Fantasy Football Trade Help on Steve McNair ????

[spliffstar69]

I have Steve McNair and im thinking about a trading him for either Jeff Garcia or Rich Gannon.

I would like McNair to have an MVP year again but im concerned after week 1
All 3 can scramble and run for TD's but from watching the games in week I think Garcia or Gannon may post better numbers this season.

Let me know what you guys think or if i should just keep McNair
Thanks for any advice.

My current Fantasy Roster

McNair, Steve QB TEN
Faulk, Marshall RB STL
Martin, Curtis RB NYJ
Johnson, Keyshawn WR DAL
Owens, Terrell WR PHI
Gonzalez, Tony TE KC
Vanderjagt, Mike K IND
Titans, DST DST TEN

Bench
Warner, Kurt QB NYG
Jones, Thomas RB CHI
Givens, David WR NE
Kinney, Erron TE TEN
Rackers, Neil K ARI
Bears, DST DST CHI


Compare 2003 NFL Stats

Player Att Cmp Yd TD Int Rate
McNair, Steve 400 250 3246 24 7 100.7
Garcia, Jeff 392 225 2704 18 13 80.1
Gannon, Rich 224 124 1270 6 4 73.3

Compare 2002 NFL Stats

Player Att Cmp Yd TD Int Rate
Gannon, Rich 618 418 4689 26 10 97.3
McNair, Steve 492 301 3387 22 15 84.0
Garcia, Jeff 528 328 3344 21 10 85.6

Compare Year to Date Stats

Player Att Cmp Yd TD Int Rate
Gannon, Rich 37 20 305 2 2 77.0
Garcia, Jeff 24 15 180 1 0 99.3
McNair, Steve 14 9 73 1 0 101.2

 

[Slick5150]

I think you'd be crazy to trade for either. McNair will do fine, they just ran a conservative offense in week 1.

Gannon is old and on an old, tired Raiders team. I'm guessing Kerry Collins will be starting by week 6 or 7. And Garcia? Please.

 

[gistech1978]

Originally posted by: PinwiZ
I think you'd be crazy to trade for either. McNair will do fine, they just ran a conservative offense in week 1.

Gannon is old and on an old, tired Raiders team. I'm guessing Kerry Collins will be starting by week 6 or 7. And Garcia? Please.

exactly.

gannon's way past his prime.

garcia is better but quickly on his way.

they shouldnt put up numbers like mcnair will.

 

[mpitts]

McNair played against Miami in his first game. Don't read too much into his performance.

 

[Glitchny]

dont do the trade, McNair will be solid this season

 

[nycxandy]

Stick with McNair. How can you trade away the reigning co-MVP? It's absurd.

 

[spliffstar69]

ok cool guys thanks for the advise its just i was expecting a bit more but if things dont change by week 3
l ill be looking again

those numbers againt miami were Kordell Stewet like.

Steelers fans you know what i mean.