Car audio ohm question...

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Pastore

Diamond Member
Feb 9, 2000
9,728
0
76
ok I was just reading another site and it said that if an amp is rated at less power than the speakers, the speakers would clip and over time be detrimental to the speakers. Now, seeing that when I hook these up it will be running 100W per channel, when each channel can max at 200W. Would I have to worry about clipping with this set up?
 

KMurphy

Golden Member
May 16, 2000
1,014
0
0
It's all about impedance matching and maximum power transfer between source and load (amplifier and speaker).

Check Here for lots of good useful information.

Also, click here.
 

PowerEngineer

Diamond Member
Oct 22, 2001
3,598
774
136
I think I can help out on this question! :)

Power supplies give a wattage rating and a load impedance because the wattage delivered to the load will change with the load's impedance. A real world power supply can be modeled as an ideal voltage source with a resistance in series. The load resistance is connected across the output to close the circuit (i.e. voltage source with the two resistances in series). This means that some of the power will be consumed inside the power supply and some consumed by the load. The split between what's consumed inside the power supply and what's delivered to the load is a function of how big the load resistance is compared to the internal resistance. As I recall (and should be able to demonstrate if I remembered how to do derivatives), the maximum power delivery to the load occurs when the load resistance is equal to the internal resistance. So if your speakers are actually 4 ohms, then the power delivered to them will be roughly 89% of the power supply rating at 2 ohms. So you do not have to worry about blowing them out.

Another obvious possibility is to get another set of 4 ohm speakers to form parallel pairs which will have a 2 ohm resistance.

Good luck!

Nuts! KMurphy beat me to it! :eek:
 

Adul

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
32,999
44
91
danny.tangtam.com
Originally posted by: Beast1284
ok I was just reading another site and it said that if an amp is rated at less power than the speakers, the speakers would clip and over time be detrimental to the speakers. Now, seeing that when I hook these up it will be running 100W per channel, when each channel can max at 200W. Would I have to worry about clipping with this set up?

you speaker will run fine has long has you to blast them to distorion levels.
 

Adul

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
32,999
44
91
danny.tangtam.com
lets keep it simple here

you amp is

100 watts X 2 channels @ 2 ohmns

So that is 100 watts per channel for a 2 ohmn load.

But you will be placing a 4 ohmn load on each channel. So the power sent to the speakers will be halfed.

it will be

50 watts x 2 channels @ 4 ohmns.

You speakers shall handle this just fine. You will not blow them or anything.
 

Pastore

Diamond Member
Feb 9, 2000
9,728
0
76
Originally posted by: Adul
lets keep it simple here

you amp is

100 watts X 2 channels @ 2 ohmns

So that is 100 watts per channel for a 2 ohmn load.

But you will be placing a 4 ohmn load on each channel. So the power sent to the speakers will be halfed.

it will be

50 watts x 2 channels @ 4 ohmns.

You speakers shall handle this just fine. You will not blow them or anything.

Adul, thats what i thought too, but I am still seeing differing opinions on this... WHO IS RIGHT?!?!?!?!
 

frizzlefry

Golden Member
May 14, 2001
1,711
0
0
Originally posted by: Adul
lets keep it simple here

you amp is

100 watts X 2 channels @ 2 ohmns

So that is 100 watts per channel for a 2 ohmn load.

But you will be placing a 4 ohmn load on each channel. So the power sent to the speakers will be halfed.

it will be

50 watts x 2 channels @ 4 ohmns.

You speakers shall handle this just fine. You will not blow them or anything.


This. Take for instance my amp. rated for 600W @ 2ohm and 300W @ 4ohm... doesn't get any easier.
 

PowerEngineer

Diamond Member
Oct 22, 2001
3,598
774
136
Originally posted by: Beast1284

WHO IS RIGHT?!?!?!?!

I AM! :D

It's not quite as simple as Adul and frizzlefry think, but the important point that we all agree on is that using higher impedance speakers will reduce the maximum power your amplifier will deliver. Your 80 watt continuous speakers should be fine with that 100 watt/channel amplifier. I expect you'll run into objectionable distortion long before you reach maximum amplifier output anyway.

Before taking advice from me, you should remember that I also believe in evolution. :Q

Good luck!
 

Evadman

Administrator Emeritus<br>Elite Member
Feb 18, 2001
30,990
5
81
Originally posted by: Beast1284
Originally posted by: Adul
lets keep it simple here

you amp is

100 watts X 2 channels @ 2 ohmns

So that is 100 watts per channel for a 2 ohmn load.

But you will be placing a 4 ohmn load on each channel. So the power sent to the speakers will be halfed.

it will be

50 watts x 2 channels @ 4 ohmns.

You speakers shall handle this just fine. You will not blow them or anything.

Adul, thats what i thought too, but I am still seeing differing opinions on this... WHO IS RIGHT?!?!?!?!


No your not. minendo is just explaining it from the speakers end instead of the amp's end that everyone thinks of it as, so it messes with your head unless you think it out.

If your amp is rated to put out 100w x 2 @ 2 ohms, then if you hook one speaker up to each chanle, then the amp will put out 50 watts to each speaker because the resistance ( ohm's ) are doubled. HOWEVER if you connect the 6 x 9's in parallel, then hook the entire setup to your amp on one channel, it will put out 100 watts to the set ( still 50 watts per speaker ) but what is really nifty, is your amp can be bridged ( hooking the positve on one chanel and the negitive on the other ) so with the speakers in the parallel setup, the speaskers will now get the full 200 watts that the amp can put out.

Also be aware that if your amp is rated @ 100 watts x 2 @ 2 ohms then it can probably put out 200 x 2 @ 1 ohm. As long as it is 1 ohm stable. My crappy 250 watt jensen was 1 ohm stable, so I would assume the MTX series would be.

Read your instruction manual on how to bridge the amp. They are all different. The MTX I used to have, it was Right channel positive and left channel ground to bridge.

 

thomsbrain

Lifer
Dec 4, 2001
18,148
1
0
Originally posted by: minendo
Originally posted by: Beast1284
ok, this site says they are 4 ohms, so what would it happen if I hooked up that amp? Just cut the rated power in half to each channel? :(
Double the power to each channel.

sigh. no. more resistance = less power. you get half the power per channel out of the amp with 4 ohm speakers as you do with 2 ohm speakers.

minendo, amps can't change the resistance you're using. that is defined by speakers and speakers alone.

evadman, these are 6x9's, not subwoofers. he's going to be running them in stereo, not a mono parallel setup. at least i assume that's what he's doing. anything else would be silly.

the short answer to Beast's question is using your MTX speakers with your Thunder amp will give you an output of 50 watts per channel, well below their rated capacity. so go for it.

 

minendo

Elite Member
Aug 31, 2001
35,560
22
81
Originally posted by: thomsbrain
minendo, amps can't change the resistance you're using. that is defined by speakers and speakers alone.

evadman, these are 6x9's, not subwoofers. he's going to be running them in stereo, not a mono parallel setup. at least i assume that's what he's doing. anything else would be silly.

the short answer to Beast's question is using your MTX speakers with your Thunder amp will give you an output of 50 watts per channel, well below their rated capacity. so go for it.
Yes, but my whole point was that you can change the resistance of the speakers to allow them to run at the 2ohms stated as output by the amp.

 

AvesPKS

Diamond Member
Apr 21, 2000
4,729
0
0
Originally posted by: minendo
Originally posted by: Beast1284
so at 0 ohms they could handle 400W?
Actually by carrying out the equation I=V^2/R you get an undefined answer.

Heh...that's why most wouldn't use that. You have to take the limit to get anything of substance...and as R approaches 0, I approaches infinity.
 

XCLAN

Platinum Member
Mar 22, 2001
2,401
0
0
Originally posted by: Beast1284
Originally posted by: Adul
lets keep it simple here

you amp is

100 watts X 2 channels @ 2 ohmns

So that is 100 watts per channel for a 2 ohmn load.

But you will be placing a 4 ohmn load on each channel. So the power sent to the speakers will be halfed.

it will be

50 watts x 2 channels @ 4 ohmns.

You speakers shall handle this just fine. You will not blow them or anything.

Adul, thats what i thought too, but I am still seeing differing opinions on this... WHO IS RIGHT?!?!?!?!

adul is right.....trust me or i will buy you new speakers :){errrrr did i say that?}...lol seriously....yer all set dude
 

kherman

Golden Member
Jul 21, 2002
1,511
0
0
Originally posted by: minendo
Originally posted by: Beast1284
ok, this site says they are 4 ohms, so what would it happen if I hooked up that amp? Just cut the rated power in half to each channel? :(
Double the power to each channel.

Have that backwards. It's cuts the power in half. And with Amps, you can never be toosure if half is accurate. You have to see what hte manufacturer says they do at 4 ohms.
 

kherman

Golden Member
Jul 21, 2002
1,511
0
0
Originally posted by: Beast1284
So it would be pushing 200W per channel? WOuldn't that fry the amp/speakers pretty quickly?

You can hook up a 10000 watt amp to a 10 watt speaker and not fry it. It can be easily done, but as long as you don't turn the volume up too high, everything will be fine.

I have "200 watts" going into my front MB Quarts that are rated at 100 watts. Don't even come close to fryingthem.

Truth is, in my experience, that if you have a more powerful amp, there is less static in the speakers at higher volumes. Makes it sound much cleaner.
 

kherman

Golden Member
Jul 21, 2002
1,511
0
0
Sems to be confusion here:

Two formula you NEED TO KNOW:

P = IV
V = IR

P = power
I = current
V = volts
R = resistance.

Using these formulas, you should be able to figure out how different load will effect power output.
 

Doodoo

Golden Member
Feb 14, 2000
1,423
0
76
K...simply put....ur amp puts out 50 x 2 at 4 ohms...or 100 x 2 at 2 ohms....or 200 x 1 at 4 ohms. It wont handle 2 ohm mono. So you can either hook up each speaker to each channel and each will get 50 watts. Or you can wire the two speakers in parallel and treat it as one big speaker and hook it up to one channel and each speaker will still see 50 watts. If you do that, you will still have one channel free.
 

Pastore

Diamond Member
Feb 9, 2000
9,728
0
76
Originally posted by: Doodoo
K...simply put....ur amp puts out 50 x 2 at 4 ohms...or 100 x 2 at 2 ohms....or 200 x 1 at 4 ohms. It wont handle 2 ohm mono. So you can either hook up each speaker to each channel and each will get 50 watts. Or you can wire the two speakers in parallel and treat it as one big speaker and hook it up to one channel and each speaker will still see 50 watts. If you do that, you will still have one channel free.

If you connect them in parallel you lose the left/right difference correct?