Did I make a wise college choice?

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Rickten

Golden Member
Apr 17, 2001
1,607
0
0
Originally posted by: kevinthenerd
Originally posted by: Kauru
job interviewer:
to you: okay, let's see, you majored in EE from (your state school here)? I'll call you back
to MIT grad: you majored in EE from MIT? very impressive, you're hired.
(you never hear back)

College DOES make a difference. People do care where you go to college. Sure you're saving money now, but will you be earning money later? Perhaps not as much had you gone to a better school. Just consider it. A Brown education will get you a lot farther than a state college education. A friend of mine who went to Brown: making $75,000/yr out of college in San Francisco, another friend of mine (just as smart) went to the University of Maine and is not even making half as much.

In the end, it's your decision, but IMO, a better education will do you a lot of good in the long run.

GPA makes a difference.

Whether you've continued on to earn your master's makes a big difference.

I think an employer would rather see a Ph.D. recipient from the University of Central Florida (Mechanical Engineering) than a bachelor's recipient from MIT.

That's just me, and hopefully, I'll be doing some hiring of my own a few years from now when I start a car company.

I agree GPA matters much more than the school. If you goto IVY league and get below 3.0 don't expect people to be recuiting you. If you goto state and do well grades wise you won't have a problem getting a job. At the career fairs at my school one of the first things they would look at or ask about was your GPA. They would see your GPA briefly chat with you and instantly want to talk further at a later date.
 

timosyy

Golden Member
Dec 19, 2003
1,822
0
0
Not sure where Rowan is placed on the undergrad engineering charts, but if its not in the top 100 or so I probably would've gone with more name recognition.

That being said, I went for more name recognition in my college decision, and I'm trying to transfer back to a state school now (cost/enviroment reasons, plus its a hassle getting home from where I am now). However, the jump from UIUC (ranked 5th) to VA Tech (ranked 14th) isn't really that much, and worth it IMO for its closeness to home (4 hours driving verses practically 10-12 hours driving/flying), smaller college enviroment (all classes are pretty much just across the drill field, verses being spread out as fvck and having to take the bus everywhere), and huge drop in total cost (somewhere along the lines of <9k verses ~34k a year).

Also maybe i'm just being ignorant, but if you're in Jersey why not Rutgers?

Edit: oooo, thats a pretty building on the Rowan.edu site...
 

bonkers325

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
13,076
1
0
i goto State and my scholarship/financial aid covers my costs and then some. even though i get an extra ~$1k a semester, i'd much rather sink loans into Ivy league schools
 

dartworth

Lifer
Jul 29, 2001
15,200
10
81
Rowan has a great football program...:)

DIII...but they are good. Not as good as Mount Union however...:p
 

Kipper

Diamond Member
Feb 18, 2000
7,366
0
0
Originally posted by: Fox5
Originally posted by: MSCoder610
How does $500 a semester => graduating with $50k?

I think his scholarship is $500 greater then what he has to pay and he has $50K in the bank for college.

Yep, that's it.

And I'm going to Rowan University. I actually don't have much idea on the quality of their engineering program, they were ranked #3 for chem eng in some report, but I have no idea how those reports are done. Their engineering department is about a decade old. Anyhow, I was under the idea that it's not really so much about the school you go to, as it is about what you do with/towards it. If I'm lazy and fail (in life) at the state school, I likely would have done the same at a private / out-of-state school. If I succeed, maybe I would have done a bit better at a different school, but most of the importance is going to be on how much effort I put towards my education and towards things like internships and what not.

You will have to have some exceptional stand-out features on your resume to get people to take a second look at you if you're coming from a lesser-known institution such as Rowan (which I haven't heard of, personally - but I'm a Northeaster).

It's amazing how much a strong university name can carry on a resume.

It's like working for a small startup vs. working for Microsoft. When it comes around to choosing people to interview out of a pile of 2,000 resumes, whose name is going to come out on top?

People say there is no difference between a state-funded institution and a private one, but I beg to differ. I went to a small Virginia public university, but when I visited schools like Duke, Georgetown, and the like I was surprised at the condition of their buildings, the facilities they had available to them (small things you could really use like 24-hour libraries), and the general quality of the education was infinitely superior to my own poorly underfunded school.

Privates have deep pockets. Deep pockets equal better-known professors, more money spent per student, and generally superior student life and facilities. Don't let anybody tell you otherwise. Why do you think Princeton is generally regarded as THE BEST undergraduate program in the country? I'll tell you why:

Small undergraduate population
Almost no graduate schools, such as the common business/medical/law, meaning #1 professor responsibility is to teach, not research.
Low faculty:student ratio
15 billion or more in the bank.

You do the math.
 

alm4rr

Diamond Member
Dec 21, 2000
4,390
0
0
take the money and go to good grad school

good grad school > * undergrad
 

Kipper

Diamond Member
Feb 18, 2000
7,366
0
0
Originally posted by: Rickten

I agree GPA matters much more than the school. If you goto IVY league and get below 3.0 don't expect people to be recuiting you. If you goto state and do well grades wise you won't have a problem getting a job. At the career fairs at my school one of the first things they would look at or ask about was your GPA. They would see your GPA briefly chat with you and instantly want to talk further at a later date.

But if you are sending off resumes, not going to career fairs, then what are the odds that your application will stand out tremendously with no-name school and high GPA vs. "brand-name" school and average or above average GPA?

Think about it. It's like having an 'in,' knowing someone, or remembering someone. You're at a networking convention. You meet fifty people and they all work for smaller tech firms in the valley except for two guys, who work at Adobe.

Who are you going to remember the best?
 

Kipper

Diamond Member
Feb 18, 2000
7,366
0
0
Originally posted by: alm4rr
take the money and go to good grad school

good grad school > * undergrad

True, but if you're applying to jobs straight out of undergrad - which many engineers are doing...
 

mercanucaribe

Banned
Oct 20, 2004
9,763
1
0
Originally posted by: z0mb13
going to an ivy leauge is not only about the name (but that part is HUGE), its also about networking

generally you will be hanging out with smart kids or rich kids from rich lineage

if you can still transfer to an ivy league, do it. you wont regret it later

It's about EDUCATION. There is a reason those schools are ranked higher and it isn't became of "name".

My friend got an internship at the mayor's office in Houston based purely on the fact that he goes to Vanderbilt. No networking going on there. Employers know what a good education is.

Edit: On the other hand, since the OP's main concern seems to be money, it's good that he let his spot in an Ivy go to another student.
 

da loser

Platinum Member
Oct 9, 1999
2,037
0
0
Originally posted by: ed21x
Originally posted by: miniMUNCH
I went Cal Poly POmona for undergrad in Chemical Engineering

This man speaks the truth. I graduated from engineering at a top ranked institution, and don't really see any significant difference in knowledge from someone in a supposed "lower ranked" engineering school. After your first job, college becomes only a second priority on your resume.

i'm also willing to bet miniMUNCH graduated near the top of his class, though. I would ask, how are your fellow classmates doing that had lower gpas? Also, Cal poly is a good eng school. however, i'm also willing to bet he got his first job in california, although i guess you could say that about pretty much every school.

for eng school, Ivys are not that great. large state schools are just as good, if not better, imo. i don't place rowan in that class, basically because i've never heard of it. never lived in the northeast though. By going to Rowan, you need to keep near that 4.0 for the rest of your years, to have an opportunity, as well as have internships. know that undergrad eng criteria is largely the same everywhere. make of it what you will. only diff might be elite schools, have more crazy professors that only teach grad studs, and give incredibly hard tests. take your opportunity to learn more from professors, and students. do more than simply the class curriculum.

what great schools have going for them is giving their elite students opportunity for the best jobs/knowledge in the world, things that will not be offered to other schools. if you're not in that top class, it's a waste though.

i'd also like to reiterate like many others, for engineering, the top with rise to the top, regardless of school. this isn't business, where they need an artificial barrier for entry. engineering will be purely about what you can do for the company through your knowledge.
 

Fox5

Diamond Member
Jan 31, 2005
5,957
7
81
Originally posted by: z0mb13
going to an ivy leauge is not only about the name (but that part is HUGE), its also about networking

generally you will be hanging out with smart kids or rich kids from rich lineage

if you can still transfer to an ivy league, do it. you wont regret it later

I don't think the scholarships would still apply, so I'd be out the $20,000/year I would have had.

Also maybe i'm just being ignorant, but if you're in Jersey why not Rutgers?

Edit: oooo, thats a pretty building on the Rowan.edu site...

Well, all of the cities Rutgers campuses are in are pretty bad, and Rutgers has about 100x the amount of students over Rowan. Rutgers has a lot of lecture style classes, whereas nearly every Rowan class has 15 students or less. Rowan's a school of about 10,000 students, 6,000 of which are commuters, and about 120 engineering students per grade. (30 each in EE, ME, CE, and the other CE)

And the engineering building does look nice, and it's still fairly new. The faculty always complains about how poorly built it is as far as ventilation/heating goes. Environmental design seems to be a big underlying theme for all the faculty at Rowan, I'm not sure how it is at other schools.

Rowan has a great football program...

Yeah, it's wierd considering their mascot is a scholarly owl. The professor owl I guess.

People say there is no difference between a state-funded institution and a private one, but I beg to differ. I went to a small Virginia public university, but when I visited schools like Duke, Georgetown, and the like I was surprised at the condition of their buildings, the facilities they had available to them (small things you could really use like 24-hour libraries), and the general quality of the education was infinitely superior to my own poorly underfunded school.

24 hour libararies does seem like a small thing. Rowan's education buildings are in good quality though (relatively new engineering, science, and education buildings, and a well kept student center), and seem fairly accesible to students (the physics club set up a halo tournament using the school's projectors and the planetarium, that was some huge halo), the library is open 24 hours at the end of the semesters, and they're still in the process of trying to grow themselves as a university, so things are changing pretty much every year.

Rowan's not rich though, they've got hundreds of millions of dollars only.

True, but if you're applying to jobs straight out of undergrad - which many engineers are doing...

Then you're probably vastly undertrained compared to the world market, or so it appears based off of topics I've read in the Politics and News forum.
 

digitalsm

Diamond Member
Jul 11, 2003
5,253
0
0
Originally posted by: Fox5
Originally posted by: gopunk
were you accepted to MIT, ivys, or are you just hypothesizing?

I was accepted to some Ivys, though I didn't apply to MIT. I was rejected from Princeton though, but it probably didn't help that I sent my application in late and didn't put a serious effort into the essays. (I did them about 2 hours before the online deadline, my decision to apply to Ivy's was a last minute 'on a whim' decision that wasn't fully serious)

I don't buy that at all. Employers may look at the Ivy Leaguers a little harder than State Schoolers, but to say that students have more academic challenges at the former is asinine.

Really? I assumed the Ivy Leagues were harder.

The Ivy league schools are notorious for grade inflation. People are paying $35k a year, they expect passing grades no matter what.
 

Reel

Diamond Member
Jul 14, 2001
4,484
0
76
I didn't read through the thread but I think the biggest thing is how your school is viewed by the large companies. I attended one of the larger and most well-known state schools (University of Florida) and we had tons of recruiting. While the name pedigree may not be as high as an Ivy or Pseudo-Ivy school, the recruiters for many large companies come through here to look at students. On the other hand, I have talked to people at smaller state schools that had much more of an uphill battle to find jobs. Get your foot in the door early with an internship. Those are huge in the eyes of employers. If you do well in an internship near the end of your education, you can almost always count on a job offer (sometimes even higher than that of someone who didn't do the company's internship). If you can find any sort of side work that won't hurt your grades and allow you to get some experience related to your job goals, that will help too. I don't think that you made a bad decision. You aren't set up for failure or anything. It just depends on how you take advantage of and make your own opportunities from now until graduation.
 

Fox5

Diamond Member
Jan 31, 2005
5,957
7
81
Edit: On the other hand, since the OP's main concern seems to be money, it's good that he let his spot in an Ivy go to another student.

Wow, that doesn't sound the least bit elitist.
So what's the reason to go to an Ivy then? To make less money but be a better educated world citizen?

The Ivy league schools are notorious for grade inflation. People are paying $35k a year, they expect passing grades no matter what.

Ha, that's not something you normally hear.
 

ones3k

Banned
Aug 21, 2005
444
0
0
I go to a state school (UMass) and pretty much all of the CS grads here make around 50-70k to start provided they have reasonable GPAs. I've never heard of your school though, and that will probably hurt you. If you go to an elite school or at least a well known public school, i think you'll be fine for getting a job. If i were you i would transfer into either an elite school or a well known public school (like rutgers!).

Also keep in mind its easier for ivy leaguers to get into grad programs.
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
Originally posted by: GOSHARKS
The grades you receive in such an elite school are not directly comparable to less "rigorous" schools becuase of this.

Yup, ivy leagues are known for rampant grade inflation. :) If you see a 3.5+ GPA from a less "rigorous" school, you know the guy at least worked for it. ;)
 

kevinthenerd

Platinum Member
Jun 27, 2002
2,908
0
76
Originally posted by: Reel
I didn't read through the thread but I think the biggest thing is how your school is viewed by the large companies. I attended one of the larger and most well-known state schools (University of Florida) and we had tons of recruiting. While the name pedigree may not be as high as an Ivy or Pseudo-Ivy school, the recruiters for many large companies come through here to look at students. On the other hand, I have talked to people at smaller state schools that had much more of an uphill battle to find jobs. Get your foot in the door early with an internship. Those are huge in the eyes of employers. If you do well in an internship near the end of your education, you can almost always count on a job offer (sometimes even higher than that of someone who didn't do the company's internship). If you can find any sort of side work that won't hurt your grades and allow you to get some experience related to your job goals, that will help too. I don't think that you made a bad decision. You aren't set up for failure or anything. It just depends on how you take advantage of and make your own opportunities from now until graduation.

Just out of curiosity, how do you suppose UF ranks with UCF for engineering?
 

hollowman

Diamond Member
Feb 19, 2001
4,864
0
76
Originally posted by: Kauru
Originally posted by: PaulNEPats
Originally posted by: Kauru
job interviewer:
to you: okay, let's see, you majored in EE from (your state school here)? I'll call you back
to MIT grad: you majored in EE from MIT? very impressive, you're hired.
(you never hear back)

College DOES make a difference. People do care where you go to college. Sure you're saving money now, but will you be earning money later? Perhaps not as much had you gone to a better school. Just consider it. A Brown education will get you a lot farther than a state college education. A friend of mine who went to Brown: making $75,000/yr out of college in San Francisco, another friend of mine (just as smart) went to the University of Maine and is not even making half as much.

In the end, it's your decision, but IMO, a better education will do you a lot of good in the long run.

Who would want to work with an employer which is that shallow in their thinking?

I was just making up a situation. If two people had the same credentials, but one went to MIT and the other went to a state college, who the hell are you going to hire? Unless the MIT grad is a complete ass, I doubt you'll choose a state schooler over an MIT grad. It makes a difference.

Well... I understand the point you are trying to make. However, I would hire the state schooler at $37500 especially since they are about equally smart. =)
 

mercanucaribe

Banned
Oct 20, 2004
9,763
1
0
Originally posted by: Fox5
Edit: On the other hand, since the OP's main concern seems to be money, it's good that he let his spot in an Ivy go to another student.

Wow, that doesn't sound the least bit elitist.
So what's the reason to go to an Ivy then? To make less money but be a better educated world citizen?

The Ivy league schools are notorious for grade inflation. People are paying $35k a year, they expect passing grades no matter what.

Ha, that's not something you normally hear.

I mean that he can be rich with any education, especially with an EE degree.
 

Lenine

Senior member
Apr 19, 2003
371
0
0
Why are you asking this after you've applied and gone there? I feel that any comments I make concerning Ivy schools vs. yours wouldn't be constructive now.

These questions should have been considered a few months ago when you were deciding, not now.
 

imthebadguy

Platinum Member
Aug 14, 2004
2,703
0
0
nah, potential for gettin a better job is much greater if u goto a better school, imo transfer if you still can an insignificant 50k is nothing compared to how much more you will make in the future by going to a good school
 

Mo0o

Lifer
Jul 31, 2001
24,227
3
76
Well, if you and a MIT grad had the same work experience, i would guess he would have a leg up on you
 

erub

Diamond Member
Jun 21, 2000
5,481
0
0
I'm going to Texas A&M University, while a state school, #14 in engineering. Recruiters are all over the place around here, and if I wanted to, I'm sure with my ~3.7 GPA in EE and extracurriculurs I could have received a very solid job offer..people I know are tossing around 55-60K with lesser GPAs, and most of these jobs are in TX. I'm trying to go to another STATE school for graduate school, being Georgia Tech. I don't think I should have any problem getting a job after graduating from there either.

Yes, I probably could have gone to at least some of the Ivys for undergrad, but I don't resent that decision at all. I have enough scholarships to cover my entire tuition bill..that 120-150K my parents saved on my education, they told me I can use for a business one day..

My sister, OTOH, went to Pomona College (very prestigious liberal arts college in CA) and my parents paid $$ for her education. She ended up at UT Medical Branch in Galveston for Medical School, sitting next to classmates who attended Texas A&M..my parents have since told me that they wished that they had saved the money on her undergrad
 

ones3k

Banned
Aug 21, 2005
444
0
0
Originally posted by: imthebadguy
nah, potential for gettin a better job is much greater if u goto a better school, imo transfer if you still can an insignificant 50k is nothing compared to how much more you will make in the future by going to a good school


That depends on what you study. If you study engineering or computer science, you'll make at least 50k with a decent GPA. Most of the students that attend state schools arent cut out for majors such as engineering, and LOTS of freshman engineering majors get weeded out. So the few that actually end up graduating with good GPAs end up being the ones with the good jobs.

On the other hand, if you're going to major in something like business or liberal arts, it will help a lot coming from an elite school.