Droid Razr Maxx HD mini review

dguy6789

Diamond Member
Dec 9, 2002
8,558
3
76
I’ve had the Razr Maxx HD for over a week now and have been putting it through some pretty heavy use and felt like sharing my thoughts on the phone.

Build

The most striking first impression the phone gives is the build quality and design. The front is glass with a very thin hardened plastic bezel. Below that is a ring of aluminum that encircles the entire phone. There’s a Kevlar backing that is about as thick as the aluminum band on the Maxx. The non Maxx Kevlar is a bit thinner but otherwise the two phones are identical.

The phone feels extremely solid and dense. It gives an impression almost like an expensive watch; not unlike the iPhone 4S. There’s no creaking or give. It’s clear that Moto paid a great attention to detail when building this phone. It’s a very boxy design that seems to have made no effort to be ergonomic. I would describe this phone as feeling similar to what an iPhone 4S would feel like if it were the size of the Galaxy S3.

The front of the phone has a Motorola logo at the top and a Verizon logo at the bottom. The microphone is on the front of the phone at the edge of the bezel slightly to the right of the Verizon logo. I like that the microphone is on the front of the phone instead of the bottom. Right below the Motorola logo is the LED notification light(which is shaped very much like the earpiece) and the earpiece. Slightly to the right is the front facing camera. The right side of the phone has the sleep key and the volume rocker. Both of these keys are made of metal and feel very industrial. The sleep key is grooved like a rumble strip on a highway so you can’t possibly confuse It by feel with the volume rocker and the volume rocker has raised points on the end so it’s easy to feel where it ends on either side. The top of the phone has the typical 3.5mm headphone jack. On the left is the micro sim and microSD card tray(which requires the included tool or a paper clip to open). This tray does not feel at all wobbly or cheap(it does not move at all without using the tool) like it could break like the one on the Droid Razr did. Below the tray are the micro HDMI and micro USB ports. There’s nothing on the bottom of the phone except two exposed hex screws.
On the back of the phone at the top from left to right you’ll find the LED flash. Below that is the rear microphone. The 8 megapixel camera is in the center and the speaker is on the right. In the center is the Motorola logo and below that the 4G LTE and Verizon branding. At the very bottom you’ll find some fine print wording including the model number, FCC information, and the phrase designed by Motorola assembled in China.

The phone gives a very good impression that it’s a high quality premium device. It’s a pretty far cry from the plastic phones of HTC and Samsung that have been common place most of this year.

Good set of pictures of the phone from Moto: http://www.motorola.com/us/consumer...html?selectedTab=tab-4&cgid=mobile-phones#tab

Screen

The screen is a 4.7 inch 1280x720 Super AMOLED HD display that uses Gorilla Glass. I’m not sure if it uses GG 1 or 2 but I’d imagine it is probably 1 since they aren’t advertising it as using 2 anywhere. Coming from a Galaxy Nexus the display is noticeably nicer looking than what was in the Nexus. The improvement in viewing angle is the main thing I’m noticing. With the screen on auto brightness I am having no difficulty using the phone outdoors in direct sunlight here in Florida.

Camera

The camera on the phone is pretty good. I’d describe it as above average and definitely a competitive a camera performance and feature set wise with the One X and Galaxy S3 although I’d definitely give the nod to those two. The camera is very fast, has a burst shot mode, and the image quality is significantly better than the Galaxy Nexus(the phone I’m coming from). The software detects low light conditions and gives you a suggestion to enable HDR mode which dramatically improves the quality of low light photos. This is a really, really nice touch.

Battery Life

Battery life on this phone is very solid to put it lightly. 9 hours of Pandora streaming on 4G LTE and the phone has over 60% left. This phone will make it through a day with the heaviest usage I can throw at it with the screen on auto brightness(That kind of use does require nightly charging however). For normal everyday use one could definitely get away with charging this once every other night or maybe even every three nights. This is the first phone I have ever had where 4G LTE battery life was so good that I would never consider turning 4G off.

Software

The software on the phone is very close to stock Android. It has all of the Galaxy Nexus notification sounds and ringtones and almost all of the settings and menus are exactly the same. All of the vanilla Android widgets are there as well.
There are a handful of changes and tweaks to the UI. A few apps have different icons and a different color scheme. One nice touch that non stock Android phones tend to have but vanilla Android does not have is notifications on the app icon itself such as a number telling you how many new texts you have received. That kind of stuff is present here. I don’t remember if the stock Android calendar app did this or not but the calendar app on here changes the app icon to show you the appropriate number for the day of the month each day. The new Motorola circle widget is pretty solid.

The home screen works more like iOS than Android. Your home screen is the left most screen here. Moving to the right gives you a screen that asks if you’d like to add another screen(You can have a maximum of 7 home screens just like most modern Android phones). Moving to the left from the home screen brings up the quick settings screen that lets you toggle ringtone, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, GPS, mobile data, and airplane mode. While different I don’t feel like any of these changes hurt the experience in any way. I rather like the quick settings menu.

The phone uses the on screen buttons just like the Nexus phones. They behave the same as on the Nexus in that they move around depending on which way the phone is oriented and they go away completely when doing certain full screen things like YouTube.
The phone comes with a pretty large number of Verizon apps preinstalled. Most of them can not be disabled or uninstalled. That said I haven't really found them to get in the way or be like some bloatware of the past has been.

The stock keyboard is virtually identical to the stock ICS keyboard. It could be placebo or because of the minutely larger screen or maybe even a better digitizer but I find my typing to be noticeably better on this than on the Galaxy Nexus.

General usage performance is a whole lot faster than the Galaxy Nexus on ICS but not as smooth as the Nexus on Jellybean. Web browsing performance in Chrome is significantly smoother than on the Nexus regardless of Jellybean. General usage performance is more or less exactly what is expected from the Snapdragon S4 and a next gen phone; very, very good.

I have not been able to get my photos in the gallery to be able to upload to Picasa using the share button in the gallery even though there is a Picasa option in there. Other forums have told me that Verizon is blocking it but other people have reported that it works fine on their phone. I haven’t spent a lot of time trying to troubleshoot it so I couldn’t say for sure yet.

General Stuff

The 32GB of onboard storage is not partitioned; it behaves as one big contiguous block. Every bit of it is available for apps or for files just like with the Galaxy Nexus. When plugging into the PC it asks if you’d like to install some Motorola connectivity software. I did install it but haven’t played with it any. Moving files to and from the phone’s internal storage when connected to a PC works exactly the same as on the Galaxy Nexus; just drag and drop with no need to switch to mass storage mode. I do not have a MicroSD card to test how that works but I would imagine for that mass storage mode would be required.
The vibrate motor is very soft. Depending on how tight your pockets are it’s possible to not notice the phone vibrating for a text or an email.

The speaker I would describe as average in volume compared to other phones I have had. It is louder than the Galaxy Nexus but not as loud as other Motorola phones in recent memory. I would subjectively describe the sound quality of the speaker as above average; listening to music through it is not painful but it’s still a phone speaker.

The notification light is very bright and pulses often enough that there’s no way you can miss it unlike the Galaxy Nexus which was ~7 seconds between pulses. I really like the way the notification light on this phone looks. Photo of the notification light courtesy of droidlife: http://www.droid-life.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/razr-hd-light2.jpg
Reception has been fantastic for me in the week+ I have used the phone. 3G, 4G, Wifi doesn’t matter. The handoff is quicker than any Verizon 4G phone I’ve had (and I’ve had quite a few). I have never had the data connection get frozen and require an airplane mode toggle to be fixed; an issue that happened with the Galaxy Nexus and many Verizon phones I have had.

Calls have all connected reliably and everything was loud and clear. None have dropped and I have received no complaints on the other end from people about my call quality.

Wrap Up

It’s a good phone. Walking into the Verizon store it was either this or the Galaxy S3 and after a week of using this(and having played with the S3 plenty due to many acquaintances having it) there is no way I’d consider the S3. Hopes this sheds a little light on what the phone is like.
 

shortylickens

No Lifer
Jul 15, 2003
80,287
17,080
136
Good for you sir, we havent had a proper review on here since that guy Shorty Lickens stopped them back in 2010.
 

bearxor

Diamond Member
Jul 8, 2001
6,605
3
81
We ordered a RAZR HD at work for replacement of original RAZR MAXX's. I'm hoping the increased battery capacity and more efficient chipset will let the HD hit battery life of the original MAXX.
 

Bateluer

Lifer
Jun 23, 2001
27,730
8
0
Worth it to upgrade from the GNex to the HD Maxx, in your opinion?

Any comments on the radios between the Nexus and the Moto?
 

podspi

Golden Member
Jan 11, 2011
1,982
102
106
How do you like the LED notification? I loved the light on my OG Droid, the one on the Bionic is 'ok', and I feel like the one on the Droid 4 is pretty small/dim. Of course, none of them are as bad as the one on the Thunderbolt (why'd they even bother?).
 

Red Storm

Lifer
Oct 2, 2005
14,233
234
106
I'm either going to get this phone, or make the jump and leave Verizon for a Nexus 4. Thanks for the review.
 

dguy6789

Diamond Member
Dec 9, 2002
8,558
3
76
Definitely worth it to upgrade from the Nexus to the Maxx HD imo. Subjectively I'd say the Maxx radios are better.

Objectively the only thing I have to go on is at work I work in a very big building deep inside and on the battery life settings page the cell signal quality spot always displayed as yellow or red on my Nexus. It goes between yellow and green on the Maxx.

I'm a fan of the notification light. It's very large and pretty bright and flashes often enough so that it's not likely to be missed when glancing at the phone to see if you have a message.

I think the Nexus 4 looks really nice and strongly considered jumping ship to get one but ultimately one of the main reasons I left the Galaxy Nexus was battery life and I get the feeling I'd be running myself into the same perpetual dissatisfaction with battery life scenario if I went the N4 route.
 

OBLAMA2009

Diamond Member
Apr 17, 2008
6,574
3
0
nice useful review. im more interested in whether/how a phone works than features. you need to know things like how is battery life/how is the 4g handoff/how buggy(stable) is it etc...and most review sites that are on the industry gravy train wont tell you that
 

Bateluer

Lifer
Jun 23, 2001
27,730
8
0
Mine arrived Friday morning, but I didn't get a chance to really play with anything on it until tonight. Its definitely speedy, though the GNex with 4.1 hammers it soundly in the Vellamo benchmark.

The LTE signal strength in my house seems to be comparable to the GNex, though I've spend most of the time with it on WiFi as I get all my apps installed, data restored, settings configured to my liking, etc. I will say, after installing 300 apps, configuring all the settings, etc, all with the screen locked on, the battery only went from 100% to 65%. Over the course of about 6 hours. Impressive.

Speakers are also 10x better than the Gnex, who's signal speaker was basically worthless.

Haven't had a chance to really test the GPS, Navigation etc.

Have to see how it performs over the next week.

PS: I also made it a point to leave 1 star reviews for all the Verizon junkware installed. NFL Mobile and Verizon Navigator are my biggest annoyances, but there's quite a few. As one would expect. After I play with it for a few days, make sure everything is solid, I'll root it and freeze that crap.
 

saratoga172

Golden Member
Nov 10, 2009
1,564
1
81
Mine arrived Friday morning, but I didn't get a chance to really play with anything on it until tonight. Its definitely speedy, though the GNex with 4.1 hammers it soundly in the Vellamo benchmark.

The LTE signal strength in my house seems to be comparable to the GNex, though I've spend most of the time with it on WiFi as I get all my apps installed, data restored, settings configured to my liking, etc. I will say, after installing 300 apps, configuring all the settings, etc, all with the screen locked on, the battery only went from 100% to 65%. Over the course of about 6 hours. Impressive.

Speakers are also 10x better than the Gnex, who's signal speaker was basically worthless.

Haven't had a chance to really test the GPS, Navigation etc.

Have to see how it performs over the next week.

PS: I also made it a point to leave 1 star reviews for all the Verizon junkware installed. NFL Mobile and Verizon Navigator are my biggest annoyances, but there's quite a few. As one would expect. After I play with it for a few days, make sure everything is solid, I'll root it and freeze that crap.

Thanks for the info as well. I've got a Gnex and I'm extremely satisfied with the device and performance...minus the battery life sometimes. Seriously considering something like the Maxx HD for battery life, love the build on it too, as long as I can root it.

Just wish I could get all of this in the size of the RAZR M. That phone is the perfect size imo. Maybe I'll just stop rooting/customizing and fgo with the M...choices choices.
 

Bateluer

Lifer
Jun 23, 2001
27,730
8
0
Phone at work today, 12hr shift. Surprisingly didn't have to juice the phone up once, ended the day with 75% of the battery, 15hrs of life. Not too shabby.

What really shocked me though, is the radio performance. At my desk, the GNext would get 2-3 bars of LTE, and speed test at 4-6Mb down, 500kbps up. The Razr gets the same bars, but tests at 15-18Mbs down, with ~10 up. There's a side of the building with cellular boosters mounted outside, near that side, the Gnex would get full bars and test around 10Mbs down. The Razr flirts with 30Mbs.

Thats pretty stunning. I've seen the Gnex hit those speeds before, but it is pretty rare.
 

dguy6789

Diamond Member
Dec 9, 2002
8,558
3
76
Verizon has announced that Jellybean is going to begin rolling out to the HD and Maxx HD starting next week
 

Bateluer

Lifer
Jun 23, 2001
27,730
8
0
Verizon has announced that Jellybean is going to begin rolling out to the HD and Maxx HD starting next week

Saw the news this morning. :) Pleasently surprised by Moto & Verizon on this one . . . I thought it'd be in the closing days of 2012, if Moto kept their word of launching before 2013. Not too shabby.

Still behind the latest Android, but I think I'd rather wait a bit for Google to polish out the bugs in 4.2 before they push an update to my daily driver.
 

Paladin

Senior member
Oct 22, 2001
660
33
91
Actually shocked they are beating Samsung with the rollout of JB for the S3. I'll look for the update on my son's HD.
 

Bateluer

Lifer
Jun 23, 2001
27,730
8
0
Actually shocked they are beating Samsung with the rollout of JB for the S3. I'll look for the update on my son's HD.

Thats debatable. The JB update for the S3 has rolled out to Sprint and TMO GS3s, its AT&T/Verizon jerking off in the executive lounge thats holding it back.