
Also get back about $250 a month income tax rebate

Welcome to the real world 😉

 
Back
Top