these guys sold me shoes that don't fit (the salesman didn't bother measuring my width), weren't matched (the left is *noticeably* more narrow than the right), and wouldn't let me return them.
"oh, they'll loosen up when you wear them"
yeah, well after 3 months it didn't happen.
And they're both the same size? That's strange.
With Allen Edmonds shoes, it can take some trial and error to get your sizing right since they have many different lasts.
I stick to the same lasts with their shoes. Park Ave, Fifth Ave, Strands, McAllister's etc...all share the same lasts.
They also run long and are very narrow, so instead of getting regular D, I'd get E.
I bought them at Nordstrom which has an awesome return policy and it took sometime for me to get my size. I hear Zappos has a great return policy as well.