Cannot burn DVD+-R, but DVD-RW works

[LantisBo]

My burner is driving me insane.

I can't burn any DVD-R or DVD+R with success anymore. Worked before I updated my hardware and reinstalled Windows XP. I can burn DVD-RW without any problems. I can burn CDs.

I've tried the following without success:

Burn DVD-R in 4x speed.

Tried different media.

Uninstall Nero and tried a different burning application (CDBurnerXP). This application gives "device error 197120" when the burning is done.

Unplugged all IDE HDDs except the burner and made sure the burner is runnig in UDMA mode. Changed IDE cable.

It feels like I've tried everyting except the burned in another computer.

My question is really, can be the burner be broken? Feels like a software bug since it can burn everything except DVD+-R...

Relevant HW & SW info:
Windows XP
ASUS P5K
NEC ND-3551 v 2.03

 

[robisbell]

what hardware did you update exactly?
manufacturer and model of the hardware you updated.

 

[LantisBo]

I changed from a AMD system to Intel, so pretty much everything except the DVD burner and 2 HDDs.

 

[jae]

well this was really going to be suggestion... Try it another machine. You'll find out if the buner was anygood or maybe its bad hardware; RAM, motherboard, bad ide slot is all i can thunk of

 

[robisbell]

okay, when you did this did you do a reinstall of the OS?
what exactly hardware wise did you replace?