<<
My daughter has an interview for Dartmouth tomorrow. She will be interviewing with a doctor here in California. Any advice on how to present yourself and what to say would be helpful. She is a 4.0 all thru high school with honors classes. How much weight does the interview carry? Thanks for any help. >>
My wife interviewed (and was accepted) at Dartmouth ... this would have been in winter '94. She is a NH native and had her interview in Nashua. Hers was a team interview -- 1 alum, 3 admissions office people. She remembers it was the toughest of the three interviews she had (Harvard, Tufts, Dartmouth), but that was probably due to the fact it was a multiple-person interview.
I'm guessing that format is something they only do with locals. It sounds like your daughter will be having a more "typical" alumnus/a interview (my Harvard interview in Florida was a one-on-one alum interview like what you've described.) The real key she should remember is that alum interviews are really designed to only help the candidate. Admissions offices look primarily at high school transcripts (how well the applicant did in, as well as how hard the courses were), college board scores, activities, and recommendations. But, a solid interview with an alum can push a borderline candidate over the top into the admit pile.
An alum interview will typically be either just "good" or outstanding. That is, either the interviewer thought, yeah, this candidate could do the work and would have a good experience there, or, wow, this is a great candidate and I'd love to see her at my alma mater! The key is engendering that second type of reaction... which, of course, does not and will not happen in every case or with every interviewer. As I understand it, it rarely hurts you to have a so-so interview... but the upside can be terrific.
In my alum interview for Harvard, I hit it off very well with my interviewer, and we talked for two hours longer than we were scheduled to. I think it really helped me in the admissions process, especially since her last name was the same as one of the major buildings on campus.
One last bit of advice for your daughter: she should remember that alums aren't drafted into doing these interviews--they volunteer to do them, and they do so because they have fond memories of their alma mater and want to see good students go there. Many alum interviewers see their job as one of selling the school as much as evaluating the candidate. They want her to succeed; it's not a zero-sum game among the candidates.
Good luck, and let us know how it goes.