E8400 vs Q9550 processor on a budget game system

Hav0k99

Platinum Member
May 10, 2002
2,968
0
71
This is for a backup computer upstairs for guests to game on. It's a Dell w/ the following
(OC is not an option) :

4 GBs of DDR3
ATI HD5770 1GB
SB Gamer X-Fi sound card
Windows 7 64bit

The games I want to run are:

Diablo 3
Battlefield 3
Skyrim
Modern Warfare 3
 

borisvodofsky

Diamond Member
Feb 12, 2010
3,606
0
0
Diablo 3 will run on anything that's not a netbook or cellphone. It's a whore like that.

BF3 and SKY will favor the Q9550 because they like m0re C0res.

MW3 is intensive on neither the CPU nor GPU.


I don't think you're gonna find a great price on 8400s and 9550s though.

I was right, just looked up ebay for ya, 8400 going for near $100 and 9550 going for near $200. WTFFFFF

Unless you have those processors already, you should actually sell them, LOL and buy yourself a new 2500k or 3570k
 
Last edited:

2is

Diamond Member
Apr 8, 2012
4,281
131
106
Q9550 by a loooooong shot is better. But they aren't cheap. I wish I had one just so I can sell it and make some money.
 

borisvodofsky

Diamond Member
Feb 12, 2010
3,606
0
0
Q9550 by a loooooong shot is better. But they aren't cheap. I wish I had one just so I can sell it and make some money.

Frrraaak.. I know right???? $200 WHYYYYyyyyy.. Whoo are these people.. I want to meet them. :confused:


BUT, if you want to play starcraft the 8400 might do a little better, because it can clock higher.
 

Jacky60

Golden Member
Jan 3, 2010
1,123
0
0
I' avoid both but get the quad caore as 8400 (I loved mine and it easily did 4ghz) will really slow you down in games using more than 2 cores which is pretty much all you'll want to play these days. E8400 was great 4 years ago just not today!
 

Hav0k99

Platinum Member
May 10, 2002
2,968
0
71
Thanks everyone for your input. I happen to have both these processors and wasn't sure if quad processing was here yet to be able to be useful in gaming.
 

BonzaiDuck

Lifer
Jun 30, 2004
16,663
2,038
126
Diablo 3 will run on anything that's not a netbook or cellphone. It's a whore like that.

BF3 and SKY will favor the Q9550 because they like m0re C0res.

MW3 is intensive on neither the CPU nor GPU.


I don't think you're gonna find a great price on 8400s and 9550s though.

I was right, just looked up ebay for ya, 8400 going for near $100 and 9550 going for near $200. WTFFFFF

Unless you have those processors already, you should actually sell them, LOL and buy yourself a new 2500k or 3570k

Dominant-firm or duopoly situation between AMD and Intel. If Intel has a serious edge, it's a near-monopoly situation. If there were ten different CPU makers for desktops and workstations, you'd see them introduce product at an MSRP and then the prices would drop within a year and before they discontinued production -- as a result of cutthroat competition. I think INtel has -- for years -- maintained a strict discipline on pricing through some sort of "Intel product distributor" membership or something with a similar moniker.

But you [and maybe others here] are right. It would be false economy to -- say -- get an $80 mATX LGA775 motherboard, pay for the processor and DDR2 RAM, even for a "guest" computer. For nearly the same price, you could get gen-2 socket-1155 (even an I3 core) with DDR3 and a mobo probably in the range of $135.

I suspect, on the pricing, that they hold out for people already in possession of an LGA775 system who don't want to buy a new one or want to avoid the data transfer and software reinstallation they'd have to do on a rig of the latest or newer generation CPU. Or -- there's surplus inventory in "retail-box," and it hasn't dried up yet.
 

nenforcer

Golden Member
Aug 26, 2008
1,779
20
81
You will be fine on the E8400 on all four of those games and that video card.

The only thing you won't be able to play is Battlefield 3 Multiplayer which definitely requires a quad core. You would need the Q9550 for that.
 

Don Karnage

Platinum Member
Oct 11, 2011
2,865
0
0
This is for a backup computer upstairs for guests to game on. It's a Dell w/ the following
(OC is not an option) :

4 GBs of DDR3
ATI HD5770 1GB
SB Gamer X-Fi sound card
Windows 7 64bit

The games I want to run are:

Diablo 3
Battlefield 3
Skyrim
Modern Warfare 3

Dont waste your money on 775 chips. Grab a Sandy Celeron if you want a backup computer. It'll game better then a Q
 

VirtualLarry

No Lifer
Aug 25, 2001
56,587
10,225
126
Dont waste your money on 775 chips. Grab a Sandy Celeron if you want a backup computer. It'll game better then a Q

For raw performance, I'd still much rather have a Q9550 (and OCed of course), rather than a meager un-overclockable SB Celeron G530 or G620. Sure, the SB Cellys perform well for the price, but they are no substitute for a true quad-core at 3.0 or better.