Originally posted by: yukichigai
Originally posted by: Iron Woode
It needed a serious updating.
The new site isn't half bad.
...it's just slightly more than half bad.
Pros:
Ratings system is interesting (
I like being able to rate EVERYTHING)
Forums are much easier to access
Ditto for Reviews
Genre and Category entries: definite plus
Expanded information in Cast and Crew, etc., including headshots of the cast and other coolness.
Black/Dark Blue color scheme is much easier on my eyes.
Cons:
Series summary is truncated and limited on the main page
News items have no visible editor comments on the main page
Related, editors can't post info on the main page except in the "Summary" field
Front page is missing much of the useful info on TVTome, like:
- Current Season
- Number of episodes per season
- First aired / Last aired
- Upcoming Episodes
Limited size of screencaps of the series on the front page
Cast and Crew appears to be limited to 10 entries on main page
Synopsis of most recent episode appears on main page. (
Potential spoilers)
No Notes section for Episode entries, neither in the Episode Guide page nor the individual page for the Episode. (
Very useful for shows like Doctor Who, Lost, etc.)
Related, "Trivia Guide" has been incorrectly merged with "Goofs" rather than "Notes".
Episode guide is also missing Production Codes and Season numbers, e.g. 1x01, s01e13, etc. (
The latter are especially invaluable, and really need to be there)
Community Reviews take up half the main page. (
We care about reviews, but not that much)
Can't just type in "tv.com/<show_name>" and get the show page. (
e.g. "http://www.tv.com/doctor-who-2005/show/34391/summary.html" vs. "http://www.tv.com/doctor-who-2005/")
A couple of the Cons sound more like migration problems than anything else. If they fixed most of those I'd be much happier with the layout. As it is I'm having too damn much difficulty finding useful information. C'mon, Cnet guys! You made the page look shiny and nice, created a really decent ratings system, now fix the layout so it doesn't suck!