1.) I have been thinking about this for a few days since, since it became clear that Brown would win. My conclusion is that scrapping the bill and trying to get a "bi-partisan" bill is the least bad option. Ramming it through would have very dire political consequences. Reconciliation will not work. Passing the Senate version as is it will not happen.
2.) So let's start over and see if the repubs can agree with a healthbill that has even a single item in it that isn't part of their agenda. They have their own proposal which contains exactly zero of the several hundred provisions in the dems bill, not even the pre-existing conditions or recission reform. Let's have lots of time consuming hearings and debates, and let the people see if the repubs really do want healthcare reform.
3.) Perhaps at the end of the process we will end up with a small, compromize bill that has some insurance reform in it to end some abuses, doesn't cover anyone not already covered, and doesn't control costs. If that is what the American people want at this stage, that is exactly what they should get. And it will be politically best for the dems right now to just give it to them. They can get credit for being bi-partisan, and most importantly, they can get credit for doing nothing of any substance about healthcare reform. It's a win-win.
- wolf