Blog rant: "I Hate Todays Smartphones."

Page 8 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Do you agree with his rant?

  • Yes, I fully agree.

  • No, I fully disagree.

  • Yes, but I also think both the Nexus 5 and Moto X are too big.

  • Yes, but I think Steve Jobs originally had it right. 3.5" or nothing


Results are only viewable after voting.

alkemyst

No Lifer
Feb 13, 2001
83,769
19
81
get ready for disappointment then.

Not sure what you mean.

Which is why I am going with iPhone 5S right now rather than saving my upgrades for the next generation.

I just replaced the last iPhone 4 we had. Mostly because the user thought they really needed 64GB...now they are getting a 16GB 5S. Their total memory space used was like 12GB.

I have two 4S to get rid off. I have a 5 and another person has a 5. I have one more free upgrade right now. In six months, another upgrade is due...then six months later 2 more free ones pop up.

By next month we will be a family of 2 iPhone 5S, 2 iPhone 5's and one 4S (for an 11 year old).

I am OK with it.
 

gorcorps

aka Brandon
Jul 18, 2004
30,739
454
126
Not sure what you mean.

Which is why I am going with iPhone 5S right now rather than saving my upgrades for the next generation.

I just replaced the last iPhone 4 we had. Mostly because the user thought they really needed 64GB...now they are getting a 16GB 5S. Their total memory space used was like 12GB.

I have two 4S to get rid off. I have a 5 and another person has a 5. I have one more free upgrade right now. In six months, another upgrade is due...then six months later 2 more free ones pop up.

By next month we will be a family of 2 iPhone 5S, 2 iPhone 5's and one 4S (for an 11 year old).

I am OK with it.

Pretty sure he means, get ready for disappointment because rumors are the iPhone is getting bigger. If you like that size this might be the last time you see it.
 

Brian Stirling

Diamond Member
Feb 7, 2010
3,964
2
0
I have to believe Apple will offer at least two different sized phones with the release of the iP6. I think we can safely assume they will have a 5" class phone and I suspect they will continue to offer a 4" class phone for the foreseeable future. If they do, and they'd be dumb if they didn't, the interesting question is will both be similar spec phones. I suspect not and the small phone crowd will be wringing there hands over it. There small hands!


Brian
 

alexeus

Member
Apr 28, 2014
29
0
0
Imo bigger it's better, but it has its limits. I won't walk around with a backpack in order to take my phone with me. I think things are almost at the limit now, but there's still room for improvements.
 

poofyhairguy

Lifer
Nov 20, 2005
14,612
318
126
I have to believe Apple will offer at least two different sized phones with the release of the iP6. I think we can safely assume they will have a 5" class phone and I suspect they will continue to offer a 4" class phone for the foreseeable future. If they do, and they'd be dumb if they didn't, the interesting question is will both be similar spec phones. I suspect not and the small phone crowd will be wringing there hands over it. There small hands!


Brian

I think that is completely reasonable given their previous actions. In fact I think for the next year two of the three lineups will be 4 inches.

We will see an updated 5C for their midrange and the old 5C will drop to the low range. In fact I can see the original 5C becoming the first universal "free with contract" iPhone given its low build costs.

What I DON'T think we will see is any 4 inch model that will have a cutting edge (aka equal to the 5 incher) SoC. Apple is going to make size a reason to pay for the flagship.
 

bearxor

Diamond Member
Jul 8, 2001
6,605
3
81
I don't think we'll see an updated 5C. I think we'll get the same thing we get from Apple every year. 8GB iPhone 5C free, 16-32Gb iPhone 5S for $200-300 and the 16-64GB iPhone 6 for $200-400.
 

poofyhairguy

Lifer
Nov 20, 2005
14,612
318
126
I don't think we'll see an updated 5C. I think we'll get the same thing we get from Apple every year. 8GB iPhone 5C free, 16-32Gb iPhone 5S for $200-300 and the 16-64GB iPhone 6 for $200-400.

The only reason I don't agree is because Apple so far has not made a new phone design for one generation. I think that from the start the 5C was meant to hold the guts of the 5S.

In fact I don't think Apple will ever again give consumers premium design for anything but the flagship going forward. I think the C's are here to stay.

So this year the 5S will turn into the 5CS (or whatever they call it) and we will get a new premium build 6 with a larger screen.

Then next year the 5CS will become the base model and a new plastic 6C will launch at the midrange with 6's guts wrapped in plastic. Then we will see a new 6S with the same body as the 6 but a new SoC.

Rinse and repeat.

I admit there could be an exception this year if only because the larger 6 will seem obviously premium compared to the 5S, but I would be really surprised if the 5S in its current form is still being sold at the end of the year.
 

bearxor

Diamond Member
Jul 8, 2001
6,605
3
81
I'm going with an exception this year to focus on cost savings and to try to generate interest in a mid-tier model with different colors.
 

gorcorps

aka Brandon
Jul 18, 2004
30,739
454
126
The only reason I don't agree is because Apple so far has not made a new phone design for one generation. I think that from the start the 5C was meant to hold the guts of the 5S.

In fact I don't think Apple will ever again give consumers premium design for anything but the flagship going forward. I think the C's are here to stay.

So this year the 5S will turn into the 5CS (or whatever they call it) and we will get a new premium build 6 with a larger screen.

Then next year the 5CS will become the base model and a new plastic 6C will launch at the midrange with 6's guts wrapped in plastic. Then we will see a new 6S with the same body as the 6 but a new SoC.

Rinse and repeat.

I admit there could be an exception this year if only because the larger 6 will seem obviously premium compared to the 5S, but I would be really surprised if the 5S in its current form is still being sold at the end of the year.

They aren't going to release a new 'c' version every year. We'll either see two years of the 5c, or there will be a 6c this year and there won't be one during the '6s' year. There's no reason to develop a separate cheap version every year.
 

poofyhairguy

Lifer
Nov 20, 2005
14,612
318
126
They aren't going to release a new 'c' version every year. We'll either see two years of the 5c, or there will be a 6c this year and there won't be one during the '6s' year. There's no reason to develop a separate cheap version every year.

They won't be developing a new C version every year from scratch. This year's C will use the same form factor as last years, just with new S guts. Just like every flagship model they have made, I expect them to milk each C design for two generations.

I guess we'll know soon enough...