I agree with Trader05 here. The 75GXP has gotten a bad rap in a couple of forums (storagereview being the main one). But people must recognize that just because about 30 or 40 people have posted to forums complaining that their drives have failed doesn't mean the line is bad. The 75 GXP was a VERY popular drive, and it stands to reason that because of its popularity, even at failure rates equal to that of other drives, a larger number will fail simply because of the higher quantities. Add to that the propensity for people who frequent these forums either to own or know someone who owns a 75GXP which has had problems, and whoila! We have ourselves a nice rumor about a defective product.
Every statement from IBM I've seen has continued to deny that there is any significantly higher return rate for the 75GXP drives than their other lines.
So, back to the point of this thread, I think IBM is a great hard drive manufacturer and you won't go wrong with a 60GXP.