• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Father kills man sexually abusing his daughter, thoughts?

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Definitely

I agree as well.

The reason why I didn't say that is because he paid his price for being there... death, really.

You have one person dead. That should mean something... rapist or not.

The reason I say that is that a person lost his life and that cannot be undone... even if the father is guilty. Doesn't bring the deceased back.

I personally don't like seeing/hearing about people dying. Yeah, some people are deserving, but death is final and shouldn't happen unless COMPLETELY justifiable....
 
Good for the dad. I mean it would of been better if he didn't kill the guy but I don't think any reasonable father upon the realization of what was happening to his 4 year old daughter, would of been able to control them selves either.

I'd be ok if he gets sentenced to like anger management classes and some community service.

It's best he killed him if the guy was trying to sexually assault his kid. Until we create Pedophisle(a secret island of pedophiles where no children are allowed, idea by Adam Carolla), pretty much ever pedophile going after small children is going to end up a repeat offender. And guess what happens to people targeted by pedophiles? They have a tendency to become pedophiles themselves. They spread themselves and we really need to end the cycle.
 
I'll gladly serve jail time to kill the scumbag who lays a finger on my daughter ....

And then you'd be locked away from your daughter at the time she needs you most.
I'm not saying you're wrong, believe me. But you do have to consider the possible consequences.
 
It was just on the news again. Apparently the dad heard his daughter screaming behind his barn. When he got there the 53 year old molester had taken the little girls underwear off and was molesting her as she was screaming. The father is 23 and the guy was a horse handler that had worked for him before.
 
Last edited:
I agree as well.

The reason why I didn't say that is because he paid his price for being there... death, really.

You have one person dead. That should mean something... rapist or not.

The reason I say that is that a person lost his life and that cannot be undone... even if the father is guilty. Doesn't bring the deceased back.

I personally don't like seeing/hearing about people dying. Yeah, some people are deserving, but death is final and shouldn't happen unless COMPLETELY justifiable....

There's 45 murders per day in the U.S. and I bet this one was most justified of the decade.
 
It was just on the news again. Apparently the dad heard his daughter screaming behind his barn. When he got there the 53 year old molester had taken the little girls underwear off and was molesting her as she was screaming.

then blind murder was the wrong thing to do. the father should have very, slowly, cut, off, his, balls, one, by, one and shoved them down his throat. THEN deform his skull until his brains ooze out.

and "mental trauma"? i dont think so. the daughter now knows that daddy will protect her. i bet she will grow up in a strong knit family.
 
And then you'd be locked away from your daughter at the time she needs you most.
I'm not saying you're wrong, believe me. But you do have to consider the possible consequences.

But you've also done the world a favor as this man will never molest anything again.
 
From the news report the father did not realize that he had killed the man and is remorseful, why I don't know, but he is.
 
I'm glad to see he beat the cr@p out of him right away instead of going home, getting a gun, and calculating his next move.

There's no way a father in this position should be charged with using his fists on a guy he just caught in the act of molesting his daughter.
 
From the news report the father did not realize that he had killed the man and is remorseful, why I don't know, but he is.

This is just an idiotic statement.

What if he realized he went too far? Should he not be remorseful?

Either case, it's good that he didn't WANT to kill the guy, he just wanted to stop the rape/molestation. Kudos to him for showing some humanity by not wanting to KILL someone....
 
I agree as well.

The reason why I didn't say that is because he paid his price for being there... death, really.
Not seeing a problem here...
You have one person dead. That should mean something... rapist or not.
If rapist then no, it doesn't mean anything
The reason I say that is that a person lost his life and that cannot be undone... even if the father is guilty. Doesn't bring the deceased back.
Not seeing a problem here...
I personally don't like seeing/hearing about people dying. Yeah, some people are deserving, but death is final and shouldn't happen unless COMPLETELY justifiable....
Sounds justifiable to me!


txt
 
The more relevant question I think is "how large of an age gap did you think there was between you and her" - if you were 30 checking out a 16 year old...you were asking for it. If you were 20 looking at a 17 year old...less of a problem. (what is the age of consent these days, 16?)

It's ok for someone in their 20s to check out 16 year olds but not if you're in your 30's?


Yeah ok :hmm:
 
SHINER, Texas – Just days after a Shiner father beat another man to death for allegedly molesting his 4-year-old girl, residents of the small town were expressing support for his actions.

It happened Saturday on the father’s rural property.

Investigators said the dead man had been hired to help the father with his horses and was at the property for a barbecue when he allegedly tried to molest the child.

But the father found out, investigators said he hit the 47-year-old man over the head so hard, the man died from his injuries.

Lavaca County Sheriff Micah Harmon said he doesn’t anticipate arresting the father, because nothing suggests the beating death happened for "any reason other than what he told us."

A grand jury will have to decide what, if any, charges will be filed against the dad.

But many Shiner residents told KHOU 11 News they didn’t think he should be charged at all.

"I don’t think he should be arrested for it. I don’t think any charges should be filed," one resident said.

"Everybody’s been talking about the same thing, and they would’ve did the same thing," another said.

"He got what he well deserved," another resident said of the dead man.

Sheriff Harmon, who is also a dad, would not say if he thought charges should be filed.

As of Monday afternoon, the names of the father and the victim had not been released.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

txt
 
All I have to say is that I hope there is some physical evidence to back up what the father is saying happened here. Everyone is simply taking his story at face value.
 
All I have to say is that I hope there is some physical evidence to back up what the father is saying happened here. Everyone is simply taking his story at face value.

Harmon said the father and daughter were at their barn with several other people to groom and care for horses there. The victim came with some of the other people, but was not well-known, if all, to the father and child.

The group later heard the girl screaming behind the barn, Harmon said. Her father ran to see what was wrong and said he saw the man allegedly sexually assaulting the child. While pulling the man away from the girl, he hit the man several times in the head, Harmon said.

http://blog.chron.com/hottopics/2012/06/dad-accused-of-beating-daughter’s-alleged-molester-to-death/
 
You are the idiot and apparently not a father of a little girl, when I find out where he is going to be buried I'm going to piss on his grave. Wanna come with me?


I am just giving the father some credit for not wanting to take someone's life even though he probably was justified. Too many people kill, kill,/rape, rape and enjoy it.
 
It was just on the news again. Apparently the dad heard his daughter screaming behind his barn. When he got there the 53 year old molester had taken the little girls underwear off and was molesting her as she was screaming. The father is 23 and the guy was a horse handler that had worked for him before.

This is just sick. How awful for the little girl. Glad dad did the right thing and terminated this piece of shit's existence.
 

That's not physical evidence. A child screaming doesn't of itself justify beating someone to death.

I'm not saying the father was in the wrong. I just take issue with people automatically taking his story as accurate when all we have is his say-so. If we're going to let people beat other people to death and just say "okey-dokey" to whatever story they tell afterwards, there are going to be a lot of busy coroner's offices.
 
Back
Top