• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Cooking with SunnyD: The cake is a (Boston Cream) pie.

SunnyD

Belgian Waffler
Today's cooking endeavor is learning how to use a cookbook. Yes, believe it or not, I don't cook everything without aid from some of my favorite friends... namely Betty Crocker and company. Sometimes, it's just a bit too complicated to go it alone. Boston Cream Pie is one of those things. It sounds simple enough: Some Boston, some cream and some pie. But it's not. Time-wise, it takes about an hour and a half to make, but it requires you to do three things at once.

Thankfully, two of those three things can happen while the cake portion is in the oven. In fact, I learned only too late that one of those things shouldn't be done until the cake is already cooled, cut and assembled with the custard. Anyhow, I won't post the recipe since I used the Betty Crocker recipe directly, with the exception of adding about 3 tablespoons of milk to the chocolate glaze to smooth it out and make it not quite as bitter.

Anyhow, feel free to enjoy. After all, the cake is a pie. :sneaky:

We start with the three separate components:
BCPieParts.jpg


Cut the cake in half, which is never an easy task, then top with the custard:
BCPieCustard.jpg


Give it a hat, and voila, the pie is a cake... pie. A cake pie!:
BCPieCake.jpg


Top with chocolate glaze:
BCPie.jpg


There are definitely a few things I'd do different. For starters, using bakers chocolate is WAY too bitter for this recipe. I added around 3 tablespoons of milk, and frankly that wasn't even enough. It needs a smoother milk chocolate.

Second, the custard recipe is good, but not good enough. It's not creamy nor silky enough compared to real Boston Cream custard. It's also a hair not sweet enough. It's good, but relies a good bit on the vanilla extract to give it its flavor, and the extract doesn't get enough time to cook off to remove the "alcohol" flavor from it. In my opinion of course.

Other than that, the cake recipe is good, pretty moist, but heavier than what you'll find in good Boston Cream Pies. None the less, for an hour and change worth of work, it's still pretty good.

BCPieServing.jpg
 
I would have thought any bitterness using baker's chocolate would be made up with sufficient confectioner's sugar and milk.
 
Congrats! SunnyD, you have got to graduate from Betty Crocker. Stick with that recipe format if it works for you but, find some better cook books. Betty Crocker really dumbs down recipes and shoots for the lowest common denominator as far as kitchen skills and ingredients.
 
One thing I've learned, Boston Cream is a very ambiguous name.

For most of my life, I've known Boston Cream anything tends to be an airy, light, sweet and vanilla concoction... slightly more dense and sweeter than whipped cream, but fairly similar.

Yet, according to some, Boston Cream pie or donuts can be closer to cream or custard.
I call BS. Boston Cream should never be custard, unless you want to include the noun "custard" in the full name of the food item.

Note: I say this because I despise what I've known to be Boston Cream.
I demand real custard, or at least something resembling a real custard (sometimes I strongly doubt the custard in custard-filled donuts actually has any egg in it). See, when shopping for these products, I've seen separate displays for both Custard and Boston Cream. Never have I seen something with custard, or at least custard-flavored sweet filling, referred to as Boston Cream. Seems odd.

I'm a huge fan of custard and custard-like items. Makes me want to make this, but actually make some real custard for the filling.
 
My tip: Use semi sweet chocolate not unsweetened baker's chocolate, unless you want to get a workout stirring the sugar in by hand.
 
the most difficult cake i have ever made was a 3 layer chocolate cake, made it for an ex gf's bday... oddest part was the hot water that was necessary... other than that, and the whole, praying to god that 3 seperate layers came out of their pans properly part, plus the frosting... that cake was delicious, and I, like you, believe it is a straight BC recipe.
 
One thing I've learned, Boston Cream is a very ambiguous name.

For most of my life, I've known Boston Cream anything tends to be an airy, light, sweet and vanilla concoction... slightly more dense and sweeter than whipped cream, but fairly similar.

Yet, according to some, Boston Cream pie or donuts can be closer to cream or custard.
I call BS. Boston Cream should never be custard, unless you want to include the noun "custard" in the full name of the food item.

Note: I say this because I despise what I've known to be Boston Cream.
I demand real custard, or at least something resembling a real custard (sometimes I strongly doubt the custard in custard-filled donuts actually has any egg in it). See, when shopping for these products, I've seen separate displays for both Custard and Boston Cream. Never have I seen something with custard, or at least custard-flavored sweet filling, referred to as Boston Cream. Seems odd.

I'm a huge fan of custard and custard-like items. Makes me want to make this, but actually make some real custard for the filling.

This custard has egg in it. Two yolks in fact.

My tip: Use semi sweet chocolate not unsweetened baker's chocolate, unless you want to get a workout stirring the sugar in by hand.
Unfortunately, I used up all the semi sweet chocolate I had the night before. 🙁
 
To cut a layer in half easily - use a piece of sewing thread longer than the circumference of the layer. Position it around the layer where you want to cut and pull the ends slowly away from each other. Cuts right through perfectly.
 
To cut a layer in half easily - use a piece of sewing thread longer than the circumference of the layer. Position it around the layer where you want to cut and pull the ends slowly away from each other. Cuts right through perfectly.

Good tip. Have to remember that.

Looking good SunnyD! :thumbsup: I have zero baking skill but my wife is great. I'll show this to my wife and see if she'll make me one.
 
Good tip. Have to remember that.

Looking good SunnyD! :thumbsup: I have zero baking skill but my wife is great. I'll show this to my wife and see if she'll make me one.

You want your wife to give you a cream pie? Shouldn't you be cooking that one up for her?
 
Back
Top