For discussion:
Change the tax law to tax capital gains, 'realized' or 'unrealized', by the following year, like income is taxed.
Why should people who sweat for their income have to pay tax on it no later than the year after the receive it, while those few who can live off of passive investments with capital gains - who already pay a lower tax rate as well - can enjoy unlimited years of deferring any taxes, allowing them to further increase their proftits by investing that untaxed income into further investments?
If you make $50,000 in wages you want to invest each year, you pay taxes on that money within a year. If you get $50,000 a year for investing from existing investments, if you leave it in the same investments you can pay zero taxes on it, and keep on not paying taxes year after year, decade after decade with the governmnent - the public, you and me - effectively never getting their cuts except the small portion you occassionally withdrawn and realize the gain on.
If the few wealthy enough to have nearly all their income from capital gains had to pay taxes on the gains annualy like wage earners, that revenue would allow for significant tax reductions for wage earners, by equaling the playing field to where everyone had to pay taxes within a year, and not get to put it off indefinitely (imaging letting wage earners put it off indefinitely?)
It's not as if it would end people putting their money in investments - they'd still do so because that's the onoy way they can make the most on their money.
Sure, they'd have to sell part of their invetment annualy to pay taxes, like wage earners have to pay their taxes every year. The benefit would be less taxes for wage earners.
For investments where it's not practical to pay the taxes annually, like real estate, we'd have to figure out a way to handle it. There are man options from just requiring the taxes be paid on appreciated value, to exempting that investment, to having the gain calculated annualy with iinterest at the rate of inflation accumulate until the amount is paid later.
Retirment accounts could remain tax-deferred for the public policy reason of encouraging saving for retirement, jsut as they are now for the same reason.
Change the tax law to tax capital gains, 'realized' or 'unrealized', by the following year, like income is taxed.
Why should people who sweat for their income have to pay tax on it no later than the year after the receive it, while those few who can live off of passive investments with capital gains - who already pay a lower tax rate as well - can enjoy unlimited years of deferring any taxes, allowing them to further increase their proftits by investing that untaxed income into further investments?
If you make $50,000 in wages you want to invest each year, you pay taxes on that money within a year. If you get $50,000 a year for investing from existing investments, if you leave it in the same investments you can pay zero taxes on it, and keep on not paying taxes year after year, decade after decade with the governmnent - the public, you and me - effectively never getting their cuts except the small portion you occassionally withdrawn and realize the gain on.
If the few wealthy enough to have nearly all their income from capital gains had to pay taxes on the gains annualy like wage earners, that revenue would allow for significant tax reductions for wage earners, by equaling the playing field to where everyone had to pay taxes within a year, and not get to put it off indefinitely (imaging letting wage earners put it off indefinitely?)
It's not as if it would end people putting their money in investments - they'd still do so because that's the onoy way they can make the most on their money.
Sure, they'd have to sell part of their invetment annualy to pay taxes, like wage earners have to pay their taxes every year. The benefit would be less taxes for wage earners.
For investments where it's not practical to pay the taxes annually, like real estate, we'd have to figure out a way to handle it. There are man options from just requiring the taxes be paid on appreciated value, to exempting that investment, to having the gain calculated annualy with iinterest at the rate of inflation accumulate until the amount is paid later.
Retirment accounts could remain tax-deferred for the public policy reason of encouraging saving for retirement, jsut as they are now for the same reason.