• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Football is officially ruined.

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
JD50 said:
Not one of those links say that it is a new rule or that an automatic first down is new. Here's the gist of it from one of those articles...
---
That is the only difference. It has been an automatic first down since the rule was put in place years ago.
Click to expand...

SSSnail said:
Hey JD50, what was the sentence right before the paragraph that you quoted from that very article?
Click to expand...


As a 3rd party who only kind of gives a shit, there are many web pages in 2014 claiming that it's a new rule. Deeper googling will confirm that it is not.
 
SSSnail said:
Hey JD50, what was the sentence right before the paragraph that you quoted from that very article?
Click to expand...

It is poorly worded, which is why they clarified what they meant in the paragraph that I already quoted. People are being lazy when they use the phrase "new rules"

According to the new rules, defenders cannot initiate contact with receivers after 5 yards downfield when the quarterback is in the pocket with the ball.
Click to expand...

It is not a new rule. They changed the wording of the EXISTING rule and are putting more emphasis on calling the penalty. You even said that you understand that rule was there last year, but you didn't remember it being an automatic first down. You have yet to find anything to back up that statement. Go and find any game log from last year and you will see all illegal contact penalties resulting in a first down.

Like I said, the shoddy reporting is irrelevant to the actual rule.
 
Well that's what I get for believing in craps I read from the internet, and even from the broadcasts, they make it seems like this is brand new. And I honestly don't remember ever seen an automatic first down given for illegal contact that is not PI; I thought it was 5 yards, and sometimes that resulted in first down. Maybe I glossed that over.
 
SSSnail said:
Well that's what I get for believing in craps I read from the internet, and even from the broadcasts, they make it seems like this is brand new. And I honestly don't remember ever seen an automatic first down given for illegal contact that is not PI; I thought it was 5 yards, and sometimes that resulted in first down. Maybe I glossed that over.
Click to expand...

Heh, yea, I remember cursing the automatic first down many, many times.
 
OILFIELDTRASH said:
Football sucks. Get over it. Watch a real sport like basketball.
Click to expand...


Please, there are three teams on the court and the third team often plays a more important role than the other two. What percentage of all possessions ends with a whistle? And, the fouls are not called fairly with super stars having a different standard applied than the lesser players.

They are skilled and athletic but the game, as it's played now, sucks!


Brian
 
Tennis is the ultimate sport, combining skills, strategy and physical stamina and endurance like no other sport. Plus the aesthetic beauty and elegance of it is unmatched as well
 
I watched a few games over the weekend from late last week. At least the calls appeared to be consistent. It was far better than last year's replacement refs.

I noticed in some cases the call was holding rather than illegal contact. The defense is always trying to disrupt the offensive passing attempts...that can be done by bumping the WRs off the line to throw off their timing or disguising cushion when playing zone to bait the QB. When corners are playing press coverage and playing man, you're going to see a lot more of these calls made. I think the worst I saw from last week's film was when a corner tripped over the WR's feet and it was the corner who went face down on an underthrown ball.....they called the penalty.
 
GagHalfrunt said:
1) You should not be watching pre-season football. Ever. It's like watching porn that's been edited down to a G rating, it's not even close to the real thing.
.
Click to expand...

this.
never understood why people watch it

or even worse people who go to the preseason workouts/training camps to watch
 
Anubis said:
this.
never understood why people watch it

or even worse people who go to the preseason workouts/training camps to watch
Click to expand...

Some of us like seeing the rosters come together and see the backups play. I used to go as a kid to the bears camps and Mike Singletary remembered me every year. Had Gary Fencik throw balls to me when I was 12 and give me pointers. Have most signatures from the starters in 85 on a football. I know sucks right....

I have a walter jersey signed by walter that I asked my wife to bury me in...


Its a great thing to do if you really love football and had played in the past.
 
SSSnail said:
This is my surprised face reading this comment from a Broncos fan ...

After the 43 - 8 beating, stomping, trouncing, flogging, trampling, humiliation, etc... Whatever you want to call it in the SB, you know why they're now ”enforcing” this rule. You should see some of the calls, just plain ridiculous.

In case you want to forget, 43 - 8. Never forget!

Edit: to clarify, the rule is not new, the penalties are new, and how they're enforcing it.
Click to expand...

Those calls may indeed be ridiculous (I haven't watched any preseason) so we'll see how it plays out. My point was just that it's not a new rule. Just like how the tuck rule was already in place before Brady's infamous "tuck rule" game.
 
darkewaffle said:
Man Shaq is awesome. Beast on the court and he's funny as hell off it.
Click to expand...
Take Shaw in his prime and match him up one-on-one full court with any point guard and Shaq would get skunked 9 out of 10 times. He'd never make it to the other end before having the ball stolen from him and he never could shoot worth a damn.

He is a fun guy though.


Brian
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

TRENDING THREADS

Back
Top