Satori:
Anyways, I had a question on the noise level of the drives people are receiving. From Storagereview's comments, it's a crap-shoot whether you get a 60, 68 or 80 GB platter design. I've got a 120GB WD Caviar SE that I use for backups and I really can't stand it when it's up and running. Seems like the 68-GB platter Maxtor's are comparable to those, while the 80GB platter ones are closer to the Seagates.
I have these drives working in my systems. They are three Maxtors (160/8, 80/8 and an 80/2) a WD SE (80/8) and an IBM 180 GXP.
For the first 4 days of the WD SE's installation, it made this low-level grinding noise upon every initial boot up, then died away to nothing. I called WD technical and the only thing they offered was to RMA the drive. Checked it out with some software tools (IBM and WD's) and it showed OK so I kept it. Within a week, no more sounds on boot up. The Maxtor 160GB did the same thing for the first day, then it was noiseless. I thought it was something to do with the 8 M cache, but that's mere speculation and haven't read anything to support it.
Finally, my 160GB was made in late April 2003, so I'm assuming it's made with 80GB platters (didn't the article state that yields were expected to improve and the lower aerial densities were in the first production runs?) and a correspondingly lesser amount of noise to the internals.
Now they are all quiet even in their seek and read modes (and I've got good hearing). If you have a stethoscope or any type of tubing, you could actually place it on the drive housing itself to listen to the noise and if it still is bothering you, RMA it. I've found IBM, Maxtor and WD all pretty good about sending you another drive. Maxtor will even send you a replacement drive and you can send the RMA'd one back within 30 days with no charge to the credit card they take for this service. You may even get a brand new one if they haven't any replacements available.
Finally, I'm reluctant comments about these drives. The last time I stated that my IBM 75GXP seemed to be immune from the periodic 'clicking' failure after a year and a quarter of operation, I got the same failure. They sent me back the newly minted 180GXP.