That's what most people want here.
With all due respect Charles, that's not true. Yes, the majority of P&Ners voted to rescind Idontcare's trial of a no-insults rule. That was in part because the rule was capriciously enforced, in part because a large segment of P&N (myself included) never felt insults were the real problem here, and in part simply because the rule never really delivered on its promises. Yes, overt insults were down, but the noise level was at least as bad as before thanks to a handful of prolific misfits dedicated to being as disruptive as possible while remaining just barely, arguably, within the lines. Some are still quite active here, with predictable results.
In spite of rejecting the no-insults rule, however, the plurality of P&N (not sure if it was a majority) DID still want moderation for content, specifically including "
thread-crapping, thread-derailment, off-topic posting, trolling, the intentional posting of logical fallacies or misinformation." That remains on the record as the first rule in P&N, yet it appears to be very rarely enforced. It seems to me that with the rejection of the no-insults rule, management here threw up its hands and said, "Screw it, we tried. Give them the cesspool they want."
To be clear, I can't blame moderators for that. They are volunteers, and trying to moderate this place has to be one of the most thankless jobs on the face of the planet. Everything you do to try to improve quality and reduce disruption will be immediately challenged by one half of a small, but vocal group of perpetual crybabies (as you saw in DC). This is especially true for trying to moderate content, which is inherently subjective. Who needs that hassle?
In short, the current P&N cesspool is not what most people
wanted. Sadly, it appears to be the best we will get given current circumstances.
And it would seem Anand does too, or he'd move the place in a different direction.
I doubt that's what he wants. To whatever extent it's on his radar at all, I imagine it's what he's resigned himself to accepting.