Can you remain friends with an ex? (YAGT)

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Lvis

Golden Member
Oct 10, 1999
1,747
0
76
Sure you can... I have mostly. It doesn't help though when you send them free samples of personal care items that you find in hot deals, though. :D They get upset when they pick up the mail and find Depends extra absorbants in the box... while chatting with their next door neighbor. ;)
 

zCypher

Diamond Member
Aug 18, 2002
6,115
171
116
Depends on the girl. Most people I know of end up hating each other after breaking up. I broke up with my ex and it was pretty damn close... almost lost each other completely, but we held in there and eventually our friendship built back up - and now we're back together.
 

bizmark

Banned
Feb 4, 2002
2,311
0
0
it really depends on how long you were friends before you were going out, and how long the relationship lasts. Also on whether both of you agree on the breakup.
 

Mustangrrl

Golden Member
Oct 10, 1999
1,448
0
0
I think it's totally possible. I don't talk to a couple of my exes just because they moved to different states and we didn't keep in touch, but if they lived nearby we would probably be great friends (because we were like family before we hooked up).

I don't talk to a couple more just because for some reason they are p!ssed at me -- I never break up ugly or dramatic, and I don't cheat, but I can just be honest when something isn't working out and they didn't appreciate that.

My last ex, Dudefish (for any of you long-timers here), he's like a brother to me. I see him every time I go back to Carson City. He's a fun person and an awesome friend.
~robyn
 

ChinamanatNCSU

Golden Member
Nov 15, 2001
1,160
0
0
Originally posted by: LyNx01
Originally posted by: BlinderBomber
Hell no. My ex-girlfriend is a demon from hell.

LOL! I generally end up not talking to them at all.

Yeah, I hardly talk to the the last girl I went out with, after I realized how many qualities I didn't like about her. When we have classes together, I just plain ignore her.
But, I'm really good friends with my first ex. It was a pretty amicable breakup and we were young and naive (as cliched as that sounds), so we still talk to each other a lot.

I guess what it boils down to is just how compatible you two originally were before you broke up...

my $0.02
 

Geekbabe

Moderator Emeritus<br>Elite Member
Oct 16, 1999
32,229
2,539
126
www.theshoppinqueen.com
What's the worst is the person who treats you like such total crap while you're still in the relationship... but who then won't accept that it is over when you finally end it. That situation is the total pits!
 

ChefJoe

Platinum Member
Jan 5, 2002
2,506
0
0
Different levels. With the girl who was sleeping with her ex while seeing me... not bloody likely.
 

linuxboy

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
2,577
6
76
No, friendship is never, ever possible with another human being. We are always, without exception, splitting off ourselves from the people we care about because we all hate ourselves.


Now the question is, did I mean that in earnest or is this some manipulation of reality? Or maybe both? :D


Hey Susan :)

Cheers ! :)
 

Moonbeam

Elite Member
Nov 24, 1999
74,827
6,782
126
Well well, linuxboy, you ask a question that is, I think, profoundly difficult to answer. But is such an important question that I wish I could easily answer it. The answer is bound up, I think intimately, with paradox. What is that state of a mind that holds and resolves a paradox. It is, I think a kind of slippery fluidity that is called forth perhaps. I should think a certain resignation might be in order, the surrender to one implication before the appearance of another. But anyway, what can I say about your question?

We are told by psychologists that we have an unconscious, that we are motivated by things of which we are unconscious. They tell us that the reason we are unconscious of our motivations is because we don't like to think of ourselves as being motivated by those feelings. Don't be selfish, don't be angry, don't be jealous, don't hate, don't feel what you feel, you dirty little scum ball. So we become nice little obedient cheerful thrifty brave clean and reverent little children. meanwhile the Monster of the Id goes underground and we only see him in sci-fi and horror films, or in the other party, where we project him. Now half the paradox revolves around the fact, one, that there was nothing wrong with us in the first place, and two, that that trustworthy nice little thing we pretend to be is also ok in his or her own way. In short we are nice worthwhile valuable people in all kinds of wonderful ways, but we became that way by paying a horrible price. We locked a portion of ourselves in a deep hole and forgot them.

So yes we can love and love madly. We have a breathing tube back to our real selves that keeps us alive. But what is the nature of that love. So much of it is based on the feeling that finally and at last somebody is saying what I always wanted to hear, that I'm ok, that I can be loved. Thank God and bless the heavens. But when that love turns sour, when we test and test to see if we are really really loved, because we feel down deep, still that ancient self hate, and when we finally prove our suspicions that we are unlovable by making sure we are completely impossible, then out goes the love and in comes that old old hate. The one who made our day is now a piece of sh!t.

In life we all have varying aptitudes at managing our selves. Some are better at loving than others. But the true love, the unconditional love, the mystic love that bursts onto the scene so rarely, but occasionally, that is a love, I think, that comes of the love of self. It springs from a mind that has united the consciousness in full consciousness. Such a mind, would you not say, might be united and whole and filled with light.

I know it's not much of an answer, because it depends so heavily, I think, on what a person may have experienced of his own unconscious, but it's about the best I can do briefly.
 

linuxboy

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
2,577
6
76
I know it's not much of an answer, because it depends so heavily, I think, on what a person may have experienced of his own unconscious, but it's about the best I can do briefly.

And yet, all of that has similarity in the process and realizations, if not the experiences due to similar backgrounds.

Thank you MB, paradoxical froth is one of my most enjoyable becomings.


Cheers ! :)
 

lilFajita

Golden Member
Aug 2, 2002
1,313
0
0
I think that it is really hard to stay friends with an ex when one person was resistant to the breakup, which I imagine is more often the case that not. The only time that I see that it can somewhat work is when you give each other ALOT of distance initially, and then redevelop a new type of relationship. The danger in this of course, is that you lose any basis for friendship: meaning, you move on, and then you kind of forget why you want to keep in touch. One of my exs is suppose to be a friend, but we really hardly talk and certainly not about anything significant. In the end, I don't have enough time to maintain a friendship with him when I am just fake and superficial. I think that's hard to avoid.

It depends on the type of breakup, the time that you invested, and how tied you guys are to each other (same friends circle, etc.) as well. Those factors can motivate you to try harder.

Its really rough though :(
 

eakers

Lifer
Aug 14, 2000
12,169
2
0
you don't have to hate the person but i think if you remain "best friends" with your ex you aren't really taking time to heal and get over eachother.
 

EvilYoda

Lifer
Apr 1, 2001
21,198
9
81
<sigh> Damn you people and your thread topics:

I'm in the midst of dealing with a breakup after 2.5 years, and we thought we would be friends, but I can't seem to do it right now...I can still only talk to her online, every few days. So much history, and so many complications in the recent past.....

Sucks. And sucks even more than by me not being there, she's only getting closer with another guy.
 

SirFshAlot

Elite Member
Apr 11, 2000
2,887
0
0
I am friendly with EVERY single person that I ever chose to like enough at the time to date or see.

If they were good enough to spend my time with then, then they are good enough to deserve my present friendship.

My EXwife, FiddleDD, and I are best friends now, and we went through some really really crazy shi......crap.

My daughter's mother and I are also good friends, even after I took her to court and won custody of our daughter.


Hatred is very unhealthy.
 

NikPreviousAcct

No Lifer
Aug 15, 2000
52,763
1
0
Just like most of you have said, it depends on both people. If Chelsea and I split up a second time, we now know that the two of us would not be able to be friends. I wouldn't be able to hang around with her family, either. Last time that happened, I got really really really bitter, dark, depressed, and angry at life. Yeah, all you joker mothereffers can keep your mouth shut. I'm still angry and bitter, but not nearly as much as I was then. Just about everything made me snap and go apesh|t. Seeing her or her family just multiplied those feelings of hurt to the point that I couldn't handle. Thinking about her, which was pretty much a lot of the time at first, did the same thing. With the attitude that I had, I'm amazed that I didn't do something stupid that I'd regret later.

However, I'm convinced that there are people out there who think "ya know, this level of relationship just isn't for us" and logically put the relationship aside for friendship, and are still close friends. I know a few couples who have done so. So I voted yes.

nik
 

Lonyo

Lifer
Aug 10, 2002
21,938
6
81
Originally posted by: EvilYoda
<sigh> Damn you people and your thread topics:

I'm in the midst of dealing with a breakup after 2.5 years, and we thought we would be friends, but I can't seem to do it right now...I can still only talk to her online, every few days. So much history, and so many complications in the recent past.....

Sucks. And sucks even more than by me not being there, she's only getting closer with another guy.


Yeah, I know what you mean about getting closer with another guy. My ex is gettin gclose to my best frind, cos she fancies him, but he doesn't reciprocate. Doesn't make it easier though :(

Just about everything made me snap and go apesh|t. Seeing her or her family just multiplied those feelings of hurt to the point that I couldn't handle. Thinking about her, which was pretty much a lot of the time at first, did the same thing. With the attitude that I had, I'm amazed that I didn't do something stupid that I'd regret later.

I can totally relate to that as well, but then again, I was always prone to snap, no it's just been made worse sometimes. Everytime I start to talk to her, even if I've been in the best mood of my life, I just go downhill totally whenever she's near/online :/.

Man relationships can suck if they don't work :(.