Can you be a hero for doing your job?

[Mackie2k]

Now I have a lot of respect for Police, Firefighters and Military people......so let's get that out of the way.

Inspired by the Pilot who landed the plane in the river......which was totally bad ass..

Why is he a hero? Why is a firefighter who ran into the WTC on 9/11 a hero?

If you are paid to do it, you aren't a hero.

Discuss.

 

[James Bond]

Depends what you call a hero I guess

It would be much easier for me to be the villain.

 

[TallBill]

Originally posted by: Mackie2k
Now I have a lot of respect for Police, Firefighters and Military people......so let's get that out of the way.

Inspired by the Pilot who landed the plane in the river......which was totally bad ass..

Why is he a hero? Why is a firefighter who ran into the WTC on 9/11 a hero?

If you are paid to do it, you aren't a hero.

Discuss.

You are not a hero.

 

[meltdown75]

I think you can still be a hero in those professions, because some of them (pardon the cliche) go above and beyond the call of duty. I mean, to me, it sort of works the same way that military heroes emerge. They are all expected to be out there fighting in the trenches, but some of them do a lot more than others and should be recognized.

 

[Crono]

A hero is someone who helps others without the expectation of reward, whether it is payment or recognition.

 

[CRXican]

Pilot is not a hero, he just did his job well.

 

[Mackie2k]

Originally posted by: TallBill

Originally posted by: Mackie2k
Now I have a lot of respect for Police, Firefighters and Military people......so let's get that out of the way.

Inspired by the Pilot who landed the plane in the river......which was totally bad ass..

Why is he a hero? Why is a firefighter who ran into the WTC on 9/11 a hero?

If you are paid to do it, you aren't a hero.

Discuss.

You are not a hero.

What? I saved someone's data at a corporate office the other day, I didn't have to. I'm a hero.

 

[Crono]

Originally posted by: Mackie2k

Originally posted by: TallBill

Originally posted by: Mackie2k
Now I have a lot of respect for Police, Firefighters and Military people......so let's get that out of the way.

Inspired by the Pilot who landed the plane in the river......which was totally bad ass..

Why is he a hero? Why is a firefighter who ran into the WTC on 9/11 a hero?

If you are paid to do it, you aren't a hero.

Discuss.

You are not a hero.

What? I saved someone's data at a corporate office the other day, I didn't have to. I'm a hero.

Did you do it to receive recognition or to brag about it? If so, you're not a hero.

 

[MotF Bane]

Mackie2k, in saving the data, did you save the person's life, and was your own life at risk? No. Add to this...

Originally posted by: Crono
A hero is someone who helps others without the expectation of reward, whether it is payment or recognition.

/thread

 

[Lonyo]

He's a hero because he pulled it off and no one died. And it's not something that is a normal duty, crash landings never are, so it's seen as heroic because it was above and beyond the norm and he managed to have no one die.

 

[amdhunter]

Originally posted by: Mackie2k
Now I have a lot of respect for Police, Firefighters and Military people......so let's get that out of the way.

Inspired by the Pilot who landed the plane in the river......which was totally bad ass..

Why is he a hero? Why is a firefighter who ran into the WTC on 9/11 a hero?

If you are paid to do it, you aren't a hero.

Discuss.

Pilot who made a good decision which saved a bunch of lives = hero.
Firefighter who helped people get out of a falling building on time = hero.

Pilots who crashed, Firefighters who got crushed, well not so much...

 

[destrekor]

Originally posted by: meltdown75
I think you can still be a hero in those professions, because some of them (pardon the cliche) go above and beyond the call of duty. I mean, to me, it sort of works the same way that military heroes emerge. They are all expected to be out there fighting in the trenches, but some of them do a lot more than others and should be recognized.

This.

Some people just try harder at doing everything they possibly can in a situation. A pilot with great skill can land a damaged bird anywhere. A fireman that goes into a building ready to collapse and is the first one to do it has risen above what is expected of him.

But a profession like fire fighters tends to be full of more potential heros than any other, because there duty is to not let anyone burn in a building on fire. Many will run through much fire to get to someone.

 

[SMOGZINN]

Originally posted by: Mackie2k
Now I have a lot of respect for Police, Firefighters and Military people......so let's get that out of the way.

Inspired by the Pilot who landed the plane in the river......which was totally bad ass..

Why is he a hero? Why is a firefighter who ran into the WTC on 9/11 a hero?

If you are paid to do it, you aren't a hero.

Discuss.

A hero is anyone whose story can sell more advertising while still being positive and uplifting.

 

[Mackie2k]

Originally posted by: MotF Bane
Mackie2k, in saving the data, did you save the person's life, and was your own life at risk? No. Add to this...

Originally posted by: Crono
A hero is someone who helps others without the expectation of reward, whether it is payment or recognition.

/thread

Actually the person said "Wow you saved my life, thanks!!!"

So, I guess I'm a hero. Plus I wasn't expecting reward, I just did it because I'm an amazing person.

Guess I'm a hero.

 

[Crono]

Originally posted by: Lonyo
He's a hero because he pulled it off and no one died. And it's not something that is a normal duty, crash landings never are, so it's seen as heroic because it was above and beyond the norm and he managed to have no one die.

Doing something legendary in the line of duty does not make you a hero. Pilots are trained, and it is their duty, to do their best to safely land the plane. He couldn't have bailed from the plane and said, "hey, not my job!". What he did was commendable, and certainly took a lot of skill, quick thinking, etc., but it wasn't heroic.

 

[meltdown75]

Originally posted by: Crono

Originally posted by: Lonyo
He's a hero because he pulled it off and no one died. And it's not something that is a normal duty, crash landings never are, so it's seen as heroic because it was above and beyond the norm and he managed to have no one die.

Doing something legendary in the line of duty does not make you a hero. Pilots are trained, and it is their duty, to do their best to safely land the plane. He couldn't have bailed from the plane and said, "hey, not my job!". What he did was commendable, and certainly took a lot of skill, quick thinking, etc., but it wasn't heroic.

:laugh: @ the imagery

 

[Jeeebus]

Requirements for a hero:

He's gotta be strong
And he's gotta be fast
And he's gotta be fresh from the fight

I need a hero!

 

[Mackie2k]

Originally posted by: destrekor

Originally posted by: meltdown75
I think you can still be a hero in those professions, because some of them (pardon the cliche) go above and beyond the call of duty. I mean, to me, it sort of works the same way that military heroes emerge. They are all expected to be out there fighting in the trenches, but some of them do a lot more than others and should be recognized.

This.

Some people just try harder at doing everything they possibly can in a situation. A pilot with great skill can land a damaged bird anywhere. A fireman that goes into a building ready to collapse and is the first one to do it has risen above what is expected of him.

But a profession like fire fighters tends to be full of more potential heros than any other, because there duty is to not let anyone burn in a building on fire. Many will run through much fire to get to someone.

Then by default they cannot be hero's, as their job expectation is for them to live and potentially die in dangerious situations.

A firefighters job is to run into a building and save people. that's not above and beyond the job of a firefighter, that's a core skill.

 

[meltdown75]

Originally posted by: Mackie2k

Originally posted by: destrekor

Originally posted by: meltdown75
I think you can still be a hero in those professions, because some of them (pardon the cliche) go above and beyond the call of duty. I mean, to me, it sort of works the same way that military heroes emerge. They are all expected to be out there fighting in the trenches, but some of them do a lot more than others and should be recognized.

This.

Some people just try harder at doing everything they possibly can in a situation. A pilot with great skill can land a damaged bird anywhere. A fireman that goes into a building ready to collapse and is the first one to do it has risen above what is expected of him.

But a profession like fire fighters tends to be full of more potential heros than any other, because there duty is to not let anyone burn in a building on fire. Many will run through much fire to get to someone.

Then by default they cannot be hero's, as their job expectation is for them to live and potentially die in dangerious situations.

A firefighters job is to run into a building and save people. that's not above and beyond the job of a firefighter, that's a core skill.

So you don't think you should get a troll hero award for suggesting that 911 firefighters and paramedics aren't heroes (the word can be pluralized, FYI)? I think you're doing fantastic trolling; I for one recommend you for the Hero Troll award....

 

[CRXican]

Originally posted by: Crono

Originally posted by: Lonyo
He's a hero because he pulled it off and no one died. And it's not something that is a normal duty, crash landings never are, so it's seen as heroic because it was above and beyond the norm and he managed to have no one die.

Doing something legendary in the line of duty does not make you a hero. Pilots are trained, and it is their duty, to do their best to safely land the plane. He couldn't have bailed from the plane and said, "hey, not my job!". What he did was commendable, and certainly took a lot of skill, quick thinking, etc., but it wasn't heroic.

I saw the 60 minutes interview and when asked if he was thinking about the passengers he said no. All he thought about was landing the plane.

He wanted to save his own ass.

 

[amdhunter]

Originally posted by: Jeeebus
Requirements for a hero:

He's gotta be strong
And he's gotta be fast
And he's gotta be fresh from the fight

I need a hero!

:music:
And they say that a hero can save us.
Im not gonna stand here and wait.
I'll hold onto the wings of the eagles.
Watch as we all fly away.
:music:

 

[hiromizu]

You have to learn to accept the exceptions as some jobs are more special than others which makes you more important than others. Flying is an extraordinary job. IT is not. It's THAT simple.

 

[KB]

Everyones a Hero in their own way! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5yGeroywBuo

I would agree with you if you are trained to do a job and you do it, you aren't a hero. You did your job well.
The hero to me is the engineer who created the lock-down button on the plane that prevented the plane from taking water and sinking. Props to him and his team.

 

[Mackie2k]

Originally posted by: meltdown75

Originally posted by: Mackie2k

Originally posted by: destrekor

Originally posted by: meltdown75
I think you can still be a hero in those professions, because some of them (pardon the cliche) go above and beyond the call of duty. I mean, to me, it sort of works the same way that military heroes emerge. They are all expected to be out there fighting in the trenches, but some of them do a lot more than others and should be recognized.

This.

Some people just try harder at doing everything they possibly can in a situation. A pilot with great skill can land a damaged bird anywhere. A fireman that goes into a building ready to collapse and is the first one to do it has risen above what is expected of him.

But a profession like fire fighters tends to be full of more potential heros than any other, because there duty is to not let anyone burn in a building on fire. Many will run through much fire to get to someone.

Then by default they cannot be hero's, as their job expectation is for them to live and potentially die in dangerious situations.

A firefighters job is to run into a building and save people. that's not above and beyond the job of a firefighter, that's a core skill.

So you don't think you should get a troll hero award for suggesting that 911 firefighters and paramedics aren't heroes (the word can be pluralized, FYI)? I think you're doing fantastic trolling; I for one recommend you for the Hero Troll award....

I'm not trolling, I'm just tired of hearing everyone being called a hero. There are true hero's in this world and then just people doing their jobs and something bad happens. It's sad, it's tragic....but I don't think that automatically makes them a hero.

A Real Hero? The people on flight 93.

 

[effowe]

You should become An Hero.