"Let's say you are white, and so are your parents, but all your ancestors including your parents were born and raised in Africa for many generations back?"
Pics please! We only judge by appearance, since maybe some major tanning happened or some evolution. . . . 😉 Hehehe! I'm messing with you.
Really, it depends upon your definition of "African American". If you define "African American" as an ethnicity or race, then no the person you described isn't African-American. If on the other hand you define "African American" as a nationality, the person could be African-American, but not if she's still in South Africa (or Botswana or Zimbabwe or Kenya . . . you name it). 😉