Freak Wave Slams Cruise Ship

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Aharami

Lifer
Aug 31, 2001
21,205
165
106
Originally posted by: Doggiedog
Originally posted by: Aharami
Originally posted by: ScrewFace
I'm watching it on CNN right now. Apparently one of the waves was 73 feet high and took out hundreds of rooms and the restaurant. The company (what else is new) only offered a 25% reduction for their next cruise. The passengers on CNN will never take another cruise ship again. They are seeking legal advice as they want a full refund...and they should get it!:|

they dont deserve anything more than what they are getting. the cruiseline didnt create the wave...why should they be held responsible for mother nature?

The passengers were apparently POed that the ship decided to go through the storm rather than around it in order to make port on time.

yea but i bet if the NCL decided to go around the storm or wait it out, the passengers would be suing them for going off schedule
 

OVERKILL

Platinum Member
Jan 28, 2005
2,103
2
0
I had 2 friends on that ship.
It was a weird feeling to actually have known people who got hit with a 70ft wave.
 

sharkeeper

Lifer
Jan 13, 2001
10,886
2
0
For those wondering what heavy seas look like...

So far, no rogue waves or anything over 30 feet max in the past 13 weeks for me. :)

Here are some videos I took.

A little background. Ok story time. :)

On 04-16, after leaving Port Everglades, Florida. The seas got very rough with the gauges reporting 14-26'. Buoy reports confirm these numbers. I took the time to get some of this on video with my SD20.

NOTE: The system that produced this heavy weather was the same one that affected Norwegian Dawn. We were quite far south of the really bad stuff. We did have a meeting Friday night about the potential for rough weather, however. If they call for 20' seas, the TV gets unplugged and sits on the floor!

First from the bridge looking straight over the bow of the ship:

Straight on

The wind was to our backs and the anemometer was still showing 30 mph gusts coming towards us. We're doing 21.4 knots at the time this was taken so that equals to 54 mph gusts actual. This is a strong breeze!

Heading back to our cabin I decided to take some out our window. This shot is panned as far aft (towards the stern or back of the ship - keep in mind we're down fairly low on deck four and far back - with the rest of the slaves. ;) )

Looking aft from quarters.

A wave splashed our window nice making a nice slap like a book slapping the ground! I grabbed my camera to see if another would slap us but (of course) it didn't come as close. This looks much blurrier since the window now is dripping from water running down. Waves were hitting deck 3 for a good hour perhaps two after this. Things settled down considerably by dinner time, however.

Straight out from our window moments after wave hit window

Finally, most ships have swimming pools. What happens when seas start to get rough? The pools become wave pools! In the case of this video, we were leaving Nassau and got squalled pretty hard. Winds up to 40 knots and we were headed right into them so we had hurricane force winds in gusts across the decks. I have no idea how many chairs were lost but it isn't safe to walk around in those conditions.

Pool closed early tonight!

 

Doggiedog

Lifer
Aug 17, 2000
12,780
5
81
The movies I have from mine are worse. You should have seen the smokestack swaying against the clouds. It made you dizzy just looking at it.
 

WyteWatt

Banned
Jun 8, 2001
6,255
0
0
Originally posted by: sharkeeper
ICCL Statement: Norwegian Dawn

ARLINGTON, Va.

According to the U.S. Coast Guard, cruising is one of the safest modes
of transportation. Over the past two decades, an estimated 90 million
passengers safely enjoyed a cruise vacation. During this period not
one passenger death due to a marine incident has been reported on any
International Council of Cruise Lines (ICCL) member cruise vessel
operating from a U.S. port.


Cruise ships are built to the highest structural stability standards,
as set by the International Maritime Organization (IMO). The Norwegian
Dawn, affected by a freak [sic] wave on April 16, 2005, is part of the fleet
represented by the ICCL and is an excellent example of the high level
of structural integrity found on today?s cruise ships. All ICCL member
ships comply with IMO standards governing the operation of cruise
vessels worldwide, including the design, construction and operation of
ocean-going vessels. These regulations are codified in the Safety of
Life at Sea (SOLAS) Convention and are closely monitored by both flag
and port states, including the U.S. Coast Guard.

The cruise industry cooperates with the U.S. Coast Guard and other
maritime nations to assure the safety of passengers. To ensure
compliance with SOLAS, the Coast Guard examines each cruise vessel
that visits a U.S. port during its itinerary when it is under
construction, when it first enters service at a U.S. port, and
quarterly thereafter. The examinations emphasize structural integrity,
safety and proper life-saving equipment.

The highest priority of the ICCL is to ensure a safe and secure cruise
vacation. The ICCL will continue to work closely with the
international maritime community to ensure the safety of its
passengers, crew and ships.


For more information, please visit http://www.iccl.org/policies/safety.cfm.

No way. There is pee on the tables, ice cube trays, etc. There is no way thats safe.

 

sharkeeper

Lifer
Jan 13, 2001
10,886
2
0
The movies I have from mine are worse. You should have seen the smokestack swaying against the clouds. It made you dizzy just looking at it.

Of course it will *appear* worse the higher up you are. Even on a near calm day it's quite noticeable looking at the funnel against the sky. On rough days you don't do this unless you like an instant replay of your last meal or want to take a quick trip to the drink!

We're down quite low and minor things happen such as drawers that are not latched will open and a glass may slide on the table. (Or like my mouse slid, hit a chair and made it in the water pitcher!)

Go up to Hemispheres on Deck 12 and stuff really is sliding. Definitely blurs the difference between those who have had too much to drink and those who haven't touched a drink. Some actually walk around better after a few drinks it seems. We call them recips which is short for reciprocal walkers.

Also it's important to remember that M/V Century is smaller than your typical "megaliner" class vessel: LOA-815', Beam-105', 70,605 Tonnes

No way. There is pee on the tables, ice cube trays, etc. There is no way thats safe.

There is no ATOT section on that ship.

>begin shameless HAL plug<

You like blues music? Check this out. That's a nice cruise on a great ship.

>end plug<
 

FlyLice

Banned
Jan 19, 2005
1,680
1
0
Originally posted by: meltdown75
I read about this yesterday - pretty amazing stuff. The captain had never seen anything like it in 20+ years.

Extreme weather & geological events seem to happen more consistently lately. maybe it's just better coverage & reporting though. hmm.

I think it's mostly likely the latter.
 

labgeek

Platinum Member
Jan 20, 2002
2,163
0
0
Originally posted by: Doggiedog

The passengers were apparently POed that the ship decided to go through the storm rather than around it in order to make port on time.

And probably the same passengers would have been PO'ed and wanting a refund if it had gone around it and was late getting back...
 

WyteWatt

Banned
Jun 8, 2001
6,255
0
0
Originally posted by: sharkeeper
The movies I have from mine are worse. You should have seen the smokestack swaying against the clouds. It made you dizzy just looking at it.

Of course it will *appear* worse the higher up you are. Even on a near calm day it's quite noticeable looking at the funnel against the sky. On rough days you don't do this unless you like an instant replay of your last meal or want to take a quick trip to the drink!

We're down quite low and minor things happen such as drawers that are not latched will open and a glass may slide on the table. (Or like my mouse slid, hit a chair and made it in the water pitcher!)

Go up to Hemispheres on Deck 12 and stuff really is sliding. Definitely blurs the difference between those who have had too much to drink and those who haven't touched a drink. Some actually walk around better after a few drinks it seems. We call them recips which is short for reciprocal walkers.

Also it's important to remember that M/V Century is smaller than your typical "megaliner" class vessel: LOA-815', Beam-105', 70,605 Tonnes

No way. There is pee on the tables, ice cube trays, etc. There is no way thats safe.

There is no ATOT section on that ship.

>begin shameless HAL plug<

You like blues music? Check this out. That's a nice cruise on a great ship.

>end plug<


:disgust:

Doesn't matter there still pee on the tables, ice cube trays, etc.

 

sharkeeper

Lifer
Jan 13, 2001
10,886
2
0
Even on *VERY* tranquil days such as yesterday evening, movement is still noticeable if you watch the waterline...

Near flat seas

Pitch very obvious in that video. However most people hardly notice this when walking around and doing "normal" things people do on these ships...

Doesn't matter there still pee on the tables, ice cube trays, etc.

Umm so what is your point?
 

WyteWatt

Banned
Jun 8, 2001
6,255
0
0
Originally posted by: sharkeeper
Even on *VERY* tranquil days such as yesterday evening, movement is still noticeable if you watch the waterline...

Near flat seas

Pitch very obvious in that video. However most people hardly notice this when walking around and doing "normal" things people do on these ships...

Doesn't matter there still pee on the tables, ice cube trays, etc.

Umm so what is your point?

That is disgusting and can make you sick. Thats why there so many people getting sick on ships.

 

Sunbird

Golden Member
Jul 20, 2001
1,024
2
81
As long as the waves don't kill the flames of the BBQ on the ATOT gay cruise, everything will be fine.
 

Jzero

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
18,834
1
0
Originally posted by: imtim83
:disgust:
Doesn't matter there still pee on the tables, ice cube trays, etc.

And there's sh!t all over the remote controls in most hotel rooms. That's the price we have to pay for using the same rooms occupied by little choads like you.
 

iamwiz82

Lifer
Jan 10, 2001
30,772
13
81
Originally posted by: imtim83
Originally posted by: sharkeeper
Even on *VERY* tranquil days such as yesterday evening, movement is still noticeable if you watch the waterline...

Near flat seas

Pitch very obvious in that video. However most people hardly notice this when walking around and doing "normal" things people do on these ships...

Doesn't matter there still pee on the tables, ice cube trays, etc.

Umm so what is your point?

That is disgusting and can make you sick. Thats why there so many people getting sick on ships.

Do you realize how many nasties is on your toothbrush, especially if it stays in the bathroom?
 

sharkeeper

Lifer
Jan 13, 2001
10,886
2
0
That is disgusting and can make you sick. Thats why there so many people getting sick on ships.

Nonsense.

I suggest you start reading up on the CDC Vessel Sanitation Program and understand the industry. You are at greater risk of getting sick from eating at a restaurant or fast food joint than you are on a cruise ship.

VSP Homepage

If there is one reported case of GI on any ship that makes one stop at a U.S. port, the ship is REQUIRED to report this incident to the CDC. This does not apply to hotels and other land based establishments. You only see cases of illness on cruise ships in the news for this reason.

It's not much different than computer viruses and malware. This is a people problem folks. If people had better personal hygeine, things like this would not happen as often as they do. Wash your hands with soap and warm water when you finish your business. You should do this everywhere and everytime anyways. If you do not, THAT is disgusting. Don't blame the ship for YOUR lack of cleanliness. If you are sick and are booked, STAY THE HELL HOME! We don't want your damn germs! :|

 

Monkey muppet

Golden Member
Sep 28, 2004
1,241
0
0
I've heard of a coral reef about 150miles off the coast west of south cali where some of the world class surfers go - 70 foot waves are the norm there
 

WyteWatt

Banned
Jun 8, 2001
6,255
0
0
Originally posted by: sharkeeper
That is disgusting and can make you sick. Thats why there so many people getting sick on ships.

Nonsense.

I suggest you start reading up on the CDC Vessel Sanitation Program and understand the industry. You are at greater risk of getting sick from eating at a restaurant or fast food joint than you are on a cruise ship.

VSP Homepage

If there is one reported case of GI on any ship that makes one stop at a U.S. port, the ship is REQUIRED to report this incident to the CDC. This does not apply to hotels and other land based establishments. You only see cases of illness on cruise ships in the news for this reason.

It's not much different than computer viruses and malware. This is a people problem folks. If people had better personal hygeine, things like this would not happen as often as they do. Wash your hands with soap and warm water when you finish your business. You should do this everywhere and everytime anyways. If you do not, THAT is disgusting. Don't blame the ship for YOUR lack of cleanliness. If you are sick and are booked, STAY THE HELL HOME! We don't want your damn germs! :|

True but I have seen people not do that. Like at my work. I was disgusted by it for sure.