PG, you meant Liberal Progressives, just own up and stand by it.
There are faults to your reasoning in that, but I am not going to get into the slam on you alone.
The problem is simple. Even Progressives are human and make mistakes. Putting your kid into a school and expecting them to learn everything there is irresponsible. As parents, YOU should be reading to your kid and trying to help them learn as well.
What we have here is a swing too far in another direction, just like forcing kids to memorize things and follow the strait and narrow on the ironic "three R's", putting them in a free-form school with no real structure (and little motivation for such from the parents) is also a poor representation of what is needed.
The only thing I am curious about, which I will not read about in an attack article from the NYP, is what is the INTENDED curriculum at this school? Is this really a failure of the school, or a combined failure of parent and school?
No matter what school you go to, there are some kids that WANT to learn and will no matter what. Giving them better tools to do so will help them, but those that do not want to learn will have a hard time anywhere.
Especially at a "free form" academy.