computer science degree?

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

narreth

Senior member
May 4, 2007
519
0
76
Originally posted by: Martin
They are lying to you. If you go to a good school like Waterloo and do coop/internships, you will have a very wide choice of jobs that pay well and offer great working places.

I went to UofT Comp Eng since I wasn't quite sure what I wanted to do, but as it turned out I really liked writing software, so now I do that and I am not at all sorry about not going to CS. Over the 4 years, I took about as much CS courses as a CS major, the only difference is that while CS majors get to take lots of other courses (humanities, general science, etc), whereas I did EE courses.

so in short you're saying a co-op CS/EE/CE degree from waterloo would land you a job easily?
 

evident

Lifer
Apr 5, 2005
12,134
756
126
cs, cpe and ee degrees are still in great demand, especially if you're good at it
 

razor2025

Diamond Member
May 24, 2002
3,010
0
71
Originally posted by: KentState
I know as someone that was trying to hire entry level programmers, the market was very competitive even when offering $60k+ year in south west Ohio. I have about 10 years experience now and had two really good offers just recently. I'm actually moving to Atlanta because the offer was really good.

++

Location, Location, Location

Some regional/local markets can be very good for CS majors. My buddy graduated with mediocre grade (2.3) got a $60k job offer after he quit his first job (only did 6 months). The place I'm doing my Co-Op is desperately needs to fill a testing , web developer, and more Java positions.

This is wrecking havoc in my mind, as I'm see-sawing between job and grad school after my BS.
 

Deeko

Lifer
Jun 16, 2000
30,213
12
81
Originally posted by: narreth
whoa @ 2.3gpa and getting a job offer O_O

GPA is extremely overrated. Most jobs I've applied to don't even ask - and the one that did, still gave me an offer (I had a 2.8)
 

QurazyQuisp

Platinum Member
Feb 5, 2003
2,554
0
76
Originally posted by: Deeko
Originally posted by: narreth
whoa @ 2.3gpa and getting a job offer O_O

GPA is extremely overrated. Most jobs I've applied to don't even ask - and the one that did, still gave me an offer (I had a 2.8)

I'm a current student and I have a 3.5, I'm pretty sure that is part of the reason why I had so many of the big software companies ( known for smart people) contact me after applying online for internships. MS, GOOG, Intuit, IBM, and a few other larges ones and numerous small companies. I had opportunities this summer to intern with a number of companies but unfortunately something came up that would have cut my available time down for the internships. I had to turn down these companies however, every single one of them gave me contact info for a specific recruiter and told me to make sure to contact them this fall/spring for next summer.

GPA can, initially, show work ethic which is something a lot of software developers are looking for. After they got over my GPA I had to prove to them that I was able to problem solve and was above average in intelligence to get them to pursue me further. My GPA just helped me get in the door.
 

Noirish

Diamond Member
May 2, 2000
3,959
0
0
Originally posted by: dNor
Originally posted by: Special K
1. Get CS Degree
2. start web 2.0 site in garage
3. IPO
4. Profit

Just skip step 1 for even more $$$s!

1. start web 3.0 site in garage
2. IPO
3. Profit

CS is fine.
At least, after the dot-bomb, if you are in CS, you must have a passion for it, not just money.
 

Deeko

Lifer
Jun 16, 2000
30,213
12
81
QurazyQuisp, if you have good internships on your resume, that balances out any GPA deficiencies - and IMO is actually better than having a high GPA without the internships, because it translates better to the real world. Is having both ideal? Sure...but overrated, and if you need to spend your entire college life in the library to get that 3.5+, it isn't worth it.
 

QurazyQuisp

Platinum Member
Feb 5, 2003
2,554
0
76
Originally posted by: Deeko
QurazyQuisp, if you have good internships on your resume, that balances out any GPA deficiencies - and IMO is actually better than having a high GPA without the internships, because it translates better to the real world. Is having both ideal? Sure...but overrated, and if you need to spend your entire college life in the library to get that 3.5+, it isn't worth it.

Deeko, I agree, internships are most definitely more important that a high GPA, however, the high GPA can help one get their foot in the door for some of the more prestigious internships. When I was second round interviewing with Intuit in Mountain View, I was the only one there who was not from Stanford, Cal-Tech, UC-SD. All known for having excellent computer science programs.

I don't come anywhere near spending my whole college career in the library. I take about 17 credit hours a semester, work 15-25 hours a week (Depending on exams and some extracurricular activities) and a leader in one of the clubs on campus and an active member at my church. I however do not play computer games. So many of my CS friends spend all their free time playing wow or some other game. I try to make the best out of all my time every day, and it's paid off by having a decently high GPA, some experience in my field and a social-life.

I am amazed at how much time the average college student wastes. They all claim to have no time at all, but then you look at how much time they spend browsing facebook, or watching tv, playing video games or whatever.

Thankfully, I have two more years (including this coming year) in school due to my dual majors which opens up another summer for an internship.
 

Deeko

Lifer
Jun 16, 2000
30,213
12
81
Ok, yea, GPA helps for getting internships, or at least interviews for internships, because they don't really have any other criteria to judge. I'm more referring to GPA and it's meaning post-college.
 

QurazyQuisp

Platinum Member
Feb 5, 2003
2,554
0
76
Originally posted by: Deeko
Ok, yea, GPA helps for getting internships, or at least interviews for internships, because they don't really have any other criteria to judge. I'm more referring to GPA and it's meaning post-college.

No, I definitely agree there. I know that the work I am putting forth now will have little to no meaning after my first job, however, I'm hoping that it will provide me with more opportunities now.
 

Jumpem

Lifer
Sep 21, 2000
10,757
3
81
The market is great if you do some internships and have good experience (not IT/website kinds of things).
 

Martin

Lifer
Jan 15, 2000
29,178
1
81
Originally posted by: narreth
Originally posted by: Martin
They are lying to you. If you go to a good school like Waterloo and do coop/internships, you will have a very wide choice of jobs that pay well and offer great working places.

I went to UofT Comp Eng since I wasn't quite sure what I wanted to do, but as it turned out I really liked writing software, so now I do that and I am not at all sorry about not going to CS. Over the 4 years, I took about as much CS courses as a CS major, the only difference is that while CS majors get to take lots of other courses (humanities, general science, etc), whereas I did EE courses.

so in short you're saying a co-op CS/EE/CE degree from waterloo would land you a job easily?

Yep. I did UofT's program, so I spent 16 continuous months at RIM (in waterloo), so when I graduated, and felt comfortable applying for non-entry level jobs. IIRC, the listing for my current job wanted 2-4 years experience, but I got it without and problems (and with a bit more money than they initially offered), even though I only had those 16 months (plus some other vaguely related experience)
 

Jumpem

Lifer
Sep 21, 2000
10,757
3
81
Originally posted by: Deeko
QurazyQuisp, if you have good internships on your resume, that balances out any GPA deficiencies - and IMO is actually better than having a high GPA without the internships, because it translates better to the real world. Is having both ideal? Sure...but overrated, and if you need to spend your entire college life in the library to get that 3.5+, it isn't worth it.

GPA is important. My company will not interview anyone who does not have at minimum a 3.0.
 

ppdes

Senior member
May 16, 2004
739
0
0
Where I work is desperate for more developers. They won't accept people with no experience, although an internship or two might be enough. A bigger problem seems to be that the majority of people we interview can't program their way out of a paper bag. We're talking about people applying for a Java position that can't explain inheritance, polymorphism, the difference between an interface and an abstract class, etc..
 

Legendary

Diamond Member
Jan 22, 2002
7,019
1
0
Alone a CS degree is useless.
You need one of these:
1. a brand name college (think top 50)
2. a middle tier college with a 3.5+
3. a middle tier with a 3.0+ and some internships

any of these will get you into 80% of interviews.
combine features to get the other 20%
i graduated with a math/compsci degree and a 2.9 GPA from NYU (#33 on USnews, whatever that means) and i only got denied interviews twice out of ten resumes sent out in my life. of those 8 interviews i've gotten 3 offers.

it's not bad out there.

learn to interview!
 

Deeko

Lifer
Jun 16, 2000
30,213
12
81
Originally posted by: Jumpem
Originally posted by: Deeko
QurazyQuisp, if you have good internships on your resume, that balances out any GPA deficiencies - and IMO is actually better than having a high GPA without the internships, because it translates better to the real world. Is having both ideal? Sure...but overrated, and if you need to spend your entire college life in the library to get that 3.5+, it isn't worth it.

GPA is important. My company will not interview anyone who does not have at minimum a 3.0.

Congrats on ruling out plenty of qualified talent, I can assure you someone without a 3.0 will have no problems finding a good job.
 

sdifox

No Lifer
Sep 30, 2005
100,504
17,956
126
Originally posted by: Deeko
Originally posted by: Jumpem
Originally posted by: Deeko
QurazyQuisp, if you have good internships on your resume, that balances out any GPA deficiencies - and IMO is actually better than having a high GPA without the internships, because it translates better to the real world. Is having both ideal? Sure...but overrated, and if you need to spend your entire college life in the library to get that 3.5+, it isn't worth it.

GPA is important. My company will not interview anyone who does not have at minimum a 3.0.

Congrats on ruling out plenty of qualified talent, I can assure you someone without a 3.0 will have no problems finding a good job.

That's me :) I am the bottom of the rung in my class. Just because I lost interest in year 2.
So I managed to barely get out with a very low gpa... But then I was consulting even before I left school so...


All I can say kids is this : "STAY AWAY FROM NETREK!"
 

Kirby

Lifer
Apr 10, 2006
12,028
2
0
Originally posted by: Asparagus
Come to Huntsville, AL and you will have no problem finding a job here. America's third largest research park is here along with the Redstone Arsenal. This is an engineering and computer science paradise. I graduated with my CS degree in 2005 (I took 7 years to finish my degree because I worked in the industry while I was going to school). Every person that I knew in college is employed and making pretty good money. Fresh out of school, you can expect to earn around $55K/yr. There is no shortage of programming jobs in this town...

I'll be there this weekend. :p

I got a co-op at AMRDEC.
 

Deeko

Lifer
Jun 16, 2000
30,213
12
81
Originally posted by: sdifox
Originally posted by: Deeko

Congrats on ruling out plenty of qualified talent, I can assure you someone without a 3.0 will have no problems finding a good job.

That's me :) I am the bottom of the rung in my class. Just because I lost interest in year 2.
So I managed to barely get out with a very low gpa... But then I was consulting even before I left school so...

Yea. I had a low GPA, mainly because I was busy with other things so my general education classes suffered, and I'm doing plenty well....

I'm sure jumpem will come back and throw Google and his company in our faces. Yes, there are SOME companies out there that care about GPA - but guess what? My first full time job was with one of them! I actually couldn't apply there for an internship because they had a 3.4 minimum. Still ended up pulling an interview for FT, and then a job.
 

narreth

Senior member
May 4, 2007
519
0
76
Originally posted by: Legendary
Alone a CS degree is useless.
You need one of these:
1. a brand name college (think top 50)
2. a middle tier college with a 3.5+
3. a middle tier with a 3.0+ and some internships

any of these will get you into 80% of interviews.
combine features to get the other 20%
i graduated with a math/compsci degree and a 2.9 GPA from NYU (#33 on USnews, whatever that means) and i only got denied interviews twice out of ten resumes sent out in my life. of those 8 interviews i've gotten 3 offers.

it's not bad out there.

learn to interview!

is RPI considered a brand name college?
 

Bignate603

Lifer
Sep 5, 2000
13,897
1
0
Originally posted by: sdifox
Originally posted by: TallBill
Screw IT, programmers are in high demand. My buddy had a bundle of job offers upon completion of his masters. (school paid for it after his bs, so he stayed)

I'll venture a guess that he is not your typical student :) Obviously the top 5% never have problem finding jobs. Unfortunately most of people (about 95% ;) ) are not in that 5%

Then you make sure you are in the top 5%. At a normal school a person of normal intelligence can get good grades as long as they are willing to work for it. I know that there was a ton of people at my school that were smarter than me. I still got out summa cum laude and 3 different job offers in hand. If you don't treat college like a party and actually work hard at it you'll have success.
 

Skyclad1uhm1

Lifer
Aug 10, 2001
11,383
87
91
What you could consider is applying for a job in Europe. Here in the Netherlands there is currently a shortage of IT workers. And if you get a job with an American company here (e.g. Google, Dell, Microsoft, etc) you will have pretty much the same benefits as you'll have in the States.
And if the Dollar keeps doing bad a bit longer getting paid in Euros for a few years may be nice too.