ABSOLUTELY any hand tool even if you have 100 1/2" 1/4" drive sockets that are stripped...it will be replaced on the spot (pending inventory).
I have a lot of tools (over 1000
), I save up my 'bads' so I can travel to Sears and get them all replaced at once.
I have had the same #2 phillips replaced 3 times now in about 10-15 years, it's due again...nothing wrong with the tool of course, just my wear.
This is the same #2 phillips that introduced me to their professional line which works so much better in my hands. I had a normal blue and clear handled craftsman, they didn't have it in stock and gave me the upgraded 'pro'....instant love...I actually came back about 2 or 3 weeks later and bought all new Professional screwdrivers.
The only problem I have found with the warranty is that tools tend to be made more cheaply now...in the 'old' days tools were made to last forever, and the lifetime warranty wasn't to be used. Now tools are made to last the average user's lifetime, and they will gladly replace the tools the hardcore user breaks (for the cheaper replacements).
Still spending a few more bucks on a tool so if it breaks mid-job and I can drive 15 mins to get a new one is great insurance.
Unfortunately their power tools don't have this same warranty....I smoked two of their buffers doing a boat (they were a few years old already and used weekly).
Chris