My point: The thread topic of this thread should not be allowed. At least not without some pretty drastic justification, if at all.
Yet, the forum has allowed just that. An OT post, saying 'you are an asshole' to be posted, in a quote agreeing with the statement, that was reported, yet nothing was done.
The forum is better when it has some minimum civility - as per the change to the P&N forum against such behavior that has been at the top of the forum for months, "The rules for the P & N subforum have been updated to prohibit "ad hominem" or personal attacks against other posters. "
When people can discuss things that are sometimes sharing personal info, without a hateful, insulting environment. It doesn't mean no criticism, but the criticism should be based on some standards.
'You are an asshole' without that justification, at least, does not meet that standard. To a moderator's credit, that was recognized when the original post was deleted after being reported.
But, then, a (presumably different) moderator quoted the deleted post with their comment of "Quoted for truth!". That was reported, days ago, with no action to the post or response. Ask yourself how you feel when you see this thread's topic. Now, how would you like to see it aimed at you personally, in response to your post. Perhaps over and over. Not seeming like a positive thing? Because it's not. So, don't allow the behavior by other posters. Is this behavior allowed by moderators only?
Could that phrase ever be justified? That's a matter of debate. If someone posted some despicable behavior - egregious piracy, stealing, knowingly going around with covid trying to infect people, any number of such things - perhaps. But not simply 'I felt like saying it because I don't like that you are reporting a bad customer service experience'.
If those are going to be the standards, then it degrades this forum, and makes a lot of the usefulness for discussing issues in a better environment not so possible. I'd post less, missing a previously good, favorite forum, and presumably others might as well, in a cesspool instead of a decent forum. And that choice might just justify the thread title. And it would be just fine, right? Obviously, the thread title is not one I'd normally post. But the actions so far make it appropriate for this purpose.
Whatever the response, this thread can be deleted. The post referenced here is #115 in this thread: https://forums.anandtech.com/threads/more-bad-amazon-stuff.2585980/page-5#post-40315104
Yet, the forum has allowed just that. An OT post, saying 'you are an asshole' to be posted, in a quote agreeing with the statement, that was reported, yet nothing was done.
The forum is better when it has some minimum civility - as per the change to the P&N forum against such behavior that has been at the top of the forum for months, "The rules for the P & N subforum have been updated to prohibit "ad hominem" or personal attacks against other posters. "
When people can discuss things that are sometimes sharing personal info, without a hateful, insulting environment. It doesn't mean no criticism, but the criticism should be based on some standards.
'You are an asshole' without that justification, at least, does not meet that standard. To a moderator's credit, that was recognized when the original post was deleted after being reported.
But, then, a (presumably different) moderator quoted the deleted post with their comment of "Quoted for truth!". That was reported, days ago, with no action to the post or response. Ask yourself how you feel when you see this thread's topic. Now, how would you like to see it aimed at you personally, in response to your post. Perhaps over and over. Not seeming like a positive thing? Because it's not. So, don't allow the behavior by other posters. Is this behavior allowed by moderators only?
Could that phrase ever be justified? That's a matter of debate. If someone posted some despicable behavior - egregious piracy, stealing, knowingly going around with covid trying to infect people, any number of such things - perhaps. But not simply 'I felt like saying it because I don't like that you are reporting a bad customer service experience'.
If those are going to be the standards, then it degrades this forum, and makes a lot of the usefulness for discussing issues in a better environment not so possible. I'd post less, missing a previously good, favorite forum, and presumably others might as well, in a cesspool instead of a decent forum. And that choice might just justify the thread title. And it would be just fine, right? Obviously, the thread title is not one I'd normally post. But the actions so far make it appropriate for this purpose.
Whatever the response, this thread can be deleted. The post referenced here is #115 in this thread: https://forums.anandtech.com/threads/more-bad-amazon-stuff.2585980/page-5#post-40315104