Originally posted by: GuybrushThreepwood
Originally posted by: ziplux
Originally posted by: lirion
A similar question would be to ask the non believers what it would take to convince them that there is a god/higher power. Knowing that would be as valuable as knowing why the believer believes.
I would need compelling scientific evidence. Or I would need to see the higher power with my own eyes.
everyone says the same thing.
Some people get a sign and some people don't. I can't explain it, so don't ask me why.
But the whole point of faith is that you believe even though you don't see the physical, tangible evidence.
ziplux if you did receive a sign from God, would you be converted on the spot?
Ya, everyone bases it on faith. In other words, they believe that a book (the bible) is telling the truth without any empirical evidence. Yet people are skeptical of everything else.
If I told you that my friend witnessed an alien mothership land in his backyard, no one would believe me. (well practically no one). They would tell me that I'm either lying, my friend is lying, my friend was hallucinating, or generally just believe that the story was false. Why? The best reasons I can think of are 1) alien motherships landing in people's backyard is basically an unheard of event (you judge a story based on what you already know to be true), and 2) the reliability of the source is questionable.
The bible was written a very very long time ago, with additions from countless sources, describing events that are basically unheard of in our modern day. The text has traveled through many lands, and shows origins from many cultures, and has gone through numerous revisions. So the same reasons for rejecting my alien mothership story is present in christianity. 1) the bible describes unheard of events in our modern lives, and 2) the reliability of the source is questionable. Yet, people have faith that the bible is telling the truth, but have no faith that I'm telling the truth. Is it because I (as a person) am tangible and all too common, and therefore (ironically) not worthy of other's faith? Or is it because the alien mothership story offers no possible benefit, while the bible offers eternal salvation? I'm not really sure.
If you read all that... and the discussion continues, then I'll post some other fun religion questions I have.
dfi