Originally posted by: Fear No Evil
April 13th is Tax Freedom Day.. which means every penny the average American has made up until today goes to the government. Its kind of freightening when you think about it. It was wrong when Bush did it, its wrong when Obama is doing it. Government needs to FINALLY say enough is enough and we need to stop spending! How long until we are working 50% of the time just to support government spending?
I'm trying to figure out what I pay in federal taxes (as it appears your rant is mainly targeted at the federal gov't). I file as single and fall into the 25% tax bracket (which is somewhat a misnomer as only part of my income is taxed at 25%). However, with deductions and credits my effective rate is quite a bit lower. My fiance and I were helped a bit due to regional disasters and us receiving extra money due to lifetime learning credits, too be honest, but even still our effective rates were quite a bit lower than 33%. Without the benefit of living in a disaster area, my effective rate was 10%. This is after deductions I get to take for student loan interest, capital losses (which amounted to quite a bit last year), charity, and my normal lifetime learning credit. With the expanded LLC, I paid an effective rate of 5%. My fiance graduated last May but still fell into the 25% bracket. With the expanded LLC, she paid an effective rate of 2%. Without the expanded LLC, she would've paid about 15% (she basically has no student loan debt). Neither of us can claim the mortgage interest deduction, which I am sure is not true of many people here.
When I look up the per capita income for my area, I see that we each made quite a bit more than the average. In fact, we both make more than the national median for individual income for people 25 or older. I doubt most people get to claim the LLC, but I'm sure many people get to claim mortgage interest.
Throw in another 7.65% for SS and Medicare and I still fall way short of 33% in federal obligations. I owed about 4.5% to the state (where I only get deductions for capital losses and student loan interest) and I live in a relatively high-tax state. I guess I just don't feel like I'm hugely burdened by the gov't or that I work just to pay them. Maybe I'd hit 33% if I included every tax I pay, but then you can't really blame the federal government for that as I imagine the largest component would be property tax and sales tax.
I guess I just don't see why you'd levy so much blame against the federal gov't for this 33% burden when the average American almost certainly pays much less than 33% in federal taxes. Maybe if I fell in a higher bracket and couldn't claim any deduction I'd get close, but then again most Americans have some sort of deduction they can claim and fall into a much lower bracket.
After a cursory Google search, I found that the CBO claims the effective tax rate in 2005 was 20.5%, about what I would expect given what I pay. You can read the article
here. And the 20.5% number is a bit skewed as it is an average of all Americans, including the highest quintile. If we assume that the average American is in the middle quintile, then the effective rate for all federal taxes is 14.2%. That includes social insurance taxes... well, you can read the article.