Elder Scrolls Online - worth trying now?

Achilles97

Senior member
May 10, 2000
401
14
81
I have not kept up with the developments of ESO since the initial reviews upon release. I am considering giving it a try and I would appreciate any comments you may have.

I have always enjoyed the ES single-player games from Daggerdall to Skyrim.

As for MMOs, I played Wow in a guild during the early years and I recently started playing again casually doing solo content. It's not really grabbing my interest anymore.

I do not really care to play in a large, organized guild but rather I would like to just play occasionally at my own pace. Would ESO be a good game to play casually?

Thanks !
 

nurturedhate

Golden Member
Aug 27, 2011
1,767
774
136
I tried it again a little less than a year ago and while the majority of the bugs were fixed it still felt rather meh at best. If you are looking for an Elder Scrolls game to play that you haven't played, sure, it works. If you want a decent mmo that's not WoW then look at Final Fantasy 14.
 

Juiblex

Banned
Sep 26, 2016
500
253
136
There is nothing about the game that is even remotely fun. IMHO.

1) Solo content is mainly on the world map (divided into zones.) Each area is the same. Just grinding quests. Fetch this item, kill 10 mobs, return to me, I'm 10 feet away. Any solo dungeons are the size of the view radius (or smaller) so nothing complex. Just simple 4 hallway dungeons with a few rooms. You can do all dungeons on in the zone map in an hour if you knew where they are and fought through the whole thing. There is no challenge. There is no exploring aspect of the game.
2) Group content is instant dungeons which are the same as the solo dungeons. A few rooms and a few hallways. With a boss with a special attach you need to worry about. But you can run a dungeon with people who have done it before and finish it within 5 minutes. There is no challenge. No exploration.
3) PVP content is an overland capture the flag type zerging gameplay. Everybody gets scaled to the same level/power. And its basically whoever sees someone first and gets within range of their "stun" attack and who brings enough bodies to the fight wins. There is no challenge, only frustration.
4) Tradeskills you just have to do the above and bag up the tradeskill components and click the combine button. Just requires farming the solo areas of the map and pick mushrooms
5) The player skill tree is sub par at best. You level, you put a point into something to make it stronger, each character class has 4-5 main abilities they get, then some shared abilities that are based on faction/race, etc. A new ability may appear after you place 5 points into something. My cleric has "heal", "heal area", "heal over time", "cast a damage spell with a snare effect", and "special heal that heals everybody in area and myself a lot and over time every 20 minutes."
6) Combat is range attack/spell over and over until its within melee range, hit it once with your staff and its dead. Rinse and repeat.

The problem is there is nothing hard/challenging/unique or anything about it that will draw a player into it. It's even more dumbed down and generic compared to WoW. They might as well call it "MMO with friends" or "elderscrolls ville" and place it on facebook.

I'm not trying to be too negative but I've started it a few times for a few days each and scratch my head wondering how or why they made this game and who it was made for. BTW, even though it sort of looks and plays like an ES single player game. It has none of the spirit or atmosphere of them. I thought I could live with an MMO version of a single player ES game but what you get feels nothing like an ES game even if it looks like one. Mainly because they added classes, removed any challenge, made all the maps really small (overland and dungeons). Removed any AI. Added more quick paced grinding and quest hubs.
 

Achilles97

Senior member
May 10, 2000
401
14
81
Wow thanks for the posts. I appreciate the details and it has convinced me to pass on ESO and look elsewhere.
 

Mem

Lifer
Apr 23, 2000
21,476
13
81
I do not really care to play in a large, organized guild but rather I would like to just play occasionally at my own pace. Would ESO be a good game to play casually?

Thanks !

ESO you will either like or hate, it is very solo friendly and you don't need to group, I do like some of the dark brotherhood quests and you can now purchase housing in the game, new Morrowind content is being released next week, the best answer I can give without being bias one way or another is to try the game yourself, you can play it at your own pace but the main thing is are you going to like it, only you can answer that question.

I do play it from time to time myself, crafting is pretty easy to do and not really complex. Lots of players in the game as well.
 

Achilles97

Senior member
May 10, 2000
401
14
81
When I played the single-player ES games, I really enjoyed just exploring and collecting items. I liked to scout out areas to rob and add those items to my collection which I put on display in my house. I liked to keep a public profile of a good-standing citizen so all my thievery was done without getting caught - I wouldn't kill innocent civilians or kill law enforcement. The Thieves Guild was fun but I actually preferred self-driven exploration.

The houses in ESO - are they public or private/instanced for only your character?

Thanks!