I would still choose Obama. I don't think he has done a bad job, in fact, I still think it's too early to tell if the administration's moves have had a significant positive or negative effect. It's been 8 months, not even a forth of his term. It took us years to get in the hole, I don't foresee a turnaround happening in any expeditious manner no matter how well the administration handles things.
I can honestly tell you that I feel much less anxiety over the economy and the direction the country is going now, as compared to the election cycle and earlier this year. I certainly don't think we're out of the woods yet, but I feel like we're pointed in the right direction - now we need to seriously focus on our segway back to a stable economy, and get the deficit seriously under control. I'm just worried about the political consequences of those actions, and I can tell the democrats are too - I see a tax increase as necessary, as well severe cuts in social programs and spending, but any combination of the two will likely mean a vote OUT of office.