Fla. hospital defends secretly deporting patient

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Turin39789

Lifer
Nov 21, 2000
12,218
8
81
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: gingermeggs
three things-
1 how the fuck! does it cost 1.5mill to care for a quadro. 3 years?
2 the drink driver should pay compensation to the man.
3 employers using illegals should be fined massive amounts to stop the practice of employing illegal immigrants.

:thumbsup: x infinity

food prices x7
 

BoomerD

No Lifer
Feb 26, 2006
66,592
14,994
146
While I'm in favor of boxing up ALL the illegals and sending them home. (box car or pine box...let them choose) I suspect the hospital is gonna get their asses kicked in court over this.

I also agree with gingermeggs that employers who hire these illegals should be fined heavily...and I wouldn't object if the CEO's had to go to jail for it as well. Make those at the top criminally responsible and it'll stop.
 

Robor

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
16,979
0
76
Originally posted by: Fern
Secret?

This is so secret we've had a thread here about it before.

(I'm too lazy for to search for it, but I recall this being posted before. H3ll, it happend about 6 years ago)

Fern

The incident happened 6 years ago (as stated in the article) but this info (the lawsuit) is new. I don't remember the original story here - I probably missed it. :eek:
 

Robor

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
16,979
0
76
Originally posted by: Turin39789
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: gingermeggs
three things-
1 how the fuck! does it cost 1.5mill to care for a quadro. 3 years?
2 the drink driver should pay compensation to the man.
3 employers using illegals should be fined massive amounts to stop the practice of employing illegal immigrants.

:thumbsup: x infinity

food prices x7

Are you saying the illegals are a necessary evil?
 

waggy

No Lifer
Dec 14, 2000
68,143
10
81
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: Turin39789
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: gingermeggs
three things-
1 how the fuck! does it cost 1.5mill to care for a quadro. 3 years?
2 the drink driver should pay compensation to the man.
3 employers using illegals should be fined massive amounts to stop the practice of employing illegal immigrants.

:thumbsup: x infinity

food prices x7

Are you saying the illegals are a necessary evil?

illegals? no.

a worker program is needed. The goverment should work in it but they don't.

but i do think they should kick out the illegals.
 

EagleKeeper

Discussion Club Moderator<br>Elite Member
Staff member
Oct 30, 2000
42,589
5
0
Originally posted by: BarrySotero
I head stories of hospitals near me sending illegals back quite awhile ago. One guy cost 10,000 in air fare. This country has been getting pillaged.

For a private jet, that is a reasonable cost for a 8hr R/T flight between NYC and Central America.

If they use public transportation, you have to take the either first or business class airfare cost with no advance reservations, 2 escorts and expenses

 

Moonbeam

Elite Member
Nov 24, 1999
74,902
6,785
126
These complex issues of who is to live and who is not will have to be addressed somehow or we surely will go bankrupt. We will simply have to grow up and realize that those of us who naturally want every last dime spent to save our own personal lives will simply have to face the fact that health care will have to be rationed.

Rationed? Oh my God no, I have the money to pay for health care. I worked my ass off and I an a legal citizen. There has to be another way and there is. I want private health insurance without haven't to worry about waiting in line and I want the best health care money can buy, so I propose that insurance rates rise to whatever levels is necessary to supply me with all the health care I need to extend my life indefinitely. When me and a few million other rich hard working and truly deserving people are paying millions a year for health care, then the system will be working. The rest of you assholes can buy aspirin and bandages.
 

halik

Lifer
Oct 10, 2000
25,696
1
81
The guy won a 1.5 million dollar jackpot, he should have a coke and a smile and STFU.

Give the guardian an invoice if he keeps on bitching, or better yet make it abundantly obvious that when he gets served for the suit he's filing, it will be by an INS officer.

My parents and I didn't spend thousands of dollars for INS forms, interviews, fingerprints, pictures and attorneys to get a U.S. citizenship legally, so this guy can now waste my tax money, because he's not happy with a $1.5M gift. In generally they should deport all illegals w/o prior ties (kids/wife) once they are in a stable condition.
 

Robor

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
16,979
0
76
Originally posted by: halik
The guy won a 1.5 million dollar jackpot, he should have a coke and a smile and STFU.

Give the guardian an invoice if he keeps on bitching, or better yet make it abundantly obvious that when he gets served for the suit he's filing, it will be by an INS officer.

My parents and I didn't spend thousands of dollars for INS forms, interviews, fingerprints, pictures and attorneys to get a U.S. citizenship legally, so this guy can now waste my tax money, because he's not happy with a $1.5M gift. In generally they should deport all illegals w/o prior ties (kids/wife) once they are in a stable condition.

As the husband of a 'for-n-er' spouse I'm 100% in agreement. We've paid what amounts to several thousands of $$$ in the same to be here together legally and have a $500-ish payment due in 2 months to the government to remain in legal status.
 

JS80

Lifer
Oct 24, 2005
26,271
7
81
Originally posted by: waggy
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: Turin39789
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: gingermeggs
three things-
1 how the fuck! does it cost 1.5mill to care for a quadro. 3 years?
2 the drink driver should pay compensation to the man.
3 employers using illegals should be fined massive amounts to stop the practice of employing illegal immigrants.

:thumbsup: x infinity

food prices x7

Are you saying the illegals are a necessary evil?

illegals? no.

a worker program is needed. The goverment should work in it but they don't.

but i do think they should kick out the illegals.

Ship the millions on welfare to the jobs illegals had.
 

blackangst1

Lifer
Feb 23, 2005
22,902
2,359
126
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: rudder
If you are upset about $1.5 million for this one illegal.. you had better hope Obamacare fails to get passed.

I'll note this...

But she also warned the issue is serious, and it is one Congress has yet to address in its health care reform proposals.

"There is absolutely no discussion about it," Luggiero said. And yet, hospitals that receive Medicare reimbursements are required to provide emergency care to all patients and must provide an acceptable discharge plan once the patient is stabilized.

^^^^ WHY? ^^^^



Edit: Added the 'WHY'

Probably because the current congress is redefining "illegal". They want illegals to get the same constitutional rights as am American. Same benefits as a citizen. Essentially take away the incentive to do it legally.
 

blackangst1

Lifer
Feb 23, 2005
22,902
2,359
126
Originally posted by: waggy
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: Turin39789
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: gingermeggs
three things-
1 how the fuck! does it cost 1.5mill to care for a quadro. 3 years?
2 the drink driver should pay compensation to the man.
3 employers using illegals should be fined massive amounts to stop the practice of employing illegal immigrants.

:thumbsup: x infinity

food prices x7

Are you saying the illegals are a necessary evil?

illegals? no.

a worker program is needed. The goverment should work in it but they don't.

but i do think they should kick out the illegals.

We have one. Its called legal immigration and there are several visas available to do so :)
 

blackangst1

Lifer
Feb 23, 2005
22,902
2,359
126
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: halik
The guy won a 1.5 million dollar jackpot, he should have a coke and a smile and STFU.

Give the guardian an invoice if he keeps on bitching, or better yet make it abundantly obvious that when he gets served for the suit he's filing, it will be by an INS officer.

My parents and I didn't spend thousands of dollars for INS forms, interviews, fingerprints, pictures and attorneys to get a U.S. citizenship legally, so this guy can now waste my tax money, because he's not happy with a $1.5M gift. In generally they should deport all illegals w/o prior ties (kids/wife) once they are in a stable condition.

As the husband of a 'for-n-er' spouse I'm 100% in agreement. We've paid what amounts to several thousands of $$$ in the same to be here together legally and have a $500-ish payment due in 2 months to the government to remain in legal status.

Same.
 

Hacp

Lifer
Jun 8, 2005
13,923
2
81
Originally posted by: Turin39789
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: gingermeggs
three things-
1 how the fuck! does it cost 1.5mill to care for a quadro. 3 years?
2 the drink driver should pay compensation to the man.
3 employers using illegals should be fined massive amounts to stop the practice of employing illegal immigrants.

:thumbsup: x infinity

food prices x7

Not if we lower the minimum wage. Unemployment is at 9.5%. There are possibly millions more who want a job but just gave up looking for one. Send the people to the fields and let them work.
 

BoomerD

No Lifer
Feb 26, 2006
66,592
14,994
146
Originally posted by: blackangst1
Originally posted by: waggy
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: Turin39789
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: gingermeggs
three things-
1 how the fuck! does it cost 1.5mill to care for a quadro. 3 years?
2 the drink driver should pay compensation to the man.
3 employers using illegals should be fined massive amounts to stop the practice of employing illegal immigrants.

:thumbsup: x infinity

food prices x7

Are you saying the illegals are a necessary evil?

illegals? no.

a worker program is needed. The goverment should work in it but they don't.

but i do think they should kick out the illegals.

We have one. Its called legal immigration and there are several visas available to do so :)



I don't see anything wrong with a "guest worker" program for agricultural workers.

Retain half of their pay until they return to their native country. Something similar to this was tried many years ago, but either they never went home, or the Mexican banks/government claimed they never got the money.
If set up and administered correctly, this could help the farmers who cry for their cheap labor while slowing illegal immigration.

IMO, it should be accompanied by immediate expulsion of ALL illegal immigrants...regardless of the country of origin, regardless of whether they've married US citizens, regardless of any "anchor babies" they've had.

Round them up...send them back. Let them get in line like everyone else.
 

Hacp

Lifer
Jun 8, 2005
13,923
2
81
Originally posted by: BoomerD
Originally posted by: blackangst1
Originally posted by: waggy
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: Turin39789
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: gingermeggs
three things-
1 how the fuck! does it cost 1.5mill to care for a quadro. 3 years?
2 the drink driver should pay compensation to the man.
3 employers using illegals should be fined massive amounts to stop the practice of employing illegal immigrants.
:thumbsup: x infinity
food prices x7
Are you saying the illegals are a necessary evil?
illegals? no.
a worker program is needed. The goverment should work in it but they don't.
but i do think they should kick out the illegals.
We have one. Its called legal immigration and there are several visas available to do so :)
I don't see anything wrong with a "guest worker" program for agricultural workers.
Retain half of their pay until they return to their native country. Something similar to this was tried many years ago, but either they never went home, or the Mexican banks/government claimed they never got the money.
If set up and administered correctly, this could help the farmers who cry for their cheap labor while slowing illegal immigration.
IMO, it should be accompanied by immediate expulsion of ALL illegal immigrants...regardless of the country of origin, regardless of whether they've married US citizens, regardless of any "anchor babies" they've had.
Round them up...send them back. Let them get in line like everyone else.
So you want more American jobs outsourced to a 3rd world country? Keep American jobs in America for Americans and legal immigrants.
 

blackangst1

Lifer
Feb 23, 2005
22,902
2,359
126
Originally posted by: BoomerD
Originally posted by: blackangst1
Originally posted by: waggy
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: Turin39789
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: gingermeggs
three things-
1 how the fuck! does it cost 1.5mill to care for a quadro. 3 years?
2 the drink driver should pay compensation to the man.
3 employers using illegals should be fined massive amounts to stop the practice of employing illegal immigrants.

:thumbsup: x infinity

food prices x7

Are you saying the illegals are a necessary evil?

illegals? no.

a worker program is needed. The goverment should work in it but they don't.

but i do think they should kick out the illegals.

We have one. Its called legal immigration and there are several visas available to do so :)



I don't see anything wrong with a "guest worker" program for agricultural workers.

Retain half of their pay until they return to their native country. Something similar to this was tried many years ago, but either they never went home, or the Mexican banks/government claimed they never got the money.
If set up and administered correctly, this could help the farmers who cry for their cheap labor while slowing illegal immigration.

IMO, it should be accompanied by immediate expulsion of ALL illegal immigrants...regardless of the country of origin, regardless of whether they've married US citizens, regardless of any "anchor babies" they've had.

Round them up...send them back. Let them get in line like everyone else.

We. Have. One.

H-2A Visas created in 1986.......
 

BoomerD

No Lifer
Feb 26, 2006
66,592
14,994
146
Originally posted by: Hacp
Originally posted by: BoomerD
Originally posted by: blackangst1
Originally posted by: waggy
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: Turin39789
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: gingermeggs
three things-
1 how the fuck! does it cost 1.5mill to care for a quadro. 3 years?
2 the drink driver should pay compensation to the man.
3 employers using illegals should be fined massive amounts to stop the practice of employing illegal immigrants.

:thumbsup: x infinity

food prices x7

Are you saying the illegals are a necessary evil?

illegals? no.

a worker program is needed. The goverment should work in it but they don't.

but i do think they should kick out the illegals.

We have one. Its called legal immigration and there are several visas available to do so :)



I don't see anything wrong with a "guest worker" program for agricultural workers.

Retain half of their pay until they return to their native country. Something similar to this was tried many years ago, but either they never went home, or the Mexican banks/government claimed they never got the money.
If set up and administered correctly, this could help the farmers who cry for their cheap labor while slowing illegal immigration.

IMO, it should be accompanied by immediate expulsion of ALL illegal immigrants...regardless of the country of origin, regardless of whether they've married US citizens, regardless of any "anchor babies" they've had.

Round them up...send them back. Let them get in line like everyone else.

So you want more American jobs outsourced to a 3rd world country? Keep American jobs in America for Americans and legal immigrants.


I'm 100% in favor of that. HOWEVER, who are you going to get to work the fields?

MOST people don't want those jobs...not at the wages they currently pay, nor at any pay.
The idea of making welfare recipients work to earn their monthly checks is great, but the programs have had very limited success where they've been tried.



Originally posted by: blackangst1


We. Have. One.

H-2A Visas created in 1986.......

Doesn't have enough limitations attached to it, nor any incentive for them to return to their native countries.

This program would make it legal for them to come here solely for ag jobs...not construction jobs, not MickyD jobs, not janitorial jobs, nor anything else. ONLY agriculture-related jobs.
Make overstaying the work permit a crime with the stipulation that if they overstay, they're banned from future participation.
 

blackangst1

Lifer
Feb 23, 2005
22,902
2,359
126
Originally posted by: BoomerD
Originally posted by: Hacp
Originally posted by: BoomerD
Originally posted by: blackangst1
Originally posted by: waggy
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: Turin39789
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: gingermeggs
three things-
1 how the fuck! does it cost 1.5mill to care for a quadro. 3 years?
2 the drink driver should pay compensation to the man.
3 employers using illegals should be fined massive amounts to stop the practice of employing illegal immigrants.

:thumbsup: x infinity

food prices x7

Are you saying the illegals are a necessary evil?

illegals? no.

a worker program is needed. The goverment should work in it but they don't.

but i do think they should kick out the illegals.

We have one. Its called legal immigration and there are several visas available to do so :)



I don't see anything wrong with a "guest worker" program for agricultural workers.

Retain half of their pay until they return to their native country. Something similar to this was tried many years ago, but either they never went home, or the Mexican banks/government claimed they never got the money.
If set up and administered correctly, this could help the farmers who cry for their cheap labor while slowing illegal immigration.

IMO, it should be accompanied by immediate expulsion of ALL illegal immigrants...regardless of the country of origin, regardless of whether they've married US citizens, regardless of any "anchor babies" they've had.

Round them up...send them back. Let them get in line like everyone else.

So you want more American jobs outsourced to a 3rd world country? Keep American jobs in America for Americans and legal immigrants.


I'm 100% in favor of that. HOWEVER, who are you going to get to work the fields?

MOST people don't want those jobs...not at the wages they currently pay, nor at any pay.
The idea of making welfare recipients work to earn their monthly checks is great, but the programs have had very limited success where they've been tried.



Originally posted by: blackangst1


We. Have. One.

H-2A Visas created in 1986.......

Doesn't have enough limitations attached to it, nor any incentive for them to return to their native countries.

This program would make it legal for them to come here solely for ag jobs...not construction jobs, not MickyD jobs, not janitorial jobs, nor anything else. ONLY agriculture-related jobs.
Make overstaying the work permit a crime with the stipulation that if they overstay, they're banned from future participation.

I agree there arent enough restrictions; however, we dont need new laws, we need to first enforce the laws we have. And there are temp visas for non agriculture workers as well. Again, we dont need new laws.
 
Oct 30, 2004
11,442
32
91
If we would simply end illegal immigration and deport all of the illegals then this issue would not come up very often. The problem in this case is a symptom of our illegal immigration invasion disease and not the problem itself.

Our federal government needs to change its policies and its priorities from worrying about the welfare of poor people in other countries to worrying about the tens of millions of poor American citizens right here at home.
 

zeruty

Platinum Member
Jan 17, 2000
2,276
2
81
Originally posted by: Aegeon
Originally posted by: Marlin1975
How was this a secret?
The hospital contacted his homeland which said he can come back. They then went to the courts to make sure it was ok and the court said go for it.

Whats the problem?
A huge problem is the court in question was not able to apparently legally decide immigration cases. You can't decide murder cases on Judge Judy either for that matter in case you don't know.

While some of the details are unclear just from the news article, the individual in question was in such a poor mental state after the accident that he had previously had a guardian appointed by the courts and that guardian was not notified that he was about to be deported. This kind of situation is absolutely potentially dangerous because it could easily lead to a situation where somone who is actually legally in the US since they were granted asylum or the like gets deported by the hospital anyways. The proper US governmental authorities should be involved with these cases and any legally appointed guardian should at least know in advance. The last step also should help avoid the possibility of a paperwork screwup getting him sent to the wrong country of something.

The idea illegal aliens should not have access to the US legal system for any reason is just stupid. By that standard if kidnappers smuggle someone into the US for human trafficing purposes that person would have no rights at all. Another huge issue is simply saying someone is an illegal should not be enough to automatically rule out any possiblity of the person in question suing to prove otherwise in court. (Otherwise theoretically any US citizen could get accused and deported without any way to prevent this.) As far as lawsuits and the like go, otherwise you have created another huge incentive for businesses to hire illegal immigrants because they don't have to worry about the possibility of being sued for unsafe working conditions. (The employees in question can still be deported, its just that their lawsuit against a business can still potentially go forward in spite of this.)



If the hospital spent $1.5 million caring for him because he was an illegal and none of the government programs would cover him... Sounds like he is an illegal. Otherwise, someone in those 3 years should have figured it out and gotten the guy on medicaid or whatever...
I would imagine the hospital would be all over helping the guy get that, so they could get paid...


And... the guardian, if in the US illegally, should have been offered a ride on the chartered plane! By offered, I mean told either he goes too or he'll be reported. Oh and by the way, the federal government should start enforcing current laws and deporting every illegal immigrant they come across!

 

Via

Diamond Member
Jan 14, 2009
4,670
4
0
Originally posted by: Turin39789
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: gingermeggs
three things-
1 how the fuck! does it cost 1.5mill to care for a quadro. 3 years?
2 the drink driver should pay compensation to the man.
3 employers using illegals should be fined massive amounts to stop the practice of employing illegal immigrants.

:thumbsup: x infinity

food prices x7

It's actually not about food prices x7.

It's about importing more and more food from abroad as American food producers go out of business (I saw an interview with an American strawberry producer who was closing up shop last year because they couldn't find workers).

but what do we care as long as our food is cheap?

 

Robor

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
16,979
0
76
Originally posted by: blackangst1
Originally posted by: Robor
Originally posted by: rudder
If you are upset about $1.5 million for this one illegal.. you had better hope Obamacare fails to get passed.

I'll note this...

But she also warned the issue is serious, and it is one Congress has yet to address in its health care reform proposals.

"There is absolutely no discussion about it," Luggiero said. And yet, hospitals that receive Medicare reimbursements are required to provide emergency care to all patients and must provide an acceptable discharge plan once the patient is stabilized.

^^^^ WHY? ^^^^



Edit: Added the 'WHY'

Probably because the current congress is redefining "illegal". They want illegals to get the same constitutional rights as am American. Same benefits as a citizen. Essentially take away the incentive to do it legally.

Given the amount of money my wife and I have spent for her legal immigration I'll be *PISSED* if that happens. In fact, we have to spend another $480 or something in Sept for her 10 year green card only to be able to apply for naturalization shortly after (another big $$$ fee I'm sure).