If we have massive foreclosures?
Do you know the difference between being "under water" on a mortgage and foreclosure? It certainly doesn't sound like you do.
My wife is likely under water on her condo. Guess what we're going to do? If you said "Continue the payments until someone buys it so you can break even or even accept a small loss if necessary" -- you're correct. If you said "Send in the keys to the bank! OMG, a foreclosure!" -- you are wrong.
Here is the problem. You have an entire group of people buying homes to flip them for a quick profit. A lot of these guys got caught with their pants down when the bubble burst. Frankly, I don't give a shit if they have to take a hit to unload the property -- they treated it as an investment and guess what? Investments sometimes tank and tough crap for them. Where is my bailout for any of my stocks that might have tanked?
As for the people who didn't buy a home as an investment but instead, bought it as a place to live -- why would being "under water" concern them unless they had to sell or wanted a HELOC? I bought a new house in late 2008. I'm not under water on it. But let's assume I am for this argument. So what? I bought the house to live in, not to use as an investment or collateral for a loan. My house payment every month is going to be the same whether I am $100K under or have $100K in equity. I'm going to have to pay to live anywhere and I can afford my house payment, so why would I panic if the house were under water when I intend to live there the rest of my working career?
And if you're next going to tell me that my scenario above isn't correct for many because those people have adjustable rate mortgages that are about to reset, my reaction (again) is -- so? Why is it those of us who make wise financial decisions are the ones punished? Don't tell me "If you don't, you'll suffer MORE!" BULLSHIT. That is blackmail -- give us your money or we'll make you suffer more! The fact is that these people who are getting killed (or who are about to get killed) with mortgage resets are freaking idiots. For starters, many took loans like that because the house payment was deceptively low and it allowed them to buy more house than they could realistically afford. Secondly, anyone with two ounces of financial sense knows that if you get a loan like that, you may get hammered so the goal is to a) get a fixed loan to begin with or b) re-fi before the reset occurs. It isn't my fault they weren't smart enough to do that, and I shouldn't have to pay because of irresponsibility and people buying houses they had no business buying.
As another poster said, you are spreading FUD. Seriously, stop.