• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Garmin or TomTom?

ViviTheMage

ViviTheMage

Lifer
I want to get one here in Minnesota. I have a friend who loves his Garmin streetpilot c550.

What I want is :

free map updates
traffic receiver (to give me new routes if traffic is heavy in an area)
removable (to carry around when I am in the woods)
12volt cigarette adapter to power it.
touchscreen = MUST
I dont NEED bluetooth, my phone is bluetooth, but I dont see what it really does to pay the extra for that.

What model should I get of Garmin or TomTom? I have not really heard much about the other brands, I am thinking 250-350$ if possible.
 
garmin for two reasons

they are local here in KC
the tomtom, suesue, bobbob, scottscott, commercials are driving me insane
 
You're not going to get free map updates.

I can't comment on the TomTom's, but I'm very very happy with my Garmin Nuvi 350.
 
I guess I'm the only one who likes Tomtom. I've had Tomtom5 for my Dell Axim for about 2 years now and I love it!
 
My co-worker's mother works for Garmin, and the inside word is Garmin is preparing a lawsuit against TomTom for stealing their patents.
 
Originally posted by: Captante
Garmin makes some very nice units, but I prefer Magellan to both of them.
Click to expand...
My Magellan sucks....their support isn't very good either. I was mad because they don't make half of their units or their software and the support folks don't know anything. I'm hoping one day I'll figure out how to hack my Roadmate and actually make it useful again. I've driven out of my way too many times because the maps aren't accurate. I was trying to find businesses on the map that didn't exist in real life.

Hopefully Garmin or TomTom have more accurate maps.
 
Originally posted by: Fritzo
My co-worker's mother works for Garmin, and the inside word is Garmin is preparing a lawsuit against TomTom for stealing their patents.
Click to expand...

Oooh, time for a little insider trading action! Sweet...
 
I did some extensive research when I was looking for a GPS a few months ago. I ended up getting in-dash car unit from Alpine, but I found that:

- All of Garmin units use NavTeq maps, which are more accurate in North America but poor in Europe.

-Majority of TomTom units use TeleAtlas map data, which are less accurate than NavTeq in North America but much better in Europe.

-Some units of TomTom show unstableness, i.e. freezing and not turning on.

-Garmin's interface and menu options tends to be simpler than TomTom units, which could be a plus or minus depending on your needs. I played with my friend's Garmin C320 (?) and I was impressed. The interface looks a bit dated but it was very user friendly.
 
Meh, I like my TomTom Go 300, but then again that's the only one I've used. I'd say go play with each in a store (if u can) and see which interface you like better. Also, I'm pretty sure the North America maps on my TomTom are from NavTeq, but I could be wrong. I think it tells me in the 'Help' section so I'll check it out when I'm back in the car.

Oh and for free map updates, your best (and only?) choice would be VZNavigator from Verizon Wireless on a LG enV phone. I was turned off by GPS phones initially, but after using the enV for a month I was surprised at how usable it was in-car (and its just as accurate as a standalone GPS but much faster at getting a signal). Verizon updates POI and map data on their servers every 30 days I think. They'll probably have updated software with traffic info sometime next year.
 
both are good but you wont get traffic with neither for 350$. though since you cant get any TT for 350$, go with garmin
 
Originally posted by: ViviTheMage
What if I bumped my price range to 400-500?
Click to expand...

Garmin Nuvi 350, no doubt. Got mine for $488 from amazon two weeks ago. Of course it's only $449 now (isn't that always the way?)
 
Originally posted by: shortspanishguy
Originally posted by: Thraxen
I still use good old Rand McNally.
Click to expand...

i tried that but navigating DC and Baltimore was too hard while driving.
Click to expand...

duh:
2 hands on map, kee on steering wheel... standard dc driving

and look up once in a while to see the road (optional)
 
Originally posted by: ViviTheMage
I want to get one here in Minnesota. I have a friend who loves his Garmin streetpilot c550.

What I want is :

free map updates
traffic receiver (to give me new routes if traffic is heavy in an area)
removable (to carry around when I am in the woods)
12volt cigarette adapter to power it.
touchscreen = MUST
I dont NEED bluetooth, my phone is bluetooth, but I dont see what it really does to pay the extra for that.

What model should I get of Garmin or TomTom? I have not really heard much about the other brands, I am thinking 250-350$ if possible.
Click to expand...

"traffic receiver (to give me new routes if traffic is heavy in an area) "

this exists?! omg.. which unit has it!??! and is it free or subscription?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

TRENDING THREADS

Back
Top