Buy a Dell or Build My Own System?

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

bluemax

Diamond Member
Apr 28, 2000
7,182
0
0
If the time ever came when you felt you absolutely HAD to change out the motherboard, just change out the power supply at the same time. I'll say this again because I think it got missed the first couple times....

THE ONLY THING "PROPRIETARY" ABOUT DELL IS THE POWER PLUG ON THE MOTHERBOARD AND THE POWER SUPPLY OUTPUT PLUG GOING INTO THE MOBO.

The cases are ***EASY*** to get into and out of, by far the easiest I've ever owned! A button on top and bottom, press and it butterflies open giving you supremely easy access to everything with LOTS of room to move around. It's a good design - anyone who tells you otherwise has simply never owned one, or never actually opened it up.

The old Dell machine in the P2-P3 era were the same old boring, straight ATX tower most people on here use - you certainly wouldn't call THAT proprietary either. The new design is purely ATX and will take a different motherboard and a different power supply with NO hassles at all with the SINGLE exception of if you want to use DELL motherboard with 3rd party Power Supply or vice-versa. And that'll STILL work if you just use a cheap adapter plug. You WILL NOT need to replace the Dell power supply. Sure it may not be 752.8 Watts of output but you WILL NOT NEED IT either... Users have been able to load up their machines to the hilt with NO issues. You can BUY it right from Dell loaded with Radeon 9800 Pro's, twin big/fast hard drives, twin optical drives and more... You really think the PS will be a problem? Not a chance. :)

Anyone who says "Dell sucks" simply has never spent time with one.

It it a better deal than building yourself? Quite possibly, yes.
If you already have a LEGAL OS and all the software you want, RAM and/or HDD... well then you're only doing a partial upgrade and don't need a whole system do you? :) Balance how much it'll cost to get all your parts from NewEgg, the time it'll take to put them together, the time spent FIXING any issues that happen, RMA costs for failed products, shipping for returns, etc... all of a sudden Dell looks all the more attractive. It's all covered, all from one place. Once the machine is paid for, that's it. No more nasty surprises.
 

pelikan

Diamond Member
Dec 28, 2002
3,118
0
76
I think you need to go within and consider whether you want to build your own system or not. What do you really want?
 

ElFenix

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Mar 20, 2000
102,393
8,552
126
Originally posted by: AgaBooga
Originally posted by: ElFenix
Originally posted by: AgaBooga
Originally posted by: AgaBooga
While we're on the topic, do the motherboards and everything that come with Dells use their own proprietary sockets and things because personally, I don't like the Dell case and maybe somewher ein the future, I'll change it to a case I like.

What about that though?

by proprietary sockets what do you mean? it does use an odd power supply plug layout, but you can get an adpater for that. they use a ribbon cable for the front panel connector but theres no standard for that and a few motherboards actually come with that layout anyway. thats about it.

So I'd still be able to later down the road take the parts out and put it in another case? I wouldn't mind getting a new power supply for it either.

its the exact same pci slots and ide connectors and agp slot and socket 478 or whatever number intel is on now, yes.
 

ElFenix

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Mar 20, 2000
102,393
8,552
126
Originally posted by: rob123171
Two Words....

Dell Blows!

wow, that really contributed to the discussion
rolleye.gif
 
Jun 8, 2003
25
0
0
I think you need to decide. If you want the best for your dollar, go with the Dell. If you want to have a little bit more flexibility, go with the homeade system.
 

snidy1

Golden Member
Mar 17, 2003
1,285
0
0
Decide if you want a guaranteed piece of crap (Dell) or if you want your own custom made machine that you can be proud of.
 

bluemax

Diamond Member
Apr 28, 2000
7,182
0
0
Originally posted by: snidy1
Decide if you want a guaranteed piece of crap (Dell) or if you want your own custom made machine that you can be proud of.

See my posts in this thread, search for the word "clueless". :frown:
 

sellmen

Senior member
May 4, 2003
459
0
0
Someone here posted that you can't get a computer to look as good as a Dell...that is utterly rediculous. You have essential one case design choice at Dell. If you like it...great. If you want a white case, or a aluminum coolermasters type case, a case with a window, or a silver case with black drives, you're out of luck. Not everyone wants an all black system; building yourself, you can choose which ever case you want, to suit your own preference.

If you get a Dell w/ a one-year warranty, the deals are very good, as shown. However, once you get up to a three year warranty from Dell, that prices difference disappears. If you build your own, you can get pretty much every component with a three year or lifetime warranty. Many hard drives have three years, antec power supplies have three years, RAM is usually lifetime, retail CPU's have three years, videcards are either 1 year, three year, or lifetime, depending on brand, many motherboards have three years. In order to compare a well-built custom PC and a Dell, you have to add that three year warranty, which pretty much negates any cost difference.

As far as technical support...Dell has a whopping 1.94 / 10 score for technical support on resellerratings.com, and 3.75 /10 for return and replacement. Newegg, Crucial, Antec, or Western Digital are far better at providing warranty service.

The only reason I could see getting a Dell, is if you didn't care about warranty service, so you got a cheap one with a 1-year warranty and took your chances.
 

herkulease

Diamond Member
Jul 6, 2001
3,923
0
0
All add if you know what your doing and there's a good sale then go the build own. Hell if you know what your doing you can take the dell too.

But as of right now Dell has some good sales.

I decided to get a dell instead of building my own. For 1 thing I'm lazy as of late, two there's hasn't been a good sale at fry's.

So if you're lazy get a dell.

If you have lots of free time, there's a good sale then by all means build on your own.
 

Salvador

Diamond Member
May 19, 2001
7,058
0
71
Come on.. Don't you want to say to your buds, "Dude.. I'm gettin' a Dell!"? I think that's worth it alone.

Sal
 

AgaBoogaBoo

Lifer
Feb 16, 2003
26,108
5
81
Originally posted by: Salvador
Come on.. Don't you want to say to your buds, "Dude.. I'm gettin' a Dell!"? I think that's worth it alone.

Sal

I'd rather say "Dude... I built it on my own," really, I want to get whatever gives me the best deal. Prices have dropped and the components I've chosen are different now so I think I'll build my own, there isn't any tax on it either! So I save tax and shipping for the most part, saving nearly a $100, and if I really want, add like $60 more to that and get a DVD burner at newegg!
 
Jun 8, 2003
25
0
0