Originally posted by: PrinceofWands
Originally posted by: warmodder
Originally posted by: PrinceofWands
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: Kazaam
so going to the mall and buying gifts and anything else you need is not using common sense and avoiding trouble? i wouldnt ever carry a gun but it definitely seems places that were safe no longer are.
I've yet to see a gun fight at the mall. Honestly, what are the odds on that anyway considering I spend maybe 2-3 hours a year at the mall? In fact, I've yet to read a story about a shooting at the mall that I "frequent." Hell, even if you lived there you'd probably never be exposed to gunfire.
I'm not saying that things don't happen but the odds really are in your favor and the likeliness of you doing something positive with your gun while armed are slim to none. Not to mention the huge responsibility of carrying a gun to begin with. I'm not entirely convinced that that's something CCW holders really grasp.
Again, living in fear isn't part of my life.
And yet all statistics prove beyond a doubt exacly the opposite.
What positive externalities could possibly come out of carrying a gun? Does your model shoot candy canes and snowflakes? Yes in very slim circumstances you may be able to save some lives, but not many will be placed in that situation. The chance for negatives--be them by mistake, on purpose, whatever--is infinitely greater than you being in a position to cause a benefit.
And yet all statistics prove beyond a doubt exactly the opposite.
I realize it's causing you cognitive dissonance, but there is no support that lawful carry is a danger. At all. There is ample support that lawful carry is used to beneficial ends predominately. There's simply no argument there, it's absolute supportable fact. Until that is agreed on and understood (and truly accepted) there is no reason to argue further.
Originally posted by: PrinceofWands
Originally posted by: warmodder
Originally posted by: PrinceofWands
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: Kazaam
so going to the mall and buying gifts and anything else you need is not using common sense and avoiding trouble? i wouldnt ever carry a gun but it definitely seems places that were safe no longer are.
I've yet to see a gun fight at the mall. Honestly, what are the odds on that anyway considering I spend maybe 2-3 hours a year at the mall? In fact, I've yet to read a story about a shooting at the mall that I "frequent." Hell, even if you lived there you'd probably never be exposed to gunfire.
I'm not saying that things don't happen but the odds really are in your favor and the likeliness of you doing something positive with your gun while armed are slim to none. Not to mention the huge responsibility of carrying a gun to begin with. I'm not entirely convinced that that's something CCW holders really grasp.
Again, living in fear isn't part of my life.
And yet all statistics prove beyond a doubt exacly the opposite.
What positive externalities could possibly come out of carrying a gun? Does your model shoot candy canes and snowflakes? Yes in very slim circumstances you may be able to save some lives, but not many will be placed in that situation. The chance for negatives--be them by mistake, on purpose, whatever--is infinitely greater than you being in a position to cause a benefit.
And yet all statistics prove beyond a doubt exactly the opposite.
I realize it's causing you cognitive dissonance, but there is no support that lawful carry is a danger. At all. There is ample support that lawful carry is used to beneficial ends predominately. There's simply no argument there, it's absolute supportable fact. Until that is agreed on and understood (and truly accepted) there is no reason to argue further.
Originally posted by: m1ldslide1
I guess I don't understand why pontifex or others are irritated by the anti-gun posts? This is ATOT, so naturally you can expect this kind of thing. If you want praise all around, then I'm sure that Soldier of Fortune has a forum out there. Debate and discussion is good for everybody.
Personally, I'm in a weird position lately where I'm pro-gun ownership, and anti-concealed weapons. This is a combination of personal/political ideology and common sense. I think that the citizens of a country should be armed should they ever need to rise up against an unjust government. That of course is a moot point now, as most of the armed citizenry of this country have proven that they're easily manipulated with secondary religious/social issues while those they elect are treading on those freedoms they supposedly cherish. I also think it's impossible to ignore the statistics behind carrying weapons, which others have pointed out. I'm not going to march in the streets protesting concealed weapons or anything, but there's no denying that those people are a danger to themselves and others (specifically their families). They obviously don't feel that way, but that's the false sense of power that a firearm grants you.
Finally I couldn't agree more with JulesMaximus, pointing out that it takes a cynical and fearful mindset to feel the need to carry. Hell, maybe that .001% chance that you could need it someday makes it completely worth carrying - that's obviously a subjective interpretation. For me though, I don't want to live my life in that kind of fear, or allow myself to hold the people around me in such low regard. I may be wrong, but I'll err on the side of warm and fuzzy. I have good friends who are the exact opposite of me on this issue and carry everywhere they go. All of them are paranoid, hold their countrymen in very low regard, and have hero complexes (that they don't admit to in public). I sure as hell don't feel safer knowing that they are carrying.
Originally posted by: LikeLinus
Originally posted by: thepd7
The ignorance is strong in this thread.
If any CCL holder tried to pull a gun while a mugger had a gun to the back of their heads then they are morons and are going to get shot. NO ONE here is saying pull a gun on someone who has the drop on you, at least no one reasonable.
There are quite a few cases where someone with a CCL has either given their life and helped save many others or taken out the threat. Wiki the Tyler courthouse shooting. Or the example I just used with the religious organizations in Colorado. In both instances the CCL holders saved many lives, and one brave man gave his life.
The funny thing is the people being ignorant here are the ones who think that anyone who would possibly carry a concealed weapon is a cowboy or lives in a small town. They have obviously not met a responsible gun owner nor have they actually dealt with firearms for an extended period of time.
Generalization ftw.
"The funny thing is the people being ignorant"
"They have obviously not met "
GENERALIZATION FOR THE FUCKING WIN.
Yeah, someone who doesn't share YOUR opinion is obviously ignorant or automatically thinks everyone is a cowboy.
It's called a hypocrite. Look it up asshole.
Ok, so a guy in a mall opens fire with an AK. How many CCL's should pull their weapon and fire at the perp in a public place with innocent people walking around. Who decides to take the shot? How many of them take a single shot? Who hits first and where do the stray bullets go. Who says you're a great marksman? Are you trained to know when/where and how good of a shot you are? Should everyone around trust in you or someone else to take a shot and do the right thing in the right situation?
Originally posted by: LikeLinus
Originally posted by: destrekor
concealed carry normally required classes and training.
in the states where you can get a permit without classes and training.. well, that's wrong. There should be proper training, I definitely agree. But that's only a problem with the method of issuing permits. Don't block the possibility of getting a permit just because some jurisdictions hand them out like candy. Change the methods.
I said I'm for carrying if it's carried for the right reasons. Using the excuse that you could stop someone with an AK in a crowded mall is the problem. I don't think they teach or advise that in the classesYou're endangering lives at that point.
Originally posted by: thepd7
Blah Blah Blah
Originally posted by: Fritzo
Originally posted by: Darwin333
Originally posted by: Fritzo
Originally posted by: Ronstang
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
What kind of handgun/holster/belt? I have a number of different handguns and some fine leather holsters for them. Of course, I can't carry legally where I live, but that doesn't stop me from being prepared.![]()
Kind of sucks to live somewhere that the government doesn't trust you enough, doesn't it? How can you be prepared when the people you run into that are going to cause you trouble are actually carrying a gun because they don't care what the law says? Nice false sense of security you live under. Being prepared in your case means either staying home or avoiding all areas where you might run into a problem. Unfortunately that could be just about anywhere these days.
You know, statistically, you're more likely to kill a loved one with the gun you own than someone trying to harm you.
Plus, if you do shoot someone that's trying to harm you in some way, only a fraction of those incidents involve "bodily" harm, so deadly force would be unwarranted. If you shot or killed someone in that circumstance, you'd be charged with manslaughter and get prison time.
I agree with the fact that if you're in an area where you feel so scared that you need to carry a gun for protection, you're not in the right area. There really aren't many places like this in the US.
Are you statistically more likely to save your own ass with the use of a gun than injuring a loved on?
Your statement is either a play on statistics or pure bullshit. Guns are used millions of times a year to prevent rape, murder, robbery etc.. without EVER FIRING A SHOT. People with CCL statistically NEVER commit gun/violent crimes or even felonies. Very FEW (statistically almost 0) people are killed a year in accidental shootings.
If your worried about accidents you should devote your time to swimming pools. They are far deadlier than a gun in the hands of a person with a CCL (or their homes etc.).
All I have to go on is my wife's 15 years of police dept. experience, where she would have to go to a family shooting 2-3 times a week and deal with shot girlfriends, kids, dogs, relatives, neighbors....you name it. Twice in her 15 years did she go to a call where someone actually scared someone away with a gun they owned legally (one was a burglary, the other was an attack outside of a bar).
It still breaks my heart when I think about a 5 year old boy back in 2002 that took a .338 out of his dad's suit coat that was hanging on a kitchen chair and shot his 2 year old sister. This guy was licensed to carry it, and the moron decided he needed a gun at a wedding he went to...then forgot to put it away when he got home.
You can do what you want...it's a free country, but when you give someone the ability to carry around a device that you can simply point at someone and take their life, I firmly believe it's too much of a resonsibility and there's no need for it. Guns for sport- fine. Guns for hunting- fine. Guns for protection- they do more harm than good.
Originally posted by: Number1
Originally posted by: Ronstang
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
What kind of handgun/holster/belt? I have a number of different handguns and some fine leather holsters for them. Of course, I can't carry legally where I live, but that doesn't stop me from being prepared.![]()
Kind of sucks to live somewhere that the government doesn't trust you enough, doesn't it? How can you be prepared when the people you run into that are going to cause you trouble are actually carrying a gun because they don't care what the law says? Nice false sense of security you live under. Being prepared in your case means either staying home or avoiding all areas where you might run into a problem. Unfortunately that could be just about anywhere these days.
What a bunch of crap as if everybody needs to carry a gun just in case.
Fuck, Ive been around for a while now and I was NEVER in a situation where i might need a friking gun. Where the fuck do you people live?
Maybe it is that dangerous to live in the US and if it is so, i am glad I don't live there.
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: Ronstang
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
What kind of handgun/holster/belt? I have a number of different handguns and some fine leather holsters for them. Of course, I can't carry legally where I live, but that doesn't stop me from being prepared.![]()
Kind of sucks to live somewhere that the government doesn't trust you enough, doesn't it? How can you be prepared when the people you run into that are going to cause you trouble are actually carrying a gun because they don't care what the law says? Nice false sense of security you live under. Being prepared in your case means either staying home or avoiding all areas where you might run into a problem. Unfortunately that could be just about anywhere these days.
How about, not living in fear...
I've lived in this state for almost 20 years and lived in Los Angeles during the LA riots in the early 90s. Honestly, the best way to stay out of trouble isn't to carry a gun. It's using common sense and avoiding trouble to begin with.
Actually, I really love living here. I'd never move away from the state I love based on gun laws or concealed carry laws. IMO only a complete idiot would do that.
Originally posted by: Fritzo
You know, statistically, you're more likely to kill a loved one with the gun you own than someone trying to harm you.
Originally posted by: Hacp
Go back to Mexico you gun lovers.
Originally posted by: Jschmuck2
And what strikes me as even funnier is that typically when you get people talking about carrying guns, it's always in flyover states. I guess someone has to guard that pie softly cooling on the windowsill.
Originally posted by: Nebor
Originally posted by: Fritzo
Originally posted by: Darwin333
Originally posted by: Fritzo
Originally posted by: Ronstang
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
What kind of handgun/holster/belt? I have a number of different handguns and some fine leather holsters for them. Of course, I can't carry legally where I live, but that doesn't stop me from being prepared.![]()
Kind of sucks to live somewhere that the government doesn't trust you enough, doesn't it? How can you be prepared when the people you run into that are going to cause you trouble are actually carrying a gun because they don't care what the law says? Nice false sense of security you live under. Being prepared in your case means either staying home or avoiding all areas where you might run into a problem. Unfortunately that could be just about anywhere these days.
You know, statistically, you're more likely to kill a loved one with the gun you own than someone trying to harm you.
Plus, if you do shoot someone that's trying to harm you in some way, only a fraction of those incidents involve "bodily" harm, so deadly force would be unwarranted. If you shot or killed someone in that circumstance, you'd be charged with manslaughter and get prison time.
I agree with the fact that if you're in an area where you feel so scared that you need to carry a gun for protection, you're not in the right area. There really aren't many places like this in the US.
Are you statistically more likely to save your own ass with the use of a gun than injuring a loved on?
Your statement is either a play on statistics or pure bullshit. Guns are used millions of times a year to prevent rape, murder, robbery etc.. without EVER FIRING A SHOT. People with CCL statistically NEVER commit gun/violent crimes or even felonies. Very FEW (statistically almost 0) people are killed a year in accidental shootings.
If your worried about accidents you should devote your time to swimming pools. They are far deadlier than a gun in the hands of a person with a CCL (or their homes etc.).
All I have to go on is my wife's 15 years of police dept. experience, where she would have to go to a family shooting 2-3 times a week and deal with shot girlfriends, kids, dogs, relatives, neighbors....you name it. Twice in her 15 years did she go to a call where someone actually scared someone away with a gun they owned legally (one was a burglary, the other was an attack outside of a bar).
It still breaks my heart when I think about a 5 year old boy back in 2002 that took a .338 out of his dad's suit coat that was hanging on a kitchen chair and shot his 2 year old sister. This guy was licensed to carry it, and the moron decided he needed a gun at a wedding he went to...then forgot to put it away when he got home.
You can do what you want...it's a free country, but when you give someone the ability to carry around a device that you can simply point at someone and take their life, I firmly believe it's too much of a resonsibility and there's no need for it. Guns for sport- fine. Guns for hunting- fine. Guns for protection- they do more harm than good.
I'm curious, how many times did your wife shoot you?
Works for me. :thumbsup:Originally posted by: SacrosanctFiend
Just a little addition. If I didn't have a carry permit I would be dead right now, instead of some hopped up, waste-of-space druggie. I've never had to use force since then, but if I hadn't been carrying, I wouldn't be here at all. Screw your statistics and your "feel-good" beliefs.
Originally posted by: LikeLinus
Originally posted by: fleshconsumed
Originally posted by: LikeLinus
Originally posted by: Excelsior
Do you have any common sense at all? Chances are if a madman with AK starts shooting in a mall people will be running away, not toward him. So if there are any CCL's around most likely they will have a clean shot at him without any bystanders around.
LikeLinus' point is irrelevent anyway. Would you rather the AKman be shooting the place up with no resistance or have a CCL take a chance at bringing him down?
Geeze, thats a tough one. :roll:
Geeze, here's a tough one...show me one mall that doesn't have armed security or security vehicles covering the lot.
I can't say I've ever been to a Mall that didn't have off duty police officers patroling the lot. Not to mention they increased force during the holiday season.
Well, Geeze [x3 now], security at Omaha mall was obviously quick enough to arrive at the scene before he had a chance to kill nine.... NOT
I guess all the CCL people got to him first!
Is it really worth the hassle and responsibility of carrying a weapon on your person all the time?
Do we really live in a society where that level of fear is warranted?
Carrying a gun is serious business and I'm not convinced that those who have been granted this privilege really understand the ramifications and responsibilities of the task.
Hell, there are cops who aren't responsible enough to carry.
Originally posted by: Fritzo
Originally posted by: Nebor
Originally posted by: Fritzo
Originally posted by: Darwin333
Originally posted by: Fritzo
Originally posted by: Ronstang
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
What kind of handgun/holster/belt? I have a number of different handguns and some fine leather holsters for them. Of course, I can't carry legally where I live, but that doesn't stop me from being prepared.![]()
Kind of sucks to live somewhere that the government doesn't trust you enough, doesn't it? How can you be prepared when the people you run into that are going to cause you trouble are actually carrying a gun because they don't care what the law says? Nice false sense of security you live under. Being prepared in your case means either staying home or avoiding all areas where you might run into a problem. Unfortunately that could be just about anywhere these days.
You know, statistically, you're more likely to kill a loved one with the gun you own than someone trying to harm you.
Plus, if you do shoot someone that's trying to harm you in some way, only a fraction of those incidents involve "bodily" harm, so deadly force would be unwarranted. If you shot or killed someone in that circumstance, you'd be charged with manslaughter and get prison time.
I agree with the fact that if you're in an area where you feel so scared that you need to carry a gun for protection, you're not in the right area. There really aren't many places like this in the US.
Are you statistically more likely to save your own ass with the use of a gun than injuring a loved on?
Your statement is either a play on statistics or pure bullshit. Guns are used millions of times a year to prevent rape, murder, robbery etc.. without EVER FIRING A SHOT. People with CCL statistically NEVER commit gun/violent crimes or even felonies. Very FEW (statistically almost 0) people are killed a year in accidental shootings.
If your worried about accidents you should devote your time to swimming pools. They are far deadlier than a gun in the hands of a person with a CCL (or their homes etc.).
All I have to go on is my wife's 15 years of police dept. experience, where she would have to go to a family shooting 2-3 times a week and deal with shot girlfriends, kids, dogs, relatives, neighbors....you name it. Twice in her 15 years did she go to a call where someone actually scared someone away with a gun they owned legally (one was a burglary, the other was an attack outside of a bar).
It still breaks my heart when I think about a 5 year old boy back in 2002 that took a .338 out of his dad's suit coat that was hanging on a kitchen chair and shot his 2 year old sister. This guy was licensed to carry it, and the moron decided he needed a gun at a wedding he went to...then forgot to put it away when he got home.
You can do what you want...it's a free country, but when you give someone the ability to carry around a device that you can simply point at someone and take their life, I firmly believe it's too much of a resonsibility and there's no need for it. Guns for sport- fine. Guns for hunting- fine. Guns for protection- they do more harm than good.
I'm curious, how many times did your wife shoot you?
Well, the fact that she didn't carry her gun unless she was on duty helped keep that at a solid "0".![]()
Originally posted by: Ronstang
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
What kind of handgun/holster/belt? I have a number of different handguns and some fine leather holsters for them. Of course, I can't carry legally where I live, but that doesn't stop me from being prepared.![]()
Kind of sucks to live somewhere that the government doesn't trust you enough, doesn't it? How can you be prepared when the people you run into that are going to cause you trouble are actually carrying a gun because they don't care what the law says? Nice false sense of security you live under. Being prepared in your case means either staying home or avoiding all areas where you might run into a problem. Unfortunately that could be just about anywhere these days.
Well put.Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
You can argue what ifs all day long but the bottom line is this: It is probable that you will live your entire life and never be witness to a situation in which you could use a gun to prevent a crime...and even if you were in a situation in which you could have used a gun to prevent a crime the chances that you would be armed and act responsibly are probably greater than the aforementioned scenario. Is it really worth the hassle and responsibility of carrying a weapon on your person all the time? Do we really live in a society where that level of fear is warranted? Do we want to?
Carrying a gun is serious business and I'm not convinced that those who have been granted this privilege really understand the ramifications and responsibilities of the task. I've carried a gun...illegally...Yeah, I'm a legal gun owner who has broken the law and carried a concealed weapon...and for damned good reason, but I'm still not convinced that those who have them are responsible enough to carry. Hell, there are cops who aren't responsible enough to carry. What makes you or me any better than them?
