Freak Wave Slams Cruise Ship

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Kev

Lifer
Dec 17, 2001
16,367
4
81
Originally posted by: ScrewFace
I'm watching it on CNN right now. Apparently one of the waves was 73 feet high and took out hundreds of rooms and the restaurant. The company (what else is new) only offered a 25% reduction for their next cruise. The passengers on CNN will never take another cruise ship again. They are seeking legal advice as they want a full refund...and they should get it!:|

from who? mother nature?
 

surreal1221

Golden Member
Mar 12, 2005
1,206
0
0
Ignorance is bliss. . .

Cold fronts moving into the Atlantic are cause for increased wave heights, this is just a case of being in the wrong place at the wrong time.

Originally posted by: Jnetty99
Is it normal when you go a cruise from NY down south to experience rough seas all the time? A lot of people called in saying how bad this cruise line was and how they spend almost 48 on bumpy seas.

Only normal during the winter months when systems move out into the Atlantic. During the late Spring, Summer, and Fall months seas should not be that bad.
 

91TTZ

Lifer
Jan 31, 2005
14,374
1
0
Originally posted by: ScrewFace
The passengers on CNN will never take another cruise ship again. They are seeking legal advice as they want a full refund...and they should get it!:|

Those passengers are weak willed pansies. Why should they get a refund? They're on a ship in the ocean that got hit with a wave. Nobody died. The cruise ship cannot control the weather, why should they lose all that money because a ship got wet?
 

91TTZ

Lifer
Jan 31, 2005
14,374
1
0
It bothers me that news reporters choose to interview the most irrational people instead of asking the vast majority of rational people what they thought.

I remember waiting in the airport once for a friend and a flight came back because it had problems with its ventilation system. No big deal really, and most passengers seemed only mildly aggravated that they had to wait for the next flight. But of course you got 5 or 6 distraut morons stumbling out of the plane sobbing, yelling, and just acting like complete idiots. They were saying how they almost died, were thinking about suing, etc.

Over a ventilation system. The plane flew fine, it just had to turn around because its AC stopped working.
 

surreal1221

Golden Member
Mar 12, 2005
1,206
0
0
Originally posted by: sharkeeper
The passengers on CNN will never take another cruise ship again.

If was on a ship called CNN I'd jump over and end myself.


I like it. . .

If I was on a ship called Fox news I'd jump over and end myself.

The passengers of the ship that were on CNN, the one I saw, sucked at speaking english. All this jibberish jive going on I couldnt understand a thing she said. Nevertheless, here comes her get rich off of a wave hitting my cruiseship scheme she saw on late night TV.
 

DaiShan

Diamond Member
Jul 5, 2001
9,617
1
0
Originally posted by: ScrewFace
I'm watching it on CNN right now. Apparently one of the waves was 73 feet high and took out hundreds of rooms and the restaurant. The company (what else is new) only offered a 25% reduction for their next cruise. The passengers on CNN will never take another cruise ship again. They are seeking legal advice as they want a full refund...and they should get it!:|


WTF mate?! The company gave them half the price refunded and a voucher for half off their next cruise for something completely outside of their control.. But yeah, they should sue and not only get it free, but a million dollars each, that seems fair...
 

sharkeeper

Lifer
Jan 13, 2001
10,886
2
0
It bothers me that news reporters choose to interview the most irrational people instead of asking the vast majority of rational people what they thought.

That's what they want.

this just had to happen now didn't it? I am supposed to be on one Thursday morning.....

Go and have a good time. You are safe trust me. There could be a nuclear war and you are guaranteed to survive. Well at least the shock and awe part anyways.

Your chances of having an incident or death outright are far greater actually getting to the ship!

Kind of like this most unfortunate group of people.
 

CVSiN

Diamond Member
Jul 19, 2004
9,289
1
0
Originally posted by: iamwiz82
Originally posted by: BlueWeasel
Wow...7-story wave?!

How tall is your average cruise ship? I'm trying to get a relationship between the ship and the wave.

Tall. They are absolutely enormous. The last one I was on had 13 stories that were accessible to the public. Maybe Sharkeeper could tell us exactly.

they arnt that big...
put a cruise ship next to USS Ronald Reagan or any other Nimitz Class carrier and you will see cruise ship looks like a tug boat =P
and during my 2 cruises I have seen waves break over the bow of these enormous ships..
it happens all the time in the North Atlantic...
by the same token.. I have seen Navy Destroyers which again are pretty darn large.. completly submerged by large waves in the NA...

the difference is Cruise ships arnt really designed to do what a Warship is.. we dont dodge storms.. we go right through them..
 

Cable God

Diamond Member
Jun 25, 2000
3,251
0
71
Originally posted by: sharkeeper
It bothers me that news reporters choose to interview the most irrational people instead of asking the vast majority of rational people what they thought.

That's what they want.

this just had to happen now didn't it? I am supposed to be on one Thursday morning.....

Go and have a good time. You are safe trust me. There could be a nuclear war and you are guaranteed to survive. Well at least the shock and awe part anyways.

Your chances of having an incident or death outright are far greater actually getting to the ship!

Kind of like this most unfortunate group of people.


Haha, I know, I think your sarcasm meter might be broken ;)
 

PimpJuice

Platinum Member
Feb 14, 2005
2,051
1
76
Originally posted by: ScrewFace
I'm watching it on CNN right now. Apparently one of the waves was 73 feet high and took out hundreds of rooms and the restaurant. The company (what else is new) only offered a 25% reduction for their next cruise. The passengers on CNN will never take another cruise ship again. They are seeking legal advice as they want a full refund...and they should get it!:|

73 feet huh........how do they know it wasnt 72?
 

sao123

Lifer
May 27, 2002
12,656
206
106
The "freak waves" happen when various waves collide just right in the middle of an open ocean. They were speculation and rumor until they got some satallite pictures of some, and even the scientists were amazed at the size. They suspect that a number of ships sinking was caused by them. I mean, if your ship isn't f'ing huge, it's going down without warning.

Saw a program on discovery channel about this a few years back. Interesting stuff
 

sharkeeper

Lifer
Jan 13, 2001
10,886
2
0
Edit: some of the passengers called a radio station(the ones that gof off in SC) and said they were even playing the TitanTic song ha ha.

If they were NCL staff they should be fired.
 

GoSharks

Diamond Member
Nov 29, 1999
3,053
0
76
Originally posted by: CVSiN
they arnt that big...
put a cruise ship next to USS Ronald Reagan or any other Nimitz Class carrier and you will see cruise ship looks like a tug boat =P
and during my 2 cruises I have seen waves break over the bow of these enormous ships..
it happens all the time in the North Atlantic...
by the same token.. I have seen Navy Destroyers which again are pretty darn large.. completly submerged by large waves in the NA...

the difference is Cruise ships arnt really designed to do what a Warship is.. we dont dodge storms.. we go right through them..

im not too sure about that:

Navigator of the Seas
Gross Tonnage: 138,000
Length: 1020'
Beam: 157.5'
Draft: 29'
here

Nimitz Class
Length, overall 1,092 feet (332.85 meters)
Flight Deck Width 252 feet (76.8 meters)
Beam 134 feet (40.84 meters)
Displacement Approx. 97,000 tons (87,300 metric tons) full load
http://www.fas.org/man/dod-101/sys/ship/cvn-68.htm

destroyers are really small:
Arleigh Burke class (Flight II)
Length ~510 ft
Beam: max 66ft. waterline, 59ft
draft: 31ft
displacement: ~9200 tons
http://www.fas.org/man/dod-101/sys/ship/ddg-51.htm

gross tonnage does not actually count becuase it measures space on a vessel. Displacement Tonnage is the actual weight of the vessel and its contents. wiki

so we know that the navigator is wider than the nimitz (not counting the flight deck), and that it is roughly the same length. how tall is the nimitz? if i were to guess, the navigator is taller, and therefore bigger.