Originally posted by: yowolabi
Originally posted by: Captante
Originally posted by: Xed
Look how "highly" Eli Manning was regarded up through most of last year and he winds up the super bowl mvp. I doubt it'll happen for good ol' Rex because the Bears have far too many questions and lack answers, but you never know. This move was obviously to try to convince Berrian to stick around.
The difference is that Eli had already won a number of big games with his arm by this point in his career... the Bears big wins with Rexy at QB have largely been despite his play.
Also the reason Giants fans were so down on Eli all the time was that it seemed every time he was about to turn the corner & consistantly play to potential he would turn in a couple incredible stinkers.
Grossman has shown that he has a very strong arm, but very little to no sense of what going on around him and thats somthing you can't teach ... you never know I suppose, but somhow I just can't see him ever being more then a backup QB in the NFL & a shaky one at that.
You're saying that Grossman didn't win any big games with his arm? The stats and my eyes say you're mistaken. Grossman's 2006 season was more impressive than Eli's 2007 season.
http://www.nfl.com/players/rex...=GRO597298&season=2006
http://www.nfl.com/players/eli.../gamelogs?id=MAN473170
The difference between Eli and Rex is that Rex had a horrible game in the superbowl, and Eli had a good one so all his past sins are forgiven. What you were saying about playing to potential is the exact same problem that Rex has had. You don't have 8 games in a season with a passer rating of 100+ by accident. There is talent there.
It's true that Rex's sense of the pass rush leaves something to be desired. However, with a good offensive line that wouldn't matter much. It's not like there are many qbs that can succeed with a bad O-line. The Bears O-line in 2007 was one of the worst in football. There's a reason 2 of the 5 starters just got released.
"Grossman's 2006 season was more impressive than Eli's 2007 season."
What? Are you actually LOOKING at the stats? That's some wonderful crack you're smoking.
The problem with Rex is he's either good or he flat out sucks. He's not consistently good with just bad games here and there.
Eli threw more than 2 INT's in a game ONE TIME. Rex threw more than 2 INT's FIVE TIMES. Say it with me again FIVE TIMES.
He had (4) 3 INT games and one 4 INT game. Eli had 4 INT's in one game - but it's the game that his big brother attended.
Rex - 3,193 Yrds, 23 TD's and 20 INT's. He also had 0 rushing TD's and a 54.6% completion percentage.
Eli - 3,336 yrds, 23 TD's and 20 INT's. He rushed for 1 TD and had a 56.2 comp.
So Eli had more yards, more TD's overall and a better pass comp percentage. He also rushed for more yards.
Then lets break down the post season:
Eli - 854 yrds, 6 TD's and 1 INT's. 60.5% comp %.
Rex - 591 yrds, 3 TD's and 3 INT's. 56.5 comp %.
Can you HONESTLY call that a "more impressive season"? Eli won the super bowl. Kind of a no brainer if you ask me.