• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Fallujah situation 'disastrous', charity says

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Originally posted by: Sultan
Originally posted by: Riprorin
LIVE FROM FALLUJAH
By Michelle Malkin · November 07, 2004 01:06 AM
...
Link

Not that I dispute the veracity of this blog, but I find it quite humorous that a Marine writing a letter to his dad fails to put in a single personal word. I would at least let my dad know I am fine or dont worry about me, or say hi to mom, or something like that...

I agree. I don't know of any soldier ( family or friends ) that would include such non-sense as that in a personal letter to their parents.

P.S. Michelle Malkin = a wannabe failed Ann Coulter
 
Aid Convoy Reaches Falluja, Gunmen Stay in Mosul

Sat Nov 13, 2004 06:47 PM ET

By Michael Georgy and Omar Anwar

FALLUJA, Iraq (Reuters) - A Red Crescent convoy reached Falluja on Saturday with the first aid since U.S.-led forces began blasting their way in five days ago, and U.S. and Iraqi officials said only pockets of rebel resistance remained.

The offensive on Falluja has fueled violence across Iraq's Sunni Muslim heartland, especially in the northern city of Mosul where guerrillas fought on and kept control of some districts.

The U.S.-backed interim government, which has vowed to crush a widespread insurgency before planned nationwide elections in January, said Baghdad's international airport -- initially closed on Monday for 48 hours -- would remain shut indefinitely.

"Conditions in Falluja are catastrophic," said Iraqi Red Crescent spokeswoman Firdoos al-Abadi, whose organization says there are severe shortages of food and medicine in the city.

Abadi said the Red Crescent's five trucks and three ambulances had arrived at the main hospital on the western edge of Falluja, some 50 km (30 miles) west of Baghdad.

It is unclear how many of Falluja's 300,000 people remain in the city, but about half are believed to have fled before the ground assault began on Monday. There has also been no firm word on civilian casualties.

"OPERATIONS ALMOST OVER"

National Security Minister of State Kasim Daoud said more than 1,000 guerrillas had been killed in Falluja, which the interim government and Washington say has been a base for Saddam Hussein supporters and foreign Islamic fighters.

"The operations are almost over. There are only pockets of resistance left," Daoud told a news conference, adding that around 200 guerrillas had been captured.

"The coalition and Iraqi forces have completed the move, for all practical purposes, from the north down to the south (in Falluja)," said Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld.

"I don't mean to suggest that it's concluded. It's not, for sure," Rumsfeld told reporters during a visit to Panama.

U.S. Major Clark Watson said American forces expected to overcome the rebels in their last main redoubt, the Shuhada area in the south of the city, within 72 hours but were facing tough resistance from Syrian, Chechen and other foreign fighters.
Islamist groups, including one led by al Qaeda ally Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, vowed in a video to take their fight in Falluja to all corners of Iraq. No independent verification of the tape's authenticity was immediately available.

"In response to the crimes and mass annihilation the Muslims of Falluja are facing, the groups Qaeda Organization of Jihad in Iraq, the Islamic Army, the 1920 Revolution Brigades ... announce the spread of the battle to all governorates and parts of Iraq," one gunman read from a handwritten piece of paper.

He called on employees of the interim government not to go to work and to launch a civil disobedience campaign.

BUSH WARNING

President Bush warned guerrilla violence in Iraq could worsen, despite the Falluja operation, in the countdown to the January elections.

"The desperation of the killers will grow, and the violence could escalate. The success of democracy in Iraq would be a crushing blow to the forces of terror, and the terrorists know it," Bush said in his weekly radio address.

The U.S. military said 22 U.S. and five Iraqi soldiers had been killed in the Falluja battle.

Falluja had been without power and water for days, said an Iraqi journalist who left the city on Friday.

"Some people hadn't prepared well. They didn't stock up on tinned food. They didn't think it would be this bad," he said, asking not to be named.

In Mosul, gunmen were still roaming the streets in some districts after storming and looting nine police stations on Thursday, but Iraqi and U.S. forces were guarding some of the key bridges that span the Tigris River, residents said.

The U.S. military said the city was calmer on Saturday, with only sporadic fighting in some areas. It said three of five Tigris bridges had reopened and a curfew had been lifted.

In other districts, vigilantes set up roadblocks and patrolled neighborhoods to deter thieves and looters.
The Falluja assault and a week-old state of emergency have failed to quell unrest in other Sunni cities, many of which are under curfew.

The interim government closed Baghdad airport to civilian flights before the start of the Falluja offensive and it was due to have been in place for only a few days.

But an official in Prime Minister Iyad Allawi's office said on Saturday: "It is closed until further notice."

The government, however, reopened two border crossings with Syria and Jordan for festivities marking the end of the Muslim holy month of Ramadan.

(Additional reporting by Luke Baker and Lin Noueihed in Baghdad and Maher al-Thanoon in Mosul)

 
Originally posted by: sixone
Originally posted by: Sultan
Again, without wanting to dispute the veracity of the letter, but why is this soldier writing a more or less political message to his dad without even letting him know he is fine and in good health?

The site says it is an "excerpt". If I was reproducing a letter from someone to their dad, I'd cut out all the personal stuff, too, out of respect for their privacy. Plus it's not relevant to but distracts from the topic.

Thats a HUGE "excerpt" and a VERY detailed one at that from a Marine to write to his father. Interestingly, I have been unable to find the said blog at Brian Shavings
 
Originally posted by: 0marTheZealot
The best propaganda is something you think that isn't but it is.

:disgust:

You could say that anything, is propaganda, and merely restate your line no matter how many facts there are to the contrary. While your statement may be completely true, it is also completely vacuous.


On topic, this is really starting to worry me. Will Iraq ever stabilize? Can't America just call in the UN to clean up some of this mess?

I'm worried that China or other ambitious countries will see an opportunity with much of America's army tied down in Iraq.

Edit🙁 The blog may indeed be propaganda, I'm just pointing out the flaw in using 0mar's sentence as an arguement. For example:

You could say that an article about charitable humanitarian aid by Amnesty International is propaganda. When people reply, but why do you think so, they have such a good reputation! you could say ah hah! The best propaganda is something you think isn't but is!
 
The try to kill Americans and Americans try to kill them. Unfortunately for them Americans are better at it.
 
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Originally posted by: conjur
Originally posted by: Riprorin
LIVE FROM FALLUJAH
By Michelle Malkin · November 07, 2004 01:06 AM
Keep this fvcking BS out of my threads.

Sorry to interrupt your propaganda fest by posting a letter from a United States Marine bravely serving in Fallujah.
FOAD, troll.
 
U.S. Says Aid Convoy Can't Go Into Falluja Today
http://story.news.yahoo.com/ne...;cid=564&ncid=1480
FALLUJA, Iraq (Reuters) - An Iraqi Red Crescent aid convoy waiting at the edge of Falluja will not be allowed to enter the city center on Sunday, a U.S. Marine officer said.

"They will not be allowed to cross the bridge today," Captain Adam Collier told Reuters at Falluja hospital, where the convoy is waiting to cross the Euphrates river into the main part of the embattled Iraqi city. He cited security reasons.

The Iraqi Red Crescent sent seven trucks and ambulances to Falluja on Saturday, hoping to get food, blankets, water purification tables and medicine to hundreds of families trapped inside the city during the past six days of fighting.

To enter the city proper, the convoy will have to pass over one of two bridges spanning the Euphrates. U.S. forces have said that those bridges remain unsafe, even though the military has said it has taken almost full control of Falluja.

"We don't know when the bridge will be open for civilian traffic," Collier said.

Red Crescent officials, who are also trying to get aid to thousands of families who fled Falluja ahead of the offensive and are now sheltering in nearby towns and villages, said they would wait in Falluja's hospital until they can go in.

"We will wait for permission and we will stay here tonight," Jamal al-Karbouli, the leader of the convoy, said.

Those trapped inside the city, whose population was put at about 300,000 before the offensive but has fallen to around 60,000 according to some estimates, say they are reaching a point of desperation.

"Our situation is very hard," said one resident contacted by telephone in the central Hay al-Dubat neighborhood. "We don't have food or water. My seven children all have severe diarrhea.

"One of my sons was wounded by shrapnel last night and he's bleeding, but I can't do anything to help him," he told Reuters
.



http://www.globalissuesgroup.com/geneva/protocol1.html
Art. 54. Protection of objects indispensable to the survival of the civilian population

2. It is prohibited to attack, destroy, remove or render useless objects indispensable to the survival of the civilian population, such as food-stuffs, agricultural areas for the production of foodstuffs, crops, livestock, drinking water installations and supplies and irrigation works, for the specific purpose of denying them for their sustenance value to the civilian population or to the adverse Party, whatever the motive, whether in order to starve out civilians, to cause them to move away, or for any other motive.


Bush Taps White House Counsel Alberto Gonzales As Nation's First Hispanic Attorney General
http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/wireStory?id=243266
Gonzales drew criticism after the Sept. 11, 2001, terror attacks when he wrote a memo in which Bush claimed the right to waive anti-torture law and international treaties providing protections to prisoners of war. That position drew fire from human rights groups, who said it helped lead to the type of abuses uncovered in the Abu Ghraib prison scandal.

Specifically, Gonzales' memo said the Geneva Convention that had long governed the treatment of prisoners did not apply to al-Qaida or the war in Afghanistan. The memo called some of the Geneva Convention's provisions "quaint."
 
Huh?

Aid workers enter Fallujah as U.S. forces mop up
By UNITED PRESS INTERNATIONAL

Published November 13, 2004


FALLUJAH, Iraq -- Humanitarian aid workers entered Fallujah Saturday, six days after a U.S.-Iraqi assault started on the insurgent stronghold, the Telegraph reported.

An Iraqi Red Crescent aid convoy comprised of some 30 volunteers with five trucks and three ambulances passed a U.S. checkpoint and entered the northern part of the Sunni city, now nearly deserted.


Meanwhile, small groups of Muslim insurgents in Fallujah surrendered Saturday as U.S. forces closed in on the last fighters of Abu Musab Zarqawi's terror network.

At least 22 U.S. soldiers have been killed during the six-day operation and about 170 troops have been wounded, 40 of who returned to the battlefield, CNN reported. Meanwhile, about 600 insurgents have been killed and 151 have been detained. Estimates of civilian casualties were not available.

Insurgents in groups of five to 20 have started surrendering in northeast Fallujah, where the U.S. military is in control, said a U.S. official.

Marines closed in on what was believed to be the last pocket of continued resistance in the southern part of the city.

An Iraqi official in Baghdad said numerous foreign fighters have been detained in Fallujah's fighting, including 10 from Iran.

Link

 
Cnjur, so you think that the US Marines are targeting Iraqi civilians?

Why not blame the insurgents who are stroing weapons caches in schools and mosques and are using women and children as human shields?
 
Those people are interfering with American world dominion and will have to die. We voted their deaths when we voted for Bush. It's the will of the American people.
 
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Cnjur, so you think that the US Marines are targeting Iraqi civilians?

Why not blame the insurgents who are stroing weapons caches in schools and mosques and are using women and children as human shields?

"...anything that moves..."

 
Originally posted by: stratman
Originally posted by: 0marTheZealot
The best propaganda is something you think that isn't but it is.

:disgust:

You could say that anything, is propaganda, and merely restate your line no matter how many facts there are to the contrary. While your statement may be completely true, it is also completely vacuous.


On topic, this is really starting to worry me. Will Iraq ever stabilize? Can't America just call in the UN to clean up some of this mess?

I'm worried that China or other ambitious countries will see an opportunity with much of America's army tied down in Iraq.

Edit🙁 The blog may indeed be propaganda, I'm just pointing out the flaw in using 0mar's sentence as an arguement. For example:

You could say that an article about charitable humanitarian aid by Amnesty International is propaganda. When people reply, but why do you think so, they have such a good reputation! you could say ah hah! The best propaganda is something you think isn't but is!

Good points. Iraq has been getting increasingly unstable/violent since spring and there seems to be no stopping it.

Regarding China and the US another good point. Though few dare to admit it, Oil is certainly a part of the reason that the US is in Iraq. With China's growing appetite for Oil and the fact that the bulk of the US Military's fighting force is closeby and tied up in conflict, I'm sure some Chinese Generals/Politicians are begining to think of the opportunity to get some Oil and cause significant harm to the US's power capability at the same time. Whether such an act could ultimately succeed is almost besides the point, temptation doesn't always get dealt with in a reasonable manner.
 
Puppet or not, the IRAQI GOVERNMENT (if you can really call it that), is spearheading this - or at the very least right there with the US (granted, their troops are nigh useless compared to the US ones), so it is supported by Allawi.
 
Originally posted by: CADsortaGUY
Originally posted by: conjur
Originally posted by: Riprorin
LIVE FROM FALLUJAH
By Michelle Malkin · November 07, 2004 01:06 AM
Keep this fvcking BS out of my threads.

Yeah, how dare he give an account from a soldier there...it might take away from your apparant quest to make everything in Iraq seem bad...

CsG


LOL .... :laugh:


:thumbsup:
 
When you start a thread, it is public domain!!!!!!!!!!!! We know you hate the truth as defined by "not in support of my BS," but get over it!
 
Don't Worry by the time we are done, it will make the 2 million+dead in Vietnam look like a walk in the ball park. B*stards!

and of coarse everything will be flattened since we can't have no one going against our occupation.

What we are doing there makes Sadam look like an Angel. Sh*t they must hate Americans big time now!!
So again, how are we liberating them by distroying them?

 
From Conjur's link:

Ahmed al-Rawi, of the Red Cross, said: "Movement is impossible inside the city. The residents fear the snipers and therefore the wounded find no help and bleed to death." On the eve of the assault, the interim Prime Minister, Ayad Allawi, imposed a 24-hour curfew on Fallujah and ordered roads in the area closed.

Do you really think that it's a good idea for the Marines to let the Red Crescent into the city to help the 150 families trapped in the the city center when there are insurgent snipers still on the loose?

 
We keep on creating more and more "terrorists" by invading nations and bossing them around. How many kids in Fallujah will grow up and despise the US? Many. Unfortunately the people on tv have you believe that they "don't like our way of life and our jealous". I guess they are right. They don't like how the US invades their country and bombs them to shreds for their oil.
 
Originally posted by: BarneyFife
We keep on creating more and more "terrorists" by invading nations and bossing them around. How many kids in Fallujah will grow up and despise the US? Many. Unfortunately the people on tv have you believe that they "don't like our way of life and our jealous". I guess they are right. They don't like how the US invades their country and bombs them to shreds for their oil.
And the 60,000 innocent civilians still in Falluja suffer for the arrogance of Bush.
 
According to al-Jazeera (a source that you will trust) there are 150 families in the center of Fallujah:

"The Red Crescent sent a convoy of essential goods along with 53 volunteers and three doctors from Baghdad to attend to people in Falluja.

It believes that 150 families are still in the heart of Falluja, but it is concerned about the plight of tens of thousands of people living in refugee camps and villages dotted outside."

Link

They are not being allowed in BECAUSE IT ISN'T SAFE DUE TO THE INSURGENT SNIPERS.
 
Originally posted by: conjur
Originally posted by: BarneyFife
We keep on creating more and more "terrorists" by invading nations and bossing them around. How many kids in Fallujah will grow up and despise the US? Many. Unfortunately the people on tv have you believe that they "don't like our way of life and our jealous". I guess they are right. They don't like how the US invades their country and bombs them to shreds for their oil.
And the 60,000 innocent civilians still in Falluja suffer for the arrogance of Bush.

😕 I'm lost on that conclusion.
 
Originally posted by: Sultan
Originally posted by: Riprorin
LIVE FROM FALLUJAH
By Michelle Malkin · November 07, 2004 01:06 AM
...
Link

Not that I dispute the veracity of this blog, but I find it quite humorous that a Marine writing a letter to his dad fails to put in a single personal word. I would at least let my dad know I am fine or dont worry about me, or say hi to mom, or something like that...

Ha ha. Yes, American propaganda defies all common sense.
 
.co.uk, again, what a surprise.

And why do all you isolationist lefties all of a sudden care about Iraqi people dying, you didn't care about them before the war.....Move to Switzerland.

Are the lives of the Iraqi people only important to you when they can be used for the leftnutz politcal gain?







 
Originally posted by: Tylanner
.co.uk, again, what a surprise.

And why do all you isolationist lefties all of a sudden care about Iraqi people dying, you didn't care about them before the war.....Move to Switzerland.

Are the lives of the Iraqi people only important to you when they can be used for the leftnutz politcal gain?
Uh...you mean the neocons' political gain. I don't seem to recall any Bush-God fanbois protesting the war before the invasion.

BTW, nice of you to dismiss the Independent. The Independent was named National Newspaper of the Year at the British Press Awards 2004.
 
Originally posted by: Gen Stonewall
Originally posted by: conjur
Originally posted by: BarneyFife
We keep on creating more and more "terrorists" by invading nations and bossing them around. How many kids in Fallujah will grow up and despise the US? Many. Unfortunately the people on tv have you believe that they "don't like our way of life and our jealous". I guess they are right. They don't like how the US invades their country and bombs them to shreds for their oil.
And the 60,000 innocent civilians still in Falluja suffer for the arrogance of Bush.
😕 I'm lost on that conclusion.
Of course you are.
 
Back
Top